Mr Salles Teaches English

macbeth essay about kingship

Kingship in Macbeth

(a grade 8 essay, improved to grade 9).

macbeth essay about kingship

Hi again Mr Salles - I hope you are well,

Here is an essay I have written on the theme of kingship, tyranny and natural order.

If you have a spare few minutes, please let me know what mark this would get and how I can improve it to get full marks :)

Shakespeare cleverly crafts the themes of kingship/tyranny/natural order through the devolution of Macbeth. By contrasting morality and corruption within Macbeth and Banquo, Shakespeare cautions against ambition and associates it with the supernatural - a very disturbing idea for the contemporary audience, contributing to Shakespeare’s overall purpose of trying to flatter King James I and warn the nobility against rebellion.

Shakespeare constructs Banquo as a foil to Macbeth by illustrating their contrasting reactions to the same evil force - the supernatural and temptation. Banquo represents the route that Macbeth chose not to take: the path where ambition does not lead to betrayal and murder. Thus, it is Banquo’s ghost, rather than Duncan’s, that haunts Macbeth and conveys to the contemporary audience that restraint will lead to a fruition of power as Banquo’s lineage stays on the throne for the longest.

The witches’ equivocation: “ Lesser than Macbeth, and greater ” paradoxically suggests the drastic difference between Banquo and Macbeth, foreshadowing character development as the witches' prophecies come true. Banquo will never be king, but he does father a line of kings. Macbeth, on the other hand, will become the King of Scotland which is commendable in terms of the Divine Order; Macbeth’s reign of power will be one of selfishness and greed as he fulfils his cruel desire for power, eliminating all obstacles that stand in the way of his kingship.

As a result, Macbeth holds the shorter end of the stick in this paradox, facing paranoia, insomnia, guilt, and a tragic demise, therefore proving its accuracy. Here, Shakespeare is flattering King James I, as he was descendant of Banquo and Fleance, in order to gain his trust and potentially patronage for his theatre. This also helps Shakespeare later in the play when he subtly warns James I not to be repressive and tyrannical in his rule.

Shakespeare ensures Banquo isn’t perfect as he is tempted on some level by the Witches’ prophecy, but his ability to reject evil is what makes him a moral character and an antithesis to Macbeth. He is less able to resist temptation when he sleeps “ I dream’d of the three weird sisters last night ”, but instead of trying to hide this, he confesses to God and asks for help in remaining moral and virtuous.

This references the Bible as Jesus was tempted three times by the devil and resisted: perhaps Shakespeare is attempting to draw parallels between Banquo and Jesus which would have been largely impactful to a Christian contemporary audience, further warning about the devastating consequences of temptation and tyranny by contrasting this with the holy and biblical ideas associated with resistance to temptation and ambition.

Shakespeare demonstrates how the acquisition of power invokes an irreversible change in character, subverting the audience’s expectations as he implies that a person’s poor qualities are amplified by the crown and personal desire - Macbeth becomes paranoid.

In the beginning of the play, Macbeth is conveyed as the epitome of a loyal and quintessential Scottish soldier when the captain recalls Macbeth’s noble actions as he “ carv’d the passage ” of the traitor Macdonwald. Specifically, the emotive verb “ carv’d ” carries strong connotations of combative expertise and nobility. Alternatively, it could allude to him carving his name famously in the beginning of the play and eventually notoriously at the end of the play, foreshadowing his drastic moral decline. The stark contrast between Macbeth murdering an enemy of the king (which would be seen as an enemy to God due to the Divine Right of Kings believed by the contemporary audience) and when he commits regicide - the ultimate sin.

Shakespeare explores the consequences of usurpation - for the nation it is a nightmare; an illegitimate king can only become a tyrant, using ever greater acts of violence to maintain his rule. However, Shakespeare is careful to emphasise how the tyrant himself suffers at his own hands - violence traumatises the violent person as well as the victims. Macbeth ‘ fixed [Macdonwald’s] head upon our battlements ’. The head is symbolic as a motif of Macbeth’s declining heroism. First he is at his moral peak as he beheads the King’s enemy, effectively God’s enemy in the eyes of the contemporary audience, then after having his moral endurance tested in the form of ‘ supernatural soliciting ’ he goes out to commit regicide, losing all virtue. Finally, Shakespeare uses this motif to highlight the negative consequences to his audience as the ‘head’ foreshadows Macbeth’s later disgrace as his own head becomes described as ‘ the usurper’s cursed head’ that is reminiscent of his previous morality before he was corrupted by ambition and the witches’ prophecies.

Supernatural

Shakespeare forces his audience to question whether the unlawful act of treason has a supernatural urge, whether there are malign witches and demonic forces working against the moral bonds of mankind. Macbeth’s growing inclination towards ‘supernatural soliciting’ leaves him in a perplexed self-questioning state " why hath it given me earnestness of success/commencing in a truth ?” Linguistically, the sibilance of ‘ supernatural soliciting’ is deliberately used by Shakespeare to raise his audience’s alarm, given the satanic connotations and reference to devastating sorcery in the form of ‘soliciting’.

Likewise, Macbeth’s rhetorical question is used by Shakespeare to create a self-doubting, unstable and malevolent fallacy created by the engagement with the ‘agents of the dark’.

This repeated motif of the supernatural was especially significant to a contemporary Christian audience as witches were believed to be women who made a pact with the Devil, but it also would have especially attracted the interests of King James I - Macbeth was first performed to him and his courtiers. James I hated witchcraft and wrote Daemonologie - a book about the supernatural. Here, Shakespeare is flattering the king by incorporating his interests into his play and is also warning the nobility who were unhappy with James as king at the time by suggesting their desire to overthrow James I was manipulated into existence by the supernatural and witches.

Mr Salles Teaches English is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and to get top grades, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

This is a very ambitious title – normally you would have just kingship or tyranny set as the question. And then you are going to make it even more ambitious by introducing the supernatural!

This has led to a very convoluted thesis – having at least 3 ideas is excellent, but it has to make sense. You could simplify this:

Shakespeare contrasts the characters of Macbeth and Banquo to caution against ambition. Unchecked ambition is associated with the supernatural, which allows Shakespeare characterise ambition as inherently evil. Macbeth becomes a tyrannical king because he welcomes “supernatural soliciting.” The focus on the supernatural also contributes to Shakespeare’s overall purpose of trying to flatter King James I and warn the nobility against rebellion.

Notice how I have structured this differently in order to make one point at a time.

If you would like to learn from the rest of my marking, consider becoming a paid subscriber.

Keep reading with a 7-day free trial

Subscribe to Mr Salles Teaches English to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.

Leaving Cert Notes and Sample Answers

Macbeth Sample Essay: Kingship

“kingship, with all its potential for good or evil, is a major theme in the play, macbeth.”, discuss this view, supporting your answer by quotation from or reference to the play. (1995) .

This is a H1 essay.  You may also like:  Full Notes on Macbeth (€)

Shakespeare’s tragedy “Macbeth” contains an elaborate exploration of the theme of power and within that, the theme of kingship. The main character’s evil plan aims at overthrowing the current ruler and assuming power over Scotland. Based on this the playwright profoundly analyses what qualities are the most important in a good king, what qualities are incompatible with kingship and the divine right of kings.

[Duncan as a great king] – you don’t need to put these in, this is just to improve readability

Before carrying out his plot Macbeth weighs up all the reasons why he wanted to proceed with it and all the arguments against his terrible murder plan. One such argument is that “this Duncan… hath been / So clear in his great office, that his virtues / Will plead like angels”. Duncan is portrayed as a wise ruler who feels strongly about the security of his country in the ongoing war with Norway. However, our encounter with this noble man is very brief. Macbeth, once he became king, did not know how to rule a country.

Kingship, with all its potential for good or evil, is a major theme in the play, Macbeth.

[Macbeth as a selfish king]

Macbeth’s major concerns are for his own safety and for the security of his own power: “Thy crown does sear mine eyeballs.”. He doesn’t even consider the welfare of the Scottish people before going ahead with the regicide. This shows that no matter how dedicated you are to your country, even as a great warrior and “Bellona’s bridegroom” – as an ordinary person you may not rule a country. This message is reflective of the prevailing belief in the divine right of kings that existed in Shakespeare’s day. Macbeth is not fit for the task: with him Scotland is “bleeding.” The tyranny is reflected by the darkness and bizarre supernatural events of the play.

[Imagery of darkness used to emphasise Macbeth’s inadequacy as king]

Darkness, nighttime and the colour black frequently referred to in the play demonstrating that there is something worth hiding. Shakespeare uses this to show just how far removed Macbeth’s kingship is from the ideal. It is always at nighttime that the Witches, the “black and midnight hags,” show their faces and act as “instruments of darkness.” After all, it was the Witches who gave Macbeth the idea to kill Duncan. Nighttime serves as the cover for Macbeth’s murders. He pleads: “Stars, hide your fires! Let not the light see my black and deep desires.” His selfish kingship is all about his desires and he knows that this should be hidden. On the night when Duncan was killed it was abnormally dark: “There’s husbandry in heaven, their candles are all out.” Most of the play is set at night time: it is only bright twice – when Duncan arrives at Inverness and when Macbeth is about to die. Both are events that subvert Macbeth’s evil plot and demonstrate Shakespeare’s views on the Macbeth’s legitimacy as a king.

[Imagery of the supernatural used to emphasise the divine right of kings]

Even more broadly, Shakespeare appeals to the supernatural to demonstrate Macbeth’s lack of fitness to be king. This is to emphasise the “unnatural” killing of the rightful king: “Unnatural deeds / Do breed unnatural troubles”. The order of things at the time hinged on a belief in the divine right of kings. When the cursed pair carry out their plan, the country descends into violent horror and disarray. Pathetic fallacy, a literary method used to illustrate deeper issues by attributing human qualities to the surroundings, is used here: “A falcon, tow’ring in her pride of place, / Was by a mousing owl hawked at and killed.” Perhaps, this is the mousing Macbeth trying to be in place of a hawk by slaughtering the towering royalty and violating the divine right of kings? [Imagery of violence demonstrates Macbeth’s inadequacy as king]

The enormous amount of heart-stopping gruesome references to blood and violence emphasise the consequences of the inadequate regime for which Macbeth is responsible: Scotland “weeps, it bleeds, and each new day a gash Is added to her wounds.” However, the Bard of Avon not only condemns the bad ruler, but he explores the good qualities that a king should possess.

[Malcolm as an ideal king]

Desperate and helpless, Macduff arrives in England to see Malcolm, the legitimate successor to Duncan’s throne. Malcolm is almost an embodiment of all the positive qualities of kings. He, along with his brother, immediately decide to rely on themselves to preserve their dynasty by leaving Scotland despite the obvious and inevitable suspicion that it raises and their own bereavement: “Nor our strong sorrow / Upon the foot of motion.” They handle the situation with wisdom and courage, all for the sake of their kingdom. When Malcolm meets Macduff we see more of his wisdom. He adopts the personality of a man who is “not fit to govern and not even to live.” Malcolm makes sure to not jeopardise his own life and the welfare of Scotland by “testing” Macduff. Malcolm, unlike Macbeth, is able to tell appearance from reality in his superiority as king.

[Examination of ideal kingship]

The main aspects highlighted by Malcolm that are absolutely incompatible with a decent king are lying, voluptuousness and greed. He plans to “cut off the nobles for their lands, / Desire his jewels… Your wives, your daughters, / Your matrons, and your maids could not fill up / The cistern of my lust.” Satisfied with Macduff’s reaction Malcolm opens up: “What I am truly, / Is thine and my poor country’s to command” and admits that he is not ridden with vices as he had pretended. We find out Shakespeare’s vision of king-becoming graces: “verity, temperance, stableness, / Bounty, perseverance, mercy, lowliness, / Devotion, patience, courage, fortitude…” The return of the rightful king is marked by the delight of the army. Macbeth, on the contrary, is full of bravado and feels invincible one minute and then left thinking about “all our yesterdays have lighted fools / The way to dusty death… It is a tale / Told by an idiot, full of sound and fury, / Signifying nothing” as Scotland, Lady Macbeth and his soul are all deteriorating around him.

[Conclusion]

Shakespeare offers a detailed examination of the concept of kingship in this play. However, I cannot quite trust that “Macbeth” was written as a pure form of art. James I, the king of England at the time, Shakespeare’s patron, was one of the main proponents of the divine right of kings and a prominent witch-hunter. On the one hand, I feel that the play is a piece of propaganda written to please the sovereign and this casts a significant shadow on anything Shakespeare has to say about kingship. I ask myself what did Duncan have to do to become king? My suspicion is that it has more in common with Macbeth’s path than Shakespeare dares to admit. On the other hand, I understand that Shakespeare lived at a different time. Notwithstanding all of this, his imagery and plot line emphasise all the selfless aspects of kingship and deliver it through a compelling play.

This is the 1995 English paper .

buy leaving cert notes

  • TOP CATEGORIES
  • AS and A Level
  • University Degree
  • International Baccalaureate
  • Uncategorised
  • 5 Star Essays
  • Study Tools
  • Study Guides
  • Meet the Team
  • English Literature
  • Miscellaneous

Kingship in Macbeth

Authors Avatar

This is a preview of the whole essay

Kingship in Macbeth

Document Details

  • Word Count 1274
  • Page Count 3
  • Subject English

Related Essays

Character Analysis of Macbeth

Character Analysis of Macbeth

english macbeth

english macbeth

Is Lady Macbeth a Monster?  Discuss with reference to how the Character is depicted in the Play.

Is Lady Macbeth a Monster? Discuss with reference to how the Character is...

Is macbeth nothing more than a bloody tyrant or can we take pity on him?

Is macbeth nothing more than a bloody tyrant or can we take pity on him?

macbeth essay about kingship

Macbeth: Essay Plan Examples

A* and Level 9 essays are always properly planned before they are written. But how should you plan a Macbeth Essay?

Here is a list of practise plans and notes that students have completed for a range of essays on Macbeth. Some are focused on ideas, and others on structuring. To get the best out of your plans, you should try to keep a balance between both of these.

Always plan a thesis before writing — this is your main argument, the main answer to the question that comes in the intro of your essay. The rest of the essay should then explore and argue on this thesis.

This page is suitable for students aged 14–18 (GCSE — A-Level), particularly those studying the following exam boards: CIE / Cambridge, AQA, OCR, WJEC / Eduqas, CCEA, Edexcel.

Thanks for reading! If you find this resource useful, you can take a look at our full online Macbeth course here . Use the code “SHAKESPEARE” to receive a 50% discount!

This course includes: 

  • A full set of video lessons on each key element of the text: summary, themes, setting, characters, context, attitudes, analysis of key quotes, essay questions, essay examples
  • Downloadable documents for each video lesson 
  • A range of example B-A* / L7-L9 grade essays, both at GCSE (ages 14-16) and A-Level (age 16+) with teacher comments and mark scheme feedback
  • A bonus Macbeth workbook designed to guide you through each scene of the play!

For more help with Macbeth and Tragedy, read our article here .

PRACTICE ESSAY 1:

Explore how Shakespeare discusses the theme of deception in Macbeth.

Trickery begets trickery — Macbeth deceives Duncan at the start, Banquo shortly after, he himself is deceived by the Witches > negative comment on deception.

Feudal system / divine right of kings vs New Politics / Machiavelli.

Deception creates temporary power, but the order of the world will be restored.

God ignores the castle — sinful behavior causes God to turn away.

Thesis: deception is evil and creates more evil and chaos, both for the individuals who deceive and the kingdom as a whole. For the human characters, it leads down a path to insanity, Shakespeare is drawing a parallel between deception and evil to show that it is ungodly and sinful.

P1 — Intro — Shakespeare discusses the theme of deception in Macbeth by exploring Macbeth’s insanity, showing the Macbeths covering their tracks and the temporary success with long term failure that deception brings.

P2 — Macbeth’s insanity — “oh full of scorpions is my mind”, “could not I pronounce Amen” “Is this a dagger I see before me”.

P3 — Showing the Macbeths covering their tracks — creates a climate of panic and paranoia — “I’ll gild the faces of the grooms withal”.

P4 — demonstrates the religious messages of Macbeth — don’t commit sinful behavior.

P5 — demonstrates Shakespeare’s political beliefs — his faith in the Feudal system / his mistrust of New Politics.

PRACTISE ESSAY 2:

How does Shakespeare make this scene particularly terrifying?

500–600 Words essay.

5 Paragraphs:

  • Intro — 50 words — Go over points quickly > thesis at the end
  • Paragraph 1 (PEAL) — 165 words
  • Paragraph 2 (PEAL) — 165 words
  • Paragraph 3 (PEAL) — 165 words
  • Conclusion — Recap strongest points quickly > Link back to the thesis

Paragraph plans

  • Shakespeare makes this scene particularly terrifying by… (religion)
  • Furthermore, the scene is particularly terrifying due to … (fear)
  • Another way that Shakespeare has made this scene particularly terrifying is… (supernatural)

PARAGRAPH STRUCTURE:

Point — 1 Sentence

Evidence — Quotation (no longer than 7 words).

Analysis — Identify techniques, language features, vocabulary, and dramatic devices ‘how / why’ something works in a certain way.

Evaluation — assessing the importance/significance of something.

Link — Link back to text and thesis.

Thesis: The significant turning point for Macbeth in the play as he realizes that he is unable to say amen and might be haunted due to his deed. Macbeth is a dynamic character, a tragic hero who undergoes a tragic fall, and this moment demonstrates the point at which his mind begins to disintegrate and he is abandoned by God, which would be very terrifying for a Shakespearean audience.

Top Level Mark Scheme:

  • Answers in this band have all the qualities of Band 2 work, with further  insight, sensitivity, individuality, and flair.  They maintain a  sustained engagement  with both text and task.
  • Sustains a perceptive, convincing and relevant personal response
  • Shows a clear critical understanding of the text.
  • Responds sensitively and in detail to the way the writer achieves her/his effects (sustaining a convincing voice in an empathic task).
  • Integrates much well-selected reference to the text

‘Make’ > understand and discuss dramatic devices

‘Particularly’ > evaluation word

Thesis: ‘what we think/feel/realize’

Shakespeare makes this scene particularly terrifying through the implicit meanings in the text. He uses varying vocabulary and language features such as allegory and allusion, which are seen throughout the text, to create a frightening atmosphere. This mainly revolves around Macbeth, a dynamic character, whose insight to murder has changed. We realize that Macbeth is unable to cope with his past actions due to his current actions.

QUOTES/IDEAS:

“ Didst thou not hear a noise ?” — Macbeth builds tension/suspense, a small amount of fear, later layers up into terror.

“ The owl scream ” — Lady Macbeth, possible link to Duncan’s death, possible horror sound, ‘scream’ > personification.

“ As I descended ?” — Macbeth, descent downstairs, but also perhaps signifies hell/degeneration into evil + madness.

Disjoined / lack of connection between characters — Macbeth is jumpy. They disagree. Macbeth is empathetic towards Donalbain > ‘ sorry sight’, Lady Macbeth is cold and says he is ‘foolish’.

“ There’s one did laugh in’s sleep, and one cried ‘Murder !’,” > terrifying, because two random people woke up during Macbeth murdering Duncan, they have a premonition or some sort of awareness.

“ I had most need of blessing, and ‘Amen’/ Stuck in my throat. ” > he’s under the influence of evil, so God has abandoned him, he’s past the point of redemption, perhaps the turning point where he realizes he can’t go back, psychological?

“ It will make us mad ” > Lady Macbeth feels that the two of them will be mad if they dwell on their deeds in a negative way.

“ Macbeth does murder sleep ” > this is particularly terrifying as sleep also means rest and peace. Not only is Macbeth murdering sleep, but he is murdering rest and peace which he will not get as he will be haunted by the murder. ( personification )

“ Smear / The sleepy grooms with blood ” > the fact that they can pass the blame so easily and effectively is terrifying, what else can they pass the blame for if they can pass the blame for the murder.

“ Painted devil ” > the image of a dead body is likened to a painted devil seen by a child. They are just images that are feared.

“ Clean from my hand? No ” > No amount of water will be able to wash the blood off of Macbeth’s hands. He will never be able to forget about the blood on his hands, in a metaphorical sense.

“ Making the green one red ” > His hands will turn the sea red. That is the amount of blood which he bears.

Foreshadowing Lady Macbeth’s ‘out damned spot’:

“Out, damned spot! Out, I say! — One, two. Why, then, ’tis time to do ’t. Hell is murky! — Fie, my lord, fie! A soldier, and afeard? What need we fear who knows it, when none can call our power to account? — Yet who would have thought the old man to have had so much blood in him?” >  5.1, just before she commits suicide, a descent into madness — she sees spots of blood on her hands, paralleling Macebeth’s visions of blood.

Motif – recurring element of a story (lack of sleep/blood on hands).

ESSAY PLAN 3:

In what ways does Shakespeare make the relationship between Macbeth and Banquo so compelling?

P1 — Intro — Shakespeare makes the relationship between Macbeth and Banquo so compelling through the exploration of the themes of deception, death, and good versus evil. The discussion of such themes leads us, as the reader, to come to the conclusion that Macbeth is a sinister character who has somehow managed to befriend an honest, decent man, Banquo which leads to a relationship filled with tension.

P2- Deception- “I fear thou have played most foully for it” “fruitless crown” “I wish your horses swift and sure of foot”

P3 — death- “Banquo, thy soul’s flight…find heaven”  Enter the Ghost of Banquo and sits in Macbeth’s place  (stage directions)

P4 — good versus evil- juxtaposing of characters

Conclusion — strongest points again

ESSAY PLAN 4:

‘Macbeth is not an evil man, but one led astray by those around him’.

To what extent do you agree with this view?

You should write 500–600 words.

Thesis — I believe that Macbeth is an evil man and is responsible for his own actions. His sheer greed for power is what has led him astray and it was his choice to kill Duncan and have Banquo and Fleance as well as Macduff’s family killed. He has shown throughout the play that his greed, not those around him, has led him astray.

Paragraph 1: — Intro- include thesis and quick overview Paragraph 2: — Disagree paragraph Paragraph 3: — Disagree paragraph Paragraph 4: — Agree paragraph (counter) Paragraph 5: — Conclusion (quick overview of strongest points, thesis)

Point -main point

Evidence -quotation

Analysis -why/how does it relate to argument

Context -context to shakespearean times

Alternative interpretation -alternative view

Link -back to thesis

  • Told by the witches that he will be king.
  • Pressured by Lady Macbeth to kill Duncan.
  • Witches tell him that Banquo’s descendants shall be king, incites Macbeth. Witches may have known that this would have riled Macbeth up.
  • Witches told Macbeth he will be king so he could have waited until he became King the right way.
  • Macbeth could have stood up to Lady Macbeth and told her no.
  • Macbeth felt the need to have Banquo and Fleance killed, nobody pressured him to do so.
  • Macbeth had Macduff’s family killed for no good reason.
  • Macbeth acted on his own accord.

If you’re studying Macbeth, you can click here to buy our full online course. Use the code “SHAKESPEARE” to receive a 50% discount!

You will gain access to  over 8 hours  of  engaging video content , plus  downloadable PDF guides  for  Macbeth  that cover the following topics:

  • Character analysis
  • Plot summaries
  • Deeper themes

There are also tiered levels of analysis that allow you to study up to  GCSE ,  A Level  and  University level .

You’ll find plenty of  top level example essays  that will help you to  write your own perfect ones!

Related Posts

The Theme of Morality in To Kill A Mockingbird

The Theme of Morality in To Kill A Mockingbird

Unseen Poetry Exam Practice – Spring

Unseen Poetry Exam Practice – Spring

To Kill A Mockingbird Essay Writing – PEE Breakdown

To Kill A Mockingbird Essay Writing – PEE Breakdown

Emily Dickinson A Level Exam Questions

Emily Dickinson A Level Exam Questions

Poem Analysis: Sonnet 116 by William Shakespeare

Poem Analysis: Sonnet 116 by William Shakespeare

An Inspector Calls – Official AQA Exam Questions

An Inspector Calls – Official AQA Exam Questions

The Dolls House by Katherine Mansfield: Summary + Analysis

The Dolls House by Katherine Mansfield: Summary + Analysis

An Occurrence At Owl Creek Bridge: Stories of Ourselves:

An Occurrence At Owl Creek Bridge: Stories of Ourselves:

How to Get Started with Narrative Writing

How to Get Started with Narrative Writing

Robert Frost’s Life and Poetic Career

Robert Frost’s Life and Poetic Career

© Copyright Scrbbly 2022

Macbeth Kingship Essay

Since Macbeth was originally written in the early 17th century, the idea of kingship would have been significantly different from what it is today. In Shakespeare’s time, the king was seen as a divine figurehead, placed on the throne by God himself. As a result, any action or decision made by the king was seen as an order from on high. Macbeth, as a usurper of the throne, would have been considered a traitor and criminal.

Interestingly, Macbeth does not seem to think of himself as a traitor; rather, he sees himself as someone who is fighting for Scotland’s independence. He justifies his crimes by telling himself that he is doing what is best for his country. This idea of the “noble rebel” is a common trope in Shakespeare’s plays. Macbeth is not the only character to wrestle with the idea of morality and duty; all of Shakespeare’s characters are complex and multi-layered.

In Macbeth, the question of kingship is explored in depth. What does it mean to be a king? What is the responsibility of a king? Can a king ever be justified in committing evil deeds? These are just some of the questions that Shakespeare asks in his play. Macbeth is an excellent example of how the themes of kingship can be explored through character and plot.

Analyse Shakespeares ideas and attributes towards kingship, as expressed in Macbeth, and assess what you believe the audience’s reaction to the play would be at the time. Shakespeares views on monarchy may be seen throughout the play. He demonstrates that a king should be elected by divine right and discusses the characteristics of a great ruler. The play Macbeth takes place in medieval Scotland during the reign of King Duncan.

Macbeth is seen as a good king, who is loved by his people. Macbeth is then killed by Macduff, who is seen as an usurper. Macduff kills Macbeth in order to save the kingdom from Macbeths tyranny.

The audiences reaction to the play would have been mixed. The play shows the dangers of a tyrant king and how it can ruin a country. However, it also shows that a good king can be beneficial to a country. The play would have been popular with the Tudor audience as they were interested in British history.

Macbeth would have been seen as an interesting play, as it showed how a good king could be corrupted by power. The play would also have been seen as a warning to the Tudor audience, as they were in the process of choosing a new king. Macbeth is a good example of how a bad king can ruin a country and the play would have been used by the Tudors to show why they needed a good king.

Macbeth is also an interesting play from a historical perspective, as it shows how Scotland was ruled in medieval times. The play would have been popular with audiences in Scotland, as it showed their history on stage. Macbeth is one of Shakespeares most popular plays and it is still performed today. It is important to analyse Shakespeares ideas about kingship as they are still relevant today.

Macbeth becomes king by deceit, and his reign continues in this fashion. When Duncan is just, Macbeth becomes tyrannical, and he turns deadly. He runs a ruthless dictatorship. King Edward of England is good compared to Macbeth, who is portrayed as an unpopular tyrant.

Macbeth murders him to gain the throne. Macduff, loyal to the King, is outraged by this and leads a rebellion against Macbeth. Macbeth is eventually killed in battle.

Mabeth’s rule as king is fraught with violence and bloodshed. He comes to power through murder and his reign is characterised by tyranny and cruelty. Macduff, a loyal subject of the king, leads a rebellion against Macbeth after he murders King Duncan. Macbeth is eventually killed in battle, bringing an end to his brutal rule.

Through the unnatural events that follow Macbeth’s unlawful ascent to the throne, James’ theories are reflected in William Shakespeare’s 1606 play Macbeth. According to the doctrine of divine right, God grants rulership rights to them.

Macbeth’s usurpation of the throne thus represents a break with the natural order, which is only restored when Macduff kills Macbeth. Macbeth therefore represents both the dangers of violating the natural order and the dangers of excessive ambition. James believed that a king must have both wisdom and courage if he is to rule his people justly. Macbeth displays neither of these qualities, instead relying on force and violence to maintain his position. The play also reflects James’s belief in the need for a strong monarchy to protect Scotland from its enemies.

When the Norwegians’ triumph is reported, Macbeth and Banquo are ready to go to war with them. When they reach home, Macbeth and Banquo meet two aged crones who tell him his destiny. This startles Macbeth, causing him to desire greater power. As a result of Macbeth’s wicked leadership, Scotland became a country of turmoil during his reign.

Macduff, a nobleman and Macbeth’s greatest rival, eventually kills Macbeth in order to restore peace to the kingdom. Macbeth is very much a play about kingship, and the various pitfalls that come with it. Macbeth is initially driven by his ambition to become king, but this desire ultimately leads to his downfall. The play also explores the idea of what it means to be a good ruler, and Macbeth is shown to be a terrible king because of his thirst for power and his willingness to kill anyone who gets in his way.

Macduff represents the ideal king – someone who is willing to put the needs of his people before his own personal desires. Macduff is a good and noble man who is willing to fight for what is right, and he ultimately becomes the rightful king of Scotland. Macbeth is a cautionary tale about the dangers of greed and ambition, and it serves as a reminder that a good king is someone who puts the needs of his people first.

More Essays

  • The Real Macbeth
  • The Nature Of Evil In Macbeth
  • Supernatural Forces In Macbeth
  • Night In Macbeth
  • Macbeth Summary Essay
  • Lady Macbeth Manipulation Essay
  • Macbeth Appearance vs Reality Essay
  • Macbeth Mock Trial Prosecution
  • What Crimes Did Macbeth Commit
  • Paradoxes In Macbeth Act 2

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

Study Like a Boss

Macbeth – Kingship Essay

With detailed reference to the characters of Macbeth, Duncan, Malcolm and Edward in the play Macbeth, analyse William Shakespeares ideas and attributes towards kingship and assess what you think the audiences reaction to the play would be at the time. Shakespeares ideas towards kingship can be seen throughout the play. He shows that a king should be chosen by divine right and shows the attributes of what a good king should be. The play Macbeth is set in medieval Scotland at the fictional time of King Duncan.

Scotland is currently at war with the Norwegians when news of their victory comes through, with thanks to the two leaders of the army Macbeth and Banquo. On their travel home Macbeth and Banquo stumble upon some old hags, and they predict Macbeths future to him. This startles Macbeth and his hunger for power grows so much that he and his wife plot to murder the well-respected King Duncan. Under Macbeths reign, Scotland becomes a country of turmoil because of the wicked leadership.

Macbeth murders his best friend and another friends family and because of this Tyranny, paranoia sets in on Macbeth who sees many ghostly visions of people he sent out to be murdered. Scotland greatly suffers under his reign, this turns Lady Macbeth mad, and she eventually commits suicide. Macduff, eventually goes to England to ask for the help of the noble king Edward, who is highly respected for help to overthrow the leadership of Macbeth, and so the Anglo-Scottish revolt sees Macbeth to his death and Malcolm the son of Duncan is proclaimed king of Scotland.

Macbeth is the main character in the play and starts the play as a very hard fighting, loyal soldier whose bravery had just led the way to a victory over the Norwegians. It could be an essay in its own right to talk about how the character of Macbeth develops and changes, at the beginning he is a god-like hero a firm, strong, loyal character. But through allowing his ambition to suppress his good qualities, he becomes this tyrant (act4 sc3 L12 Malcolm), this dwarfish thief (act5 sc3 L12 Angus) and this hellhound (act5 sc6 L42 Macduff).

The character of Macbeth is a study of how one person can degenerate from Bellonas bridegroom (act1 sc2 L55) to this dead butcher (act5 sc6 L108). Ambition is his fatal weakness. He allows, first the witches prophecy act1 sc3 L46-50 and then his wifes ambition for him, to undermine his integrity act1 sc5 L58-68. He is not easily won over by evil, his love and respect for Duncan is evident throughout the play. Because Banquo knew the prophecy of the witches, he ordered his death in case he thought that he might have killed Duncan, act3 sc1 Line start 10 Banquo says he has all three as the witches predicted.

Under his reign of tyranny, he kills and slaughters. A dominant feature about the play is that when there is a bad king, the country as well suffers, and many characters talk of how Scotland is suffering act4 sc3 L168-169 Where sighs, and groans, and shrieks that rent the air, are made, not marked. Act4 sc3 L40-41 Malcolm says, it weeps, it bleeds, and each new day a gash is added to her wounds. In the same scene Macduff also says, bleed, bleed poor country.

Also, Each new morn, new widows howl, new orphans cry, new sorrows strike heaven on the face, that it resounds as if it felt with Scotland, and yelled out like a syllable of dolour. People dont talk highly of Macbeth unlike Duncan, words like black and treacherous and also tyrant are to name but a few. Macduff comments, not in the legions of horrid hell can come a devil more damned in evils, to top Macbeth. In act4 sc3 L57-60 Malcolm says, I grant him bloody, luxurious, avaricious, false, deceitful, sudden, malicious, smacking of every sin that has a name.

Macduff shows a point that he believes that a king should be chosen by divine right (this also shows that Shakespeare as well believes in divine right) in act4 sc3, with an untitled tyrant But this is very different from the start of the play where words like worthy thane were used to greet Macbeth. Also totally different to what is said about Duncan, my liege, great king and after his death he is called an angel. Duncan is Shakespeares idea of a perfect, impartial king. Shakespeare shows Duncan to be an example to all other kings and people, he shows love for his country when he asks the captain news from the war.

He speaks to people with respect and dignity when t….. he bleeding captain brings news of the war act1 sc2 L24 o valiant cousin, worthy gentleman! People talk to him with the utmost respect, they know that he is a truly great king my liege, great king and cries of god save the king are dominant in act1 sc3. He also shows that he can be fair and rewarding because he praises the brave Captain and he also puts the Thane of Cawdor to death for betrayal against his country and then awards Macbeth his title for his heroic doings against Norway.

He also can be a charmer and very polite when he is greeted by Lady Macbeth at their household act1 sc6 L10-15. Even after his death people still speak highly of him, even Macbeth refers to Duncan as gracious (act3 sc1 L65) and when Macduff argues with Malcolm, he appeals that his father was a most sainted king (act4 sc3 L109). Malcolm also says, angels are bright still, though the brightest fell. This means that there still are good kings to come although the best has gone.

Therefore the view of Duncan is consistent throughout the play (unlike views of the Macbeths) all attest to his worth and merits. He seems decisive as a king, and clearly inspires loyalty in his Thanes. If he has a weakness it is a consequence of his goodness his trust. He comments himself that it is impossible to see the minds construction in the face (act1 sc4 L12-14), but this recognition does not cause him to behave, perhaps, with a little more discretion. Trusting Macbeth, he too readily steps into his house without appropriate safeguards, which ends up being fatal for him.

It is awful to reflect that our final view of Duncan is him kissing Lady Macbeth (his hostess) (act1 sc6) to whom we subsequently learn he has sent a diamond to her by means of a present. After his death, Macbeth still talks highly of king Duncan. Duncan wasnt only a great king but a loving and caring father of his heir, Malcolm. This is shown because Malcolm emerges similar to his father. Malcolm is the rightful heir to the throne of Scotland by divine right. He appears to be a worthy king as we get to see his character mostly in act4 sc3 where he has a long conversation with Macduff.

Malcolm can see that the country is in turmoil and he rightfully blames black Macbeth as he puts it. Also unlike Macbeth, we can see that Malcolm doesnt act without thinking, as he tries to win some confidence out of Macduff saying that he himself mightnt be fit enough to one day be king. Malcolm talks of his own faults in act4 sc3 saying that he cant get adultery off his mind, he calls himself voluptuous and with his carnal attitude also says, your wives, your daughters, your matrons and your maids, could not fill up the cistern of my lust.

He also says to win encouragement from Macduff that black Macbeth will seem as pure as snow meaning that Macbeth will be a better king than he will. It is obvious to see that Malcolm will be a good king because he lists words that a good king must have. This also implies Shakespeares ideas to what qualities a good king should have At the end of the play Shakespeare includes Malcolms last words of the play to be similar to Duncans speech when he was king, this proves that Malcolm becomes a good king, following in his footsteps and restoring Scotland to its former glory.

King Edward of England is the king least of all mentioned in the play, but still we can tell a lot about his character and what type of king he was. We can see that Edward was a good, loyal king, who wasnt prepared to see others suffer. In act4 sc3 L141-145, a doctor comments on how some ill people touched Edwards hand and were healed, Malcolm then after comments it is a most miraculous work in this good king. Also, we can see that he is a good and caring king as he chooses to help Malcolm and Macduff in their Anglo-Scottish revolt. I have really enjoyed studying this play and it is most probably the best I have read.

It is amazing how Shakespeare can make one man fall into evil just because of his lust for power, and not just that it is also the way in which he is able to do it, using his imagination, he is able to enthral his audiences into disbelief. It is clear to see Shakespeares ideas towards kingship in the play as Malcolm lists the attributes towards a good king in act4 sc3. I think most of all that the moods of the people at the time would have been mostly in shock at this tragic tale and amazed at the way the playwright could achieve this most gripping story line.

To export a reference to this article please select a referencing style below:

Related posts:

  • Macbeth’s five major acts
  • The Role Of Punishment In Macbeth Essay
  • Why Lady Macbeth is more Guilt
  • Why Lady Macbeth is more Guilty
  • The tragedy MacBeth
  • More Than A Noble Perception
  • Is Macbeth the tragic hero of the play “Macbeth”
  • Imagery In Macbeth
  • William Shakespeare’s Macbeth Shakespeare
  • Macbeth’s choice of actions
  • Macbeth In Shakespeare
  • Lady Macbeth Heres The Smell Of Blood Quotes Research Paper
  • Macbeth Appearance Vs Reality Analysis Essay
  • The story of Macbeth
  • Macbeth Introduction and Summary

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

  • International
  • Schools directory
  • Resources Jobs Schools directory News Search

Macbeth - essay plan on Kingship

Macbeth - essay plan on Kingship

Subject: English

Age range: 14-16

Resource type: Other

olzat

Last updated

17 December 2020

  • Share through email
  • Share through twitter
  • Share through linkedin
  • Share through facebook
  • Share through pinterest

macbeth essay about kingship

Ideas of Kingship are integral in Shakespeare’s ‘Macbeth’. This resource puts forward a series of points (and accompanying evidence) for students to discuss and explore. It could even be used as the basis for an essay about Shakespeare’s Presentation of Kingship in ‘Macbeth’ .

It’s uploaded as a Word document, in case you need to edit it for your students.

Tes paid licence How can I reuse this?

Your rating is required to reflect your happiness.

It's good to leave some feedback.

Something went wrong, please try again later.

This resource hasn't been reviewed yet

To ensure quality for our reviews, only customers who have purchased this resource can review it

Report this resource to let us know if it violates our terms and conditions. Our customer service team will review your report and will be in touch.

Not quite what you were looking for? Search by keyword to find the right resource:

Get £10 off your first lesson on PMT Tuition. Use the code PMTAPRIL10 . Book before 30 April, new accounts only.

PMT

University of East Anglia - MA Creative Writing (Prose)

Friendly and approachable Cambridge graduate and PhD student, committed to making English accessible to all

PMT Education

Notes || Exam Prep || Character Profiles || Themes

This topic is included in  Paper 1 . You can find notes and guides for it below.

  • Brief Overview
  • Glossary of Key Terms
  • Key Terms Flashcards
  • Guide to Paper 1 - AQA English Literature GCSE
  • Guide to Paper 1
  • How to plan and write a top mark essay - English Literature GCSE
  • How to plan and write a top mark essay

Character Profiles

  • Lady Macbeth (Brief)
  • Macbeth (Brief)
  • The Witches
  • Abuse of Power and Kingship
  • Appearance vs Reality
  • Guilt, Innocence and Paranoia

Connect with PMT Education!

  • Revision Courses
  • Past Papers
  • Solution Banks
  • University Admissions
  • Numerical Reasoning
  • Legal Notices

According to Stephen King, This Is Why We Crave Horror Movies

The horror king breaks down our obsession with the macabre.

Stephen King and horror are synonymous. Are you really able to call yourself a fan of horror if one of his novels or film adaptations isn't among your top favorites? The Maine-born writer is hands down the most successful horror writer and one of the most beloved and prolific writers ever whose legacy spans generations. Without King, we might not be as terrified of clowns and or think twice about bullying the shy girl in school. One could say that King has earned the moniker, "the King of Horror." In addition to all he's written, King has also had over 60 adaptations of his work for television and the big screen and has written, produced, and starred in films and shows as well. He has fully immersed himself in the genre of horror from all sides, and it's unlikely that we will ever have anyone else like Stephen King. But did you know that King wrote an essay that was published in Playboy magazine about horror movies?

In 1981, King's essay titled " Why We Crave Horror Movies " was published in Playboy magazine as a variation of the chapter " The Horror Movie As Junk Food" in Danse Macabre . Danse Macabre was published in 1981 and is one of the non-fiction books in which that wrote about horror in media and how our fears and anxieties have been influencing the horror genre. The full article that was published is no longer online, but there is a shortened four-page version of it that can be found.

RELATED: The Iconic Horror Movie You Won't Believe Premiered at Cannes

Stephen King Believes We Are All Mentally Ill

The essay starts out guns blazing, the first line reading "I think that we're all mentally ill; those of us outside the asylums only hide it a little bit better." From here, he describes the general behaviors of people we know and how mannerisms and irrational fears are not different between the public and those in asylums. He points out that we pay money to sit in a theater and be scared to prove a point that we can and to show that we do not shy away from fear. Some of us, he states, even go watch horror movies for fun, which closes the gap between normalcy and insanity. A patron can go to the movies, and watch someone get mutilated and killed, and it's considered normal, everyday behavior. This, as a horror lover, feels very targeted. I absolutely watch horror movies for fun and I will do so with my bucket of heart-attack-buttered popcorn and sip on my Coke Zero. The most insane thing about all of that? The massive debt accumulated from one simple movie date.

Watching Horror Movies Allows Us to Release Our Insanity

King states that we use horror movies as a catharsis to act out our nightmares and the worst parts of us. Getting to watch the insanity and depravity on the movie screen allows us to release our inner insanity, which in turn, keeps us sane. He writes that watching horror movies allows us to let our emotions have little to no rein at all, and that is something that we don't always get to do in everyday life. Society has a set of parameters that we must follow with regard to expressing ourselves to maintain the air of normalcy and not be seen as a weirdo. When watching horror movies, we see incredibly visceral reactions in the most extreme of situations. This can cause the viewer to reflect on how they would react or respond to being in the same type of situation. Do we identify more with the victim or the villain? This poses an interesting thought for horror lovers because sometimes the villain is justified. Are we wrong for empathizing with them instead?

Let's take a look at one of the more popular horror movies of recent years. Mandy is about a woman who is murdered by a crazed cult because she is the object of the leader's obsession. This causes Red ( Nicolas Cage ) to ride off seeking revenge for the love of his life being murdered. There are also movies like I Spit On Your Grave and The Last House On The Left where the protagonist becomes the murderer in these instances because of the trauma they experienced from sexual assault. Their revenge makes audiences a little more willing to side with the murderer because they took back their power and those they killed got what was deserved. This is where that Lucille Bluth meme that says "good for her" is used. I'll die on the hill that those characters were justified and if that makes me mentally ill then King might be right!

What Does Stephen King Mean When He Tells Us to "Keep the Gators" Fed?

At the end of the essay, King mentions he likes to watch the most extreme horror movies because it releases a trap door where he can feed the alligators. The alligators he is referring to are a metaphor for the worst in all humans and the morbid fantasies that lie within each of us. The essay concludes with "It was Lennon and McCartney who said that all you need is love, and I would agree with that. As long as you keep the gators fed." From this, we can deduce that King feels we all have the ability to be institutionalized, but those of us that watch horror movies are less likely because the sick fantasies can be released from our brains.

With that release, we can walk down the street normally without the bat of an eye from walkers-by. Perhaps this is why the premise for movies like The Purge came to fruition. A movie where for 24 hours all crime, including murder, is decriminalized couldn't have been made by someone who doesn't get road rage or scream into the void. It was absolutely made by someone who waited at the DMV for too long or has had experience working in retail around Black Friday. With what King is saying, The Purge is a direct reflection of that catharsis. Not only are you getting to watch a crazy horror movie where everyone is shooting everyone and everything is on fire, but it's likely something you've had a thought or two about. You can consider those gators fed for sure.

Do Horror Movies Offer Us True Catharsis or Persuasive Perspective?

Catharsis as a concept was coined by the philosopher Aristotle . He explained that the performing arts are a way to purge negative types of emotions from our subconscious, so we don't have to hold onto them anymore. This viewpoint further perpetuates what King is trying to explain. With that cathartic relief, the urgency to act on negative emotion is less likely to happen because there is no build-up of negativity circling the drain from our subconscious to our reality. However, some who read the essay felt like King was just being persuasive and using fancy imagery rather than identifying an actual reason why horror is popular. Some claim the shock and awe factor of his words and his influence on horror would cause some readers to believe they are mentally ill deep down. I have to say, as a millennial who rummages through the ends of social media multiple times a day, everyone on the internet thinks they're mentally ill, and we all have the memes to prove it. It is exciting and fascinating to watch a horror movie after working a 9-5 job where the excitement is low. Watching Ghostface stalk Sidney Prescott ( Neve Campbell ) in Scream isn't everyone's idea of winding down, but for the last 20-something years, it has been my comfort movie when I'm feeling sad or down. The nostalgia of Scream is what makes it feel cathartic to me and that's free therapy!

What is the Science Behind Loving Horror Movies?

Psychology studies will tell us that individuals who crave and love horror are interested in it because they have a higher sensation-seeking trait . This means they have a higher penchant for wanting to experience thrilling and exciting situations. Those with a lower level of empathy are also more likely to enjoy horror movies as they will have a less innate response to a traumatic scene on screen. According to the DSM-V , a severe lack of empathy could potentially be a sign of a more serious psychological issue, however, the degree of severity will vary. I do love rollercoasters, but I also cry when I see a dog that is just too cute, so horror lovers aren't necessarily the unsympathetic robots that studies want us to be. Watching horror films can also trigger a fight-or-flight sensation , which will boost adrenaline and release endorphins and dopamine in the brain. Those chemicals being released make the viewers feel accomplished and positive, relating back to the idea that watching horror movies is cathartic for viewers.

Anyone who reads and studies research knows that correlation does not imply causation, but whether King's perspective is influenced by his position in the horror genre or not, psychology and science can back up the real reasons why audiences love horror movies. As a longtime horror lover and a pretty above-average horror trivia nerd, I have to wonder if saying we are mentally ill is an overstatement and could maybe be identified more as horror lovers seeking extreme stimulus. Granted, this essay was written over 40 years ago, so back then liking horror wasn't as widely accepted as it is today. It's possible that King felt more out of place for his horror love back then and the alienation of a fringe niche made him feel mentally ill. Is King onto something by assuming that everyone has mental illness deep down, or is this a gross overestimation of the human psyche? The answer likely falls somewhere in between, but those that love horror will continue to release that catharsis through the terrifying and the unknown because it's a scream, baby!

  • Share full article

Advertisement

Supported by

Guest Essay

What Martin Luther King Jr. Knew About Crime and Mental Illness

Blurred image of a white bird taking flight from a fence.

By Alvin L. Bragg Jr.

Mr. Bragg Jr. is the Manhattan district attorney.

In September 1958, the Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. was stabbed with a seven-inch steel letter opener. He had been autographing copies of his first book in Blumstein’s department store in Harlem. The woman who stabbed him was named Izola Ware Curry .

When Dr. King found out she was schizophrenic, he harbored no ill will toward her , saying instead, “I know that we want her to receive the necessary treatment so that she may become a constructive citizen in an integrated society where a disorganized personality need not become a menace to any man.”

Dated description aside, King recognized that people in crisis need mental health care to be healthy and safe. The many Izola Ware Currys in New York today are far more likely to find themselves in jail, or relegated to street corners and subway stations, than they are to receive comprehensive treatment. This disconnect can set the stage for people with mental illness to be both victims and perpetrators of real violence.

Mental illness isn’t a crime, and jail isn’t the answer for those experiencing it. We must meet the needs of people in crisis with treatment and support. In order to do so, we need more funding.

Lawmakers in Albany right now are in the final stages of negotiating our state budget. Gov. Kathy Hochul and the leaders of the Senate and Assembly must make good on their earlier support for significant investments in mental health care — especially for New Yorkers who have been struggling, posing potential dangers to themselves and others. Doing so now can reduce assaults in our city by people experiencing mental health crises. They can also ensure that when those people do commit crimes, they are held accountable in a manner that reduces recidivism.

Around half of people in New York City jails — some 3,000 men and women — have been diagnosed with some degree of mental illness. On any given day, hundreds await evaluations or beds at dwindling and overwhelmed state psychiatric hospitals . On a typical day at Manhattan Criminal Court, you’ll witness the churn of people struggling with mental illness, caught up in a cycle of recidivism and incarceration instead of receiving the therapy, medication and other services that would help them lead healthy, productive lives.

And it’s not only New York. According to the Vera Institute of Justice, in the United States, people with serious mental illness are more likely to encounter law enforcement than they are to receive treatment . Since the 1950s, around the time King barely dodged death, the number of state hospital psychiatric beds has decreased by around 94 percent. In many cases, jails and prisons filled the void. While large-scale psychiatric institutionalization was far from perfect — to say the very least — meaningful community-based alternatives never materialized.

Today, corrections facilities double as de facto mental health hospitals across the nation — and about 63 percent of those with a history of mental illness do not receive treatment while incarcerated in state and federal prison.

But it is in New York City where the failed mental health system seems to be on starkest display.

Desperate scenes of people in clear distress on subway platforms, in city parks and on bustling street corners, are commonplace. And although overall crime is down , the city has witnessed terrifying acts of violence and alarming incidents of disorder. Innocent people shoved in front of oncoming trains is a citywide nightmare. Women fear being randomly punched while walking down the street. This is a humanitarian disaster, and a public health and safety crisis.

We must do better — for those with real and complex mental health needs, and for all New Yorkers who currently fear for their safety. But attaining a comprehensive mental health system won’t happen overnight.

In the past few years, I’ve committed $9 million to two programs, Neighborhood Navigators and Court Navigators . In both programs, individuals with lived experience — designated “navigators”— help guide our struggling neighbors through the complex landscape of social services. It’s a start, but so much more is needed.

This year’s state budget is another opportunity to continue to build New York’s mental health infrastructure. My office submitted a detailed proposal to Albany leaders outlining mental health investments that are urgently needed this year. If we fail to take systemic action, New Yorkers will continue to confront daily scenes of desperation, and risk falling victim to shocking — but not surprising — acts of arbitrary violence.

Most directly related to the work of the Manhattan district attorney’s office, I’ve asked Albany to invest at least $25 million to expand and strengthen New York’s problem-solving courts. Such courts provide precisely the kind of treatment options that King may have wanted for his attacker, but that did not exist then. In exchange for pleading guilty, participants are offered court-supervised treatment instead of incarceration.

If they comply with their treatment plan and avoid rearrest (typically for 18 to 24 months), their felony plea can be reduced to a misdemeanor or dismissed. One mental health court found that it reduced the likelihood of rearrest by 46 percent.

I also urged Albany leaders to fund community-based mental health treatment, investing $16.3 million to fund 20 new teams to provide support to justice-involved individuals with serious mental illness. Similar initiatives have been shown to reduce overall recidivism .

For those who cannot be safely diverted from incarceration to treatment in the community, Hope House , which recently broke ground in the Bronx, will soon offer a safe and humane alternative to the Rikers Island jail complex, with 24-hour security and therapeutic treatment. The state should commit $30 million in capital funding to scale up the Hope House model.

Supportive housing provides essential stability to those with mental illness who have been justice-involved. Thousands of individuals returning to New York City from state prison go straight to shelters. Homelessness increases the risk of incarceration, which in turn increases the risk of homelessness. To break this vicious cycle, Albany should invest in building 500 new re-entry apartments over the next three years, and should expand an existing housing program for people leaving city jails.

Since I took office, we have made substantial progress in driving down murders and shootings in Manhattan, but the rise in felony assaults remains a persistent challenge. To reverse the post-Covid rise in random assaults of and by people with untreated mental illness, prevention-oriented investments are critical; enforcement has little deterrence value for crimes committed by those experiencing a mental health crisis.

Following his brush with death at the hands of Izola Ware Curry, King recognized treatment as the best path to keep those with mental illness, and those around them, safe. With assaults like the one King suffered becoming more common, our leaders in Albany must heed his call today and invest in a comprehensive mental health network.

Now is the time for action to address our mental health emergency.

Alvin L. Bragg Jr. is the Manhattan district attorney.

The Times is committed to publishing a diversity of letters to the editor. We’d like to hear what you think about this or any of our articles. Here are some tips . And here’s our email: [email protected] .

Follow the New York Times Opinion section on Facebook , Instagram , TikTok , WhatsApp , X and Threads .

VIDEO

  1. Kingship in Macbeth

  2. Use these in any Lady Macbeth essay🗡️ #macbeth #ladymacbeth #englishliterature @FirstRateTutors

  3. How to Answer The Kingship Question in Macbeth #Macbeth #GCSE

  4. Macbeth revision with Primrose Kitten and We have an ever-increasing amount of resources for AQA GCS

  5. 7 CRUCIAL QUOTES for ANY QUESTION on KINGSHIP in MACBETH

  6. Kingship Macbeth

COMMENTS

  1. Kingship in Macbeth

    Thesis: Shakespeare cleverly crafts the themes of kingship/tyranny/natural order through the devolution of Macbeth. By contrasting morality and corruption within Macbeth and Banquo, Shakespeare cautions against ambition and associates it with the supernatural - a very disturbing idea for the contemporary audience, contributing to Shakespeare's overall purpose of trying to flatter King James ...

  2. Macbeth Navigator: Themes: Kingship

    Just as the King is commenting on the treachery of the former Thane of Cawdor, in comes the new Thane of Cawdor, Macbeth. The King greets Macbeth as "worthiest cousin!"(1.4.14) and says in several different ways that he can't thank him enough. Macbeth answers with heroic modesty that "The service and the loyalty I owe, / In doing it, pays itself" (1.4.22-23).

  3. Themes Kingship Macbeth (Grades 9-1)

    Macbeth comes to be king through immoral means and his rule continues in this way. When Duncan is fair, Macbeth is tyrannical and becomes murderous. His rule is a brutal dictatorship. Edward is King of England and, in contrast to Macbeth, is portrayed as a good king, well-liked by his people. Malcolm, Duncan's son, is crowned King at the end ...

  4. Macbeth: Themes

    Themes are the fundamental and often universal ideas explored in a literary work. The Corrupting Power of Unchecked Ambition. The main theme of Macbeth —the destruction wrought when ambition goes unchecked by moral constraints—finds its most powerful expression in the play's two main characters. Macbeth is a courageous Scottish general who is not naturally inclined to commit evil deeds ...

  5. How To Write The Perfect Macbeth GCSE Essay On The Theme Of "Kingship

    Join my £10 GCSE 2024 Exams Masterclass. Enter Your GCSE Exams Feeling CONFIDENT & READY! https://www.firstratetutors.com/gcse-classes Check out our 'Ultimat...

  6. Kingship In Macbeth Essay Essay

    Kingship In Macbeth Essay. Kingship is a prevalent theme in Macbeth, one of William Shakespeares most well-known plays. Macbeth, the titular character, is thrust into the role of king after Duncan, his predecessor, is murdered. Macbeth is quickly overwhelmed by the responsibility of being king and this inexperience leads to him making a number ...

  7. Macbeth: A+ Student Essay: The Significance of ...

    A+ Student Essay: The Significance of Equivocation in Macbeth. Macbeth is a play about subterfuge and trickery. Macbeth, his wife, and the three Weird Sisters are linked in their mutual refusal to come right out and say things directly. Instead, they rely on implications, riddles, and ambiguity to evade the truth.

  8. What is the theme of kingship in Macbeth?

    Malcolm gives a useful list (in the same scene) of the kingly virtues: The king-becoming graces, verity, temperance, stableness, perseverance, mercy, lowliness, Devotion, patience, courage ...

  9. Macbeth Sample Essay: Kingship

    This is a H1 essay. Shakespeare's tragedy "Macbeth" contains an elaborate exploration of the theme of power and within that, the theme of kingship. The main character's evil plan aims at overthrowing the current ruler and assuming power over Scotland. Based on this the playwright profoundly analyses what qualities are the most important ...

  10. Essay exploring the importance of the theme of Kingship in Macbeth

    A level 9 essay exploring the importance of the theme of Kingship in Macbeth consisting of detailed and thoroughly explored points. This essay is guaranteed to help you get top marks. Each point is backed up by accurately quoted quotes and any relevant contextual points, all the ingredients needed in a top-notch essay.

  11. Kingship in Macbeth

    During the time of Shakespeare, people believed that kings were appointed by God, they are God's representatives on earth. The killing of the king was an evil act shown by Macbeth, showing the measures he would take to become king, even by destroying the natural order. He has gone against God and nature. In the beginning of act 1, scene 4 ...

  12. Macbeth

    This is an A* / L9 full mark example essay on Macbeth completed by a 15-year-old student in timed conditions (50 mins writing, 10 mins planning). It contained a few minor spelling and grammatical errors - but the quality of analysis overall was very high so this didn't affect the grade. It is extremely good on form and structure, and ...

  13. PDF AQA English Literature GCSE Macbeth: Themes

    In theory, Duncan would be the perfect king, but in reality he cannot contend with the wickedness of his peers . Macbeth At the start of the play Macbeth has the ideal qualities of a noble king. The Captain calls him "brave Macbeth" , "Bellona's bridegroom" , and "Valour's minion" (1.2) , proving how

  14. The Scrbbly Blog

    P1 — Intro — Shakespeare discusses the theme of deception in Macbeth by exploring Macbeth's insanity, showing the Macbeths covering their tracks and the temporary success with long term failure that deception brings. P2 — Macbeth's insanity — "oh full of scorpions is my mind", "could not I pronounce Amen" "Is this a dagger ...

  15. Macbeth Kingship Essay Essay

    Macbeth Kingship Essay. Since Macbeth was originally written in the early 17th century, the idea of kingship would have been significantly different from what it is today. In Shakespeare's time, the king was seen as a divine figurehead, placed on the throne by God himself. As a result, any action or decision made by the king was seen as an ...

  16. Macbeth Essay: Macbeth Kingship Exam Question and Detailed Essay Plan

    Resource type: Assessment and revision. File previews. docx, 15.93 KB. docx, 15.25 KB. An essay question on the idea of kingship in Macbeth, in the style of the new AQA Lit exam for GCSE. The resource can be used for guided homework and research, a collaborative task in class or on a shared document, or as a basis for your own modelling.

  17. Grade 9 Kingship in Macbeth Essay (Act 4 Scene 3, and whole play)

    pdf, 45.55 KB. A top band, Grade 9 essay on the question of: "Starting with this speech (Act 4 Scene 3), explore how Shakespeare presents the theme of Kingship in Macbeth". Full mark model to be used for revision, notes, or lesson examples. AQA and Edexcel suited, and written specifically for the AQA GCSE English Literature mark scheme.

  18. Macbeth

    Macbeth - Kingship Essay. With detailed reference to the characters of Macbeth, Duncan, Malcolm and Edward in the play Macbeth, analyse William Shakespeares ideas and attributes towards kingship and assess what you think the audiences reaction to the play would be at the time. Shakespeares ideas towards kingship can be seen throughout the play.

  19. Virtue, Trust, and Chaos in Macbeth's Kingdoms

    Delving into the rich tapestry of Macbeth, the exploration of various kings unfolds a nuanced understanding of the complexities entwined with kingship. Duncan's tragic flaws, Macbeth's descent into tyranny, Edward's virtuous reign, and Malcolm's restoration collectively contribute to a profound analysis of the impact different leadership styles ...

  20. Macbeth

    docx, 20.3 KB. Ideas of Kingship are integral in Shakespeare's 'Macbeth'. This resource puts forward a series of points (and accompanying evidence) for students to discuss and explore. It could even be used as the basis for an essay about Shakespeare's Presentation of Kingship in 'Macbeth'. It's uploaded as a Word document, in ...

  21. Macbeth: Kingship

    Overall Duncan is seen as a good person who is highly praised, this contrasts to Macbeths reign of tyranny. Give 3 quotes that relate Macbeth to Kingship. - 'Those he commands, move only in commands, nothing in love'. - 'Upon my head they placed a fruitless crown and put a barren sceptre in my grip'.

  22. Kingship in Macbeth

    A: (R) - topic sentence in relation to the question (I) - " O valiant cousin! worthy gentleman! " , "We will establish our estate upon our eldest , ,Malcolm , whom we name hereafter The Prince of Cumberland "- ref the q B: (C) " O valiant cousin! worthy gentleman!"- When Duncan hears of Macbeth's bravery on the battlefield , he praises him publicly , he was a king who recognised the sacrifices ...

  23. AQA GCSE English Section A: Macbeth

    Friendly and approachable Cambridge graduate and PhD student, committed to making English accessible to all. £45 / hour. SEND. Graduate. Book Tutor. FINAL PLACES REMAINING on our one-day Macbeth course 12th April and our two-day AQA English Language Course 8-9th April. Book now to avoid disappointment!

  24. Macbeth Guilt Essay

    Macbeth Guilt Essay; Macbeth Guilt Essay. 1172 Words 5 Pages. Guilt plays a major role in this play because of the characters actions that follow them throughout the entire play. Gradually, their guilt begins to consume them physiologically and physically. ... It all starts with the murder of the King Duncan. Macbeth and Lady Macbeth's drive ...

  25. Two Shakespearean Triumphs in Paris, or a Plague on Both Their Houses?

    The banquet scene, in which Macbeth is haunted by his victims' ghosts, is confined to a small confessional. In that scene, King Duncan, whose death paves the way for Macbeth's ascension ...

  26. According to Stephen King, This Is Why We Crave Horror Movies

    In 1981, King's essay titled "Why We Crave Horror Movies" was published in Playboy magazine as a variation of the chapter "The Horror Movie As Junk Food" in Danse Macabre.

  27. What Martin Luther King Jr. Knew About Crime and Mental Illness

    Mr. Bragg Jr. is the Manhattan district attorney. In September 1958, the Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. was stabbed with a seven-inch steel letter opener. He had been autographing copies of his ...