- Client Login
Bulletins | January 30, 2018
Assignment by way of security – beware of giving away more than you bargained for.
Construction
Assignment by way of security is a concept that comes up on many construction projects; typically as a condition of providing finance a funder will require an assignment by way of security of key construction documents, including building contracts and appointments, with the intention that if the borrower defaults on the loan, the assignment will be perfected and the funder will be entitled to enforce its rights under the constructions documents. How and when exactly such assignment takes place and the interplay with an employer’s rights under its contracts on a project was brought into focus in last year’s case of Mailbox (Birmingham) Limited v Galliford Try Construction Limited ([2017] EWHC 67 (TCC)).
Mailbox (Birmingham) Limited (“Mailbox”), the claimant special purpose vehicle set up to develop the Mailbox in Birmingham (“the Property”), a high-end mixed used development, boasting a Harvey Nichols and the base for BBC Birmingham, engaged Galliford Try Construction Limited (“Galliford”) for refurbishment works at the Property under a building contract dated 23 December 2013. A dispute arose between the parties regarding responsibility for delay, the final account, liquidated damages and Mailbox’s termination which was referred to adjudication, where Galliford were ordered to pay Mailbox £2,477,152.86 plus 75% of the adjudicator’s costs. Galliford did not pay the sums ordered, so Mailbox sought enforcement of the adjudicator’s decision in the High Court.
Did Mailbox have a right to bring an adjudication?
Galliford’s primary defence to the enforcement was that Mailbox had no right to bring the claim, as it had assigned the benefit of the building contract with Galliford to Aareal Bank AG Wiesbaden (“Aareal”) in accordance with the requirements of a debenture dated 10 May 2011. Mailbox raised three defences:
- The building contract was not in existence at the time of the assignment referred to in the debenture. Therefore there could be no assignment;
- Alternatively, any assignment was by way of charge rather than a legal assignment; or
- The contract had been re-assigned from Aareal to Mailbox before Mailbox commenced adjudication proceedings.
Mailbox failed on the first two defences, but won on the third so was able to enforce the adjudicator’s award. However, it was the analysis of the first and second defences and Mrs Justice O’Farrell’s review of the requirements for legal assignment under Section 138 of the Law of Property Act 1925 that are of particular note.
It was held that the wording of the debenture covered future contracts, including the building contract in question. The wording “each chargor with full title guarantee assigns absolutely by way of security in favour of the security trustee” amounted to a full legal assignment rather than an assignment by way of charge and/or a conditional assignment. Further, there was a requirement for notice of the assignment to be served and specific reference to rights being re-assigned, both of which were more akin to an absolute assignment. Express notice was given to Galliford, again consistent with an absolute assignment. Thankfully for Mailbox, on the day it commenced the adjudication, Aareal had re-assigned the rights under the building contract to Mailbox. If it had not done so, or done so after the adjudication had been commenced, Mailbox would not have been entitled to commence the adjudication.
Practical Tips
When obtaining finance for a project it is crucial to understand what the funder really requires in relation to security over construction documents. If all rights are assigned, the employer no longer has the ability to enforce such rights and may have given away more than he bargained for.
It may be that the use of collateral warranties or third party rights together with a charge will suffice but if not (which is unfortunately still the common position), it is important that any such rights are re-assigned before the employer commences an adjudication or any other proceedings.
Taking security over contractual rights
Published by a lexisnexis banking & finance expert.
Contractual rights are a type of chose in action , ie something that is recoverable by legal action as opposed to something that is physically possessed.
Security over contractual rights is typically taken by an assignment by way of security though it can also be taken by way of charge. Specific considerations apply to taking security over contractual rights. It is important to review the terms of the contract that is to be assigned from both the assignor and assignee's perspective. The assignee will also want to provide notice of the assignment to the contract counterparty because this has several important advantages.
This Practice Note deals with taking security over contractual rights in general. It explains:
the nature of contractual rights
typical methods of taking security over contractual rights
common provisions to check in the contract which is to be assigned, including governing law, restrictions on assignment and contractual rights of set-off
key terms to be included in the security document
issues relating to serving notice of the security on the contract counterparty,
Access this content for free with a 7 day trial of LexisNexis and benefit from:
- Instant clarification on points of law
- Smart search
- Workflow tools
- 41 practice areas
** Trials are provided to all LexisNexis content, excluding Practice Compliance, Practice Management and Risk and Compliance, subscription packages are tailored to your specific needs. To discuss trialling these LexisNexis services please email customer service via our online form. Free trials are only available to individuals based in the UK, Ireland and selected UK overseas territories and Caribbean countries. We may terminate this trial at any time or decide not to give a trial, for any reason. Trial includes one question to LexisAsk during the length of the trial.
Get your quote today and take step closer to being able to benefit from:
- 36 practice areas
Get a LexisNexis quote
* denotes a required field
To view the latest version of this document and thousands of others like it, sign-in with LexisNexis or register for a free trial.
Existing user? Sign-in CONTINUE READING GET A QUOTE
Continue reading
To read the full practice note, register for a free Lexis+ trial
Related legal acts:
- Law of Property Act 1925 (1925 c 20)
- Small Business, Enterprise and Employment Act 2015 (2015 c 26)
Key definition:
Chose in action definition, what does chose in action mean.
A right to something such as a payment of a debt or other contractual right that can be recovered through legal action
Popular documents
Do you need a deed of release as well as a ds1 to release a legal charge over land.
Do you need a deed of release as well as a DS1 to release a legal charge over land?Generally speaking, a deed of release is not necessary in addition to a form DS1 in order to release a charge registered at HM Land Registry.In the case of a legal mortgage of unregistered land, or a mortgage under
Scotland—the process for applying for sequestration
Scotland—the process for applying for sequestrationSequestration in Scotland is the legal process by which an insolvent debtor’s estate is gathered in, realised and then distributed among their creditors by a trustee appointed for that purpose. The process requires that a formal award of
Micklefield clauses
Micklefield clausesWhat is a Micklefield clause?It is common for employee share plans to provide that, on termination of employment (or when an employee is given or receives notice of termination of employment), subsisting share awards will be forfeited and subsisting share options will lapse.It is
Early leavers—preservation
Early leavers—preservationFORTHCOMING DEVELOPMENT: Section 10 of the Finance Act 2022 will increase the normal minimum pension age (NMPA) from 55 to 57 on 6 April 2028 (save for members of the firefighters, police and armed forces public service pension schemes).The Finance Act 2022 will also give
0330 161 1234
- International Sales(Includes Middle East)
- Latin America and the Caribbean
- Netherlands
- New Zealand
- Philippines
- South Africa
- Switzerland
- United States
Popular Links
- Supplier Payment Terms
- Partner Alliance Programme
HELP & SUPPORT
- Legal Help and Support
- Tolley Tax Help and Support
LEGAL SOLUTIONS
- Compliance and Risk
- Forms and Documents
- Legal Drafting
- Legal Research
- Magazines and Journals
- News and Media Analysis
- Practice Management
- Privacy Policy
- Cookie Settings
- Terms & Conditions
- Data Protection Inquiry
- Protecting Human Rights: Our Modern Slavery Agreement
The Government restricts bans on assignment
United Kingdom | Publication | November 2018
Legislation now in force preventing parties from prohibiting the assignment of receivables under certain contracts.
At the moment, a contract can prohibit or restrict the parties’ ability to assign or transfer rights created under the contract. The extent of the restriction is a matter of interpretation of the clause concerned. If one of the parties to the contract attempts to assign the benefit of the contract in breach of the restriction, the purported assignment is ineffective.
One of the key assets of any business is its receivables, and restrictions on assignment can prevent the parties from factoring receivables or otherwise raising finance on them. The Government has decided that it should be easier for businesses to raise finance on their receivables. Accordingly the Small Business, Enterprise and Employment Act 2015 allows regulations to be made to invalidate restrictions on the assignment of receivables in particular types of contract. The regulations have now been made. They are contained in The Business Contract Terms (Assignment of Receivables) Regulations 2018. Draft regulations published in July, have been approved by both Houses of Parliament and are now in force.
What types of contracts do the Regulations apply to?
The Regulations apply to contracts for the supply of goods, services or intangible assets under which the supplier is entitled to be paid money. But there are a number of important exclusions from their application, including the following:
- They only apply to contracts entered into on or after 31 December 2018.
- They only apply where the person who supplies the goods, services or intangible assets concerned, and is therefore entitled to the receivable, is a small or medium-sized enterprise which is not a special purpose vehicle. Whether or not an entity qualifies in any particular case requires a detailed examination of the precise wording of the
- Regulations. Counter-intuitively, the test is not applied at the time the contract is entered into, but at the time the assignment takes place.
- There is a specific exemption for contracts “for, or entered into in connection with, prescribed financial services”: These are widely defined to include “any service of a financial nature”.
- There are specific exclusions for particular types of contract, including certain commodities, project finance, energy, land, share purchase and business purchase contracts and operating leases.
- As a general rule, it would seem that the Regulations only apply to contracts governed by English law or the law of Northern Ireland, but they prevent the parties from choosing a foreign law if it can be established that the purpose of doing so was to evade the Regulations.
- The Regulations do not apply if none of the parties to the contract has entered into it in the course of carrying on a business in the United Kingdom.
What is the effect of the Regulations?
The Regulations provide that “a term in a contract has no effect to the extent that it prohibits or imposes a condition, or other restriction , on the assignment of a receivable arising under that contract or any other contract between the same parties.”
A receivable is the right to be paid any amount under a contract for the supply of goods, services, or intangible assets. The Regulations do not prevent the parties from restricting the assignment of other contract rights.
More difficult is to establish what is meant by assignment. Receivables are transferred in various ways in practice. Sometimes the transfer is outright (for instance by way of sale); and sometimes it is by way of security (for instance to secure a loan). The transfer may be effected by a statutory assignment, an equitable assignment, a charge or a trust. “Assignment” is not defined in the Regulations, and so there is some doubt as to which of these transactions are covered.
Although charges are not expressly referred to, they might be covered by the expression “assignment” if it is given a broad interpretation. But because of the uncertainty, the best course is to take an assignment by way of security over a receivable where there is, or might be, a restriction. That way, it is clear that the Regulations do apply.
Non-assignment clauses come in a variety of forms. They will be covered by the Regulations if they prohibit or impose a condition , or other restriction on the assignment of a receivable. The Regulations expressly invalidate terms which prevent the assignee from determining the validity or value of the receivable or their ability to enforce it. Whether or not the Regulations apply in any particular case will require an analysis of the precise terms of the restriction.
The Regulations will be of particular importance to businesses involved in the financing of receivables. And they will also be of concern to buyers because they will override their contractual protections.
- Financial institutions
Practice area:
- Banking and finance
Recent publications
Publication
Agreement on new EU gas projects and measures under the European Green Deal
On November 28, 2023, the European Commission (EC) adopted its first list of Projects of Common Interest (PCIs), i.e., projects within the EU territory, and Projects of Mutual Interest (PMIs), i.e., projects connecting the EU with other countries, including 166 projects implementing the European Green Deal.
Global | October 24, 2024
The GCR Guide to Life Sciences
Global | October 17, 2024
The GCR Guide to Life Sciences – Merger control: Procedural issues
Miranda Cole, Julien Haverals and Emma Clarke of our Brussels/ London offices are the authors of a chapter on procedural issues in merger control that has been published in the third edition of the Global Competition Review’s The Guide to Life Sciences. This covers a number of significant procedural developments that have affected merger review of life sciences transactions.
Subscribe and stay up to date with the latest legal news, information and events . . .
© Norton Rose Fulbright LLP 2023
- Canada (English)
- Canada (Français)
- United States
- Deutschland (Deutsch)
- Germany (English)
- The Netherlands
- Türkiye
- United Kingdom
- South Africa
- Hong Kong SAR
- Marshall Islands
- Nordic region
COMMENTS
Xxxx of Sale means the Initial Xxxx of Sale or an Additional Xxxx of Sale, as applicable. Assignment Form means the assignment form attached as Annex 2 hereto. Define Assignment by way of Security. means the assignment pursuant to which any rents deriving from the real estate assets subject to Mortgage have been assigned as security for the Loan.
Assignments by way of security are a type of mortgage. They involve: •. an assignment (ie transfer) of rights by the Assignor to the assignee. subject to: •. an obligation to reassign those rights back to the assignor upon the discharge of the obligations which have been secured. When the obligations that have been secured have been ...
An assignment by way of security is a type of mortgage. It involves an assignment (ie transfer) of rights by the assignor to the assignee subject to an obligation to reassign those rights back to the assignor upon the discharge of the obligations which have been secured.
This document is from Thomson Reuters Practical Law, the legal know-how that goes beyond primary law and traditional legal research to give lawyers a better starting point. We provide standard documents, checklists, legal updates, how-to guides, and more. 650+ full-time experienced lawyer editors globally create and maintain timely, reliable ...
Lenders commonly take security over "choses in action" (such as debts or rights under contracts) by way of assignment. An assignment involves the transfer of either legal ownership (legal ...
There are two types of assignment: legal and equitable. Legal assignments by way of security involve a transfer of legal ownership, with a proviso for re-assignment on satisfaction of the secured liabilities. A legal assignment is only possible in relation to assets which already exist (this excludes future assets). A sum becoming due
Assignment by way of security. A borrower's rights against third parties, such as the right to receive payment for debts on its own books, can be assigned to a third party as a way of selling those rights - this is an absolute, or direct, assignment. It is also possible to carry out an assignment by way of security over a borrower's choses in ...
An assignment can be entered into for different reasons. An Assignor may want to sell its rights under a contract for a price to raise cash or may need to sell its rights as security for a new borrowing from a third party. The latter is what is usually referred to as "security assignment" or "assignment by way of security".
On Oct. 2, 2019, Worthy sent New Style a notice of its security interest and collateral assignment in respect of amounts owed to Checkmate. Such notice specifically referred to UCC §9-406 and ...
An assignment may be either a legal assignment or an equitable assignment. For more information on assigning rights under a contract, see Practice note, Contracts: assignment . In finance transactions, assignments may be used as a way to take security over, for example, choses in action .
if there is an outright assignment coupled with an entitlement to a re-assignment back once the secured obligation has been performed, it is an assignment by way of legal mortgage. Please see our separate Out-Law guide for more information on types of security. Restrictions on assignment. There are restrictions on the assignment of certain ...
Background. Assignment by way of security is a concept that comes up on many construction projects; typically as a condition of providing finance a funder will require an assignment by way of security of key construction documents, including building contracts and appointments, with the intention that if the borrower defaults on the loan, the assignment will be perfected and the funder will be ...
This document is from Thomson Reuters Practical Law, the legal know-how that goes beyond primary law and traditional legal research to give lawyers a better starting point. We provide standard documents, checklists, legal updates, how-to guides, and more. 650+ full-time experienced lawyer editors globally create and maintain timely, reliable ...
Examples of Assignment of Security in a sentence. If there is a separate security agreement or chattel mortgage, an Assignment of Security Agreement is required.. A signed and completed Assignment of Security form approved by the Board shall accompany all Certificates of Deposit.. Assignment of Security interest on the borrower's rights, title and interest to the extent covered by and in ...
Practice notes. Contractual rights are a type of chose in action, ie something that is recoverable by legal action as opposed to something that is physically possessed. Security over contractual rights is typically taken by an assignment by way of security though it can also be taken by way of charge. Specific considerations apply to taking ...
Security Assignment means the assignment agreements dated 20 April 2004 providing for the assignment to the Security Agent of the fixed and current assets of the Borrower. Sample 1 Sample 2 Sample 3. Based on 4 documents. Security Assignment means, that certain Deed of Assignment by way of Security dated on or about the Original Restatement ...
Although charges are not expressly referred to, they might be covered by the expression "assignment" if it is given a broad interpretation. But because of the uncertainty, the best course is to take an assignment by way of security over a receivable where there is, or might be, a restriction. That way, it is clear that the Regulations do apply.
Examples of Assignment of Security Interest in a sentence. The recordation of the Assignment of Security Interest in U.S. Patents and Trademarks in the form attached to the Security Agreement in the United States Patent and Trademark Office together with filings on Form UCC-1 made pursuant to the Security Agreement will be effective, under applicable law, to perfect the security interest ...
A standard form security assignment of contractual rights, created by a company incorporated in England and Wales in favour of a single corporate lender. This standard document creates a mortgage by way of assignment over the benefit of specified contracts entered into by the company and over the benefit of specified insurance policies taken ...
Define interest by way of security. means any mortgage, pledge, lien, charge, assignment by way of security, hypothecation, title retention, finance lease, factoring or discounting of debts or any other agreement or arrangement for or by way of security, including such as arises or is imposed by operation or implication of applicable law and including any account with bankers earmarked or ...