My Courses

Stalin Five Year Plan Essay Grade 11 History Memorandum (Questions and Answers)

' src=

An answer guide for Stalin Five Year Plan Essay History Grade 11 with memorandum on pdf:

The Five Year Plan was a set of economic goals that were developed in the Soviet Union under the leadership of Joseph Stalin. The plan was launched in 1928, and it aimed to transform the Soviet Union from an agricultural economy into an industrial powerhouse.

One of the main goals of the Five Year Plan was to increase the production of heavy industry, such as steel and machinery, in order to support the growth of other industries. The Soviet Union was still primarily an agricultural country at the time, so this was a significant shift in economic policy.

Another key goal of the Five Year Plan was to improve the infrastructure of the Soviet Union, including transportation and communication systems. This was important in order to support the growth of industry and to facilitate the movement of goods and people throughout the country.

The Five Year Plan was implemented through a series of measures, including the collectivization of agriculture, the nationalization of industry, and the use of central planning to direct economic activity. The government also encouraged the development of new technologies and the training of skilled workers to support the growth of industry.

The results of the Five Year Plan were mixed. On the one hand, the Soviet Union did experience significant industrial growth during this time, and the country’s infrastructure was greatly improved. However, the focus on heavy industry came at the expense of consumer goods and agriculture, and many people suffered as a result. The collectivization of agriculture led to a famine in which millions of people died, and the forced labor camps that were established to support the growth of industry were infamous for their harsh conditions and human rights abuses.

In conclusion, the Five Year Plan was a bold and ambitious economic program that aimed to transform the Soviet Union into an industrial powerhouse. While it did lead to significant industrial growth, it came at a great cost to many people, and its legacy continues to be debated to this day.

Do you need Help with your History Grade 11 Essay for 2023?

Please submit the pdf with the questions below:

[super_form id=”134203″]

Common Essay Questions

Here are ten potential essay questions on the Stalin Five Year Plan for Grade 11 :

  • What were the goals of the Stalin Five Year Plan, and how were they intended to transform the Soviet economy and society?
  • How did Stalin’s Five Year Plan differ from the New Economic Policy (NEP) that had been in place in the Soviet Union during the 1920s?
  • What were some of the successes of the Stalin Five Year Plan, and how did they contribute to the growth of the Soviet economy?
  • What were some of the challenges and failures of the Stalin Five Year Plan, and how did they impact the Soviet Union?
  • What role did forced labor and purges play in the implementation of the Stalin Five Year Plan, and what were their consequences?
  • What were the economic and social consequences of collectivization, which was a major aspect of the Stalin Five Year Plan?
  • How did the Stalin Five Year Plan affect the lives of ordinary Soviet citizens, particularly workers and peasants?
  • What was the role of propaganda in promoting the Stalin Five Year Plan, and how did it shape public perceptions of the plan?
  • How did the Stalin Five Year Plan impact the global balance of power, and what were its implications for the emerging Cold War?
  • What lessons can be learned from the Stalin Five Year Plan, and how do they relate to current debates about economic planning and socialism?

COMMUNISM IN RUSSIA 1900 T0 1940: STALIN’S INTERPRETATION OF MARXISM

Answer Guide for Stalin Five Year Plan Essay Grade 11

SYNOPSIS In writing this essay, candidates should be able to take a line of argument and critically discuss how Stalin, through the series of Five Year plans changed the economy of the Soviet Union and made it a superpower.

MAIN ASPECTS Candidates should include the following aspects in their response: Introduction: Candidates should contextualize the question and establish a clear line of argument

ELABORATION

  • Lenin’s death
  • Abandonment of NEP
  • Aims of the 5Year plans
  • Collectivisation of agriculture
  • Elimination of the Kulaks
  • Modernization of farming
  • Grain requisition
  • Rapid industralisation
  • Development of heavy industries
  • Improvement of transport and communication net works
  • Exploitation of newly discovered mineral wealth
  • Rapid urbanisation
  • Electrification
  • Force labour
  • Police state and party purges
  • Any other relevant response

Conclusion: Candidates should round up their argument with a relevant and contextualized conclusion

Download the complete memorandum:

View all History Grade 11 Study resources Here

Looking for something specific?

Leave a comment.

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

You May Also Like

Violation of Human Rights in South Africa: A Dark Decade (1950-1960)

Violation of Human Rights in South Africa: A Dark Decade (1950-1960)

Questions and Answers based on Bantu Education Act for Revision

Questions and Answers based on Bantu Education Act for Revision

Reasons Why is the District Six Museum Famous?

Reasons Why the District Six Museum is so Famous?

How is Heritage Day celebrated in schools in South Africa?

How is Heritage Day celebrated in schools in South Africa?

History Hit

Sign Up Today

Start your 14 day free trial today

joseph stalin 5 year plan essay

History Hit Story of England: Making of a Nation

  • 20th Century

What Were Stalin’s Five Year Plans?

joseph stalin 5 year plan essay

Celeste Neill

20 jun 2023.

joseph stalin 5 year plan essay

On 1 October 1928 Joseph Stalin’s Soviet Russia launched the first Five Year Plan, a series of revolutionary economic reforms which transformed Russia from a peasant society into a power capable of resisting the might of Hitler’s Germany.

Bolshevik leader Vladimir Lenin had died in 1924, and in the ensuing power struggle the Georgian Joseph Stalin came to the fore as the General Secretary and the de facto leader of Soviet Russia. 

What was Stalin’s Five Year Plan?

Between 1928 and 1932, Stalin’s Five Year Plan was targeted at collectivizing agriculture and developing heavy industry. This was the first of four so-called plans, which took place in 1928-32, 1933-37, 1938-42 and 1946-53.

After a period of relative economic liberalism Stalin decided that a wholesale restructuring of the economy was needed, claiming that unless the Soviets caught up with the capitalist western powers they would be destroyed.

Stalin famously stated: ”We are fifty or a hundred years behind the advanced countries. We must make up this gap in ten years. Either we do it or they will crush us.”

joseph stalin 5 year plan essay

The requisition of grains from wealthy peasants (kulaks) during the forced collectivization in Timashyovsky District, Kuban Soviet Union. 1933. Image credit: Public Domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Image Credit: Credited to U. Druzhelubov. The date of death is impossible to determine therefore PMA is not known., Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Mechanisation and collectivisation

Stalin’s first Five Year Plan involved the mechanisation and collectivisation of agriculture in a bid to make it more efficient. It also involved the opening of huge new industrial centres in previously uninhabited areas rich in natural resources, such as Magnitogorsk, built near huge iron and steel reserves east of the Ural Mountains.

Economic activity was pushed in the direction of heavy industries, which lead to a 350 percent increase in output, in a bid to prepare Russia for an industrialised war . The first Five Year Plan also had a revolutionary effect on society, as millions left the farms to pursue new lives in the cities.

The human cost

Despite these successes, Stalin’s Five Year Plan was not an unqualified success. In addition to mechanisation and collectivisation, key features of the first Five Year Plan included the disastrous impact it had on human lives. Aside from the terrible conditions in the new factories, where unskilled workers had little idea of how to operate machines, the collectivisation of agriculture was ruinous.

joseph stalin 5 year plan essay

Political prisoners eating lunch in the Minlag ‘special camp’ coal mine. In ‘special camps’ prisoners had to wear prison garb with personal numbers. Image credit: Public Domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Image Credit: Kauno IX forto muziejus / Kaunas 9th Fort Museum, Public Domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Millions died in the subsequent famine and peasant disturbances. An entire social class of wealthier peasants – the Kulaks, who had accumulated more land, livestock, or wealth than their fellow peasants — were accused of sabotaging the progress of the Plan. Consequently they were either massacred or imprisoned in Gulags , which were forced labour camps, so that the state could exploit their land for collectivisation.

As many of the deaths were in non-Russian areas such as Ukraine, the Five Year Plan created lasting divisions between Russians and non-Russians.

The policies also played a role in causing the Holodomor, a mass famine in the Ukraine, and Soviet inactivity in response to the catastrophe has lead to a recent re-categorisation of events as a genocide against the Ukrainian people.

World War Two

In World War Two , the tensions caused by the first Five Year Plan proved consequential. Ukrainians, for example, who were subject to its disastrous effects were more willing to collaborate with the Nazis against the USSR.

joseph stalin 5 year plan essay

The first Five Year Plan actually lasted 4 years, as it supposedly met all of its objectives earlier than expected. On the other hand, this can be ascribed to Russian propaganda efforts. Nevertheless, the first plan and those that followed, which continued the general objectives of the first while also emphasising the production of military hardware , were critical in preparing Russia for an industrialised war.

It seems unlikely that Russia could have resisted Nazi invasion without the immense industrialisation program that had been undertaken in the years prior. However, the vast cost in human life of the Five Year Plans and the invasion of Russia itself remain a dark stain on the history of the 20th century.

You May Also Like

joseph stalin 5 year plan essay

The Strange Sport of Pedestrianism Got Victorians Hooked on Coca

joseph stalin 5 year plan essay

Puzzle Over These Ancient Greek Paradoxes

joseph stalin 5 year plan essay

In Ancient Rome, Gladiators Rarely Fought to the Death

joseph stalin 5 year plan essay

Archaeologists Uncover Two Roman Wells on a British Road

joseph stalin 5 year plan essay

Young Stalin Made His Name as a Bank Robber

joseph stalin 5 year plan essay

3 Things We Learned from Meet the Normans with Eleanor Janega

joseph stalin 5 year plan essay

Reintroducing ‘Dan Snow’s History Hit’ Podcast with a Rebrand and Refresh

joseph stalin 5 year plan essay

Don’t Try This Tudor Health Hack: Bathing in Distilled Puppy Juice

joseph stalin 5 year plan essay

Coming to History Hit in August

joseph stalin 5 year plan essay

Coming to History Hit in September

joseph stalin 5 year plan essay

Coming to History Hit in October

joseph stalin 5 year plan essay

The Plimsoll Line: How Samuel Plimsoll Made Sailing Safer

  • Lifestyles & Social Issues
  • Philosophy & Religion
  • Politics, Law & Government
  • World History
  • Health & Medicine
  • Browse Biographies
  • Birds, Reptiles & Other Vertebrates
  • Bugs, Mollusks & Other Invertebrates
  • Environment
  • Fossils & Geologic Time
  • Geography & Travel
  • Entertainment & Pop Culture
  • Sports & Recreation
  • Visual Arts

Britannica Money

Five-Year Plans

Holodomor

Five-Year Plans , method of planning economic growth over limited periods, through the use of quotas, used first in the Soviet Union and later in other socialist states.

In the Soviet Union the first Five-Year Plan (1928–32), implemented by Joseph Stalin , concentrated on developing heavy industry and collectivizing agriculture, at the cost of a drastic fall in consumer goods. The second Five-Year Plan (1933–37) continued the objectives of the first. Collectivization, coupled with other Stalinist policies, led to terrible famines that caused the deaths of millions of people. The man-made famine in Ukraine in 1932–33, known as the Holodomor , has been recognized as an attempted genocide against the Ukrainian people. The third Five-Year Plan (1938–42) emphasized the production of armaments. The fourth (1946–53) again stressed heavy industry and military buildup, angering the Western powers.

In China the first Five-Year Plan (1953–57) stressed rapid industrial development, with Soviet assistance; it proved highly successful. Shortly after the second plan began in 1958, the Great Leap Forward was announced; its goals conflicted with the Five-Year Plan, leading to failure and the withdrawal of Soviet aid in 1960.

Primary Source 27.2: Stalin Justifies the Five-Year Plan

On February 4, 1931, Joseph Stalin delivered the following address, titled “No Slowdown in Tempo!” to the First Conference of Soviet Industrial Managers. Published the following day in Pravda , the newspaper of the Communist Party, and widely publicized at home and abroad, Stalin’s speech reaffirmed the leader’s commitment to the breakneck pace of industrialization and collectivization set forth in the first five-year plan. Arguing that more sacrifices were necessary, Stalin sought to rally the people and generate support for the party’s program. His address captures the spirit of Soviet ideology in the early 1930s.

Stalin’s concluding idea, that Bolsheviks needed to master technology and industrial management, reflected another major development. The Soviet Union was training a new class of Communist engineers and technicians, who were beginning to replace foreign engineers and “bourgeois specialists,” Russian engineers trained in tsarist times who were grudgingly tolerated in the first years after the revolution.

image

To slacken the tempo would mean falling behind. And those who fall behind get beaten. But we do not want to be beaten. No, we refuse to be beaten! One feature of the history of old Russia was the continual beatings she suffered because of her backwardness. She was beaten by the Mongol khans, … the Turkish beys, … and the Japanese barons. All beat her — because of her backwardness, cultural backwardness, political backwardness, industrial backwardness, agricultural backwardness. They beat her because to do so was profitable and could be done with impunity…. Such is the law of the exploiters — to beat the backward and the weak. It is the jungle law of capitalism. You are backward, you are weak — therefore you are wrong; hence you can be beaten and enslaved. You are mighty — therefore you are right; hence we must be wary of you. That is why we must no longer lag behind.

In the past we had no fatherland, nor could we have had one. But now that we have overthrown capitalism and power is in our hands, in the hands of the people, we have a fatherland, and we will uphold its independence. Do you want our socialist fatherland to be beaten and to lose its independence?

If you do not want this, you must put an end to its backwardness in the shortest possible time and develop a genuine Bolshevik tempo in building up its socialist economy. There is no other way. That is why Lenin said on the eve of the October Revolution: “Either perish, or overtake and outstrip the advanced capitalist countries.”

We are fifty or a hundred years behind the advanced countries. We must make good this distance in ten years. Either we do it, or we shall go under. That is what our obligations to the workers and peasants of the U.S.S.R. dictate to us.

But we have yet other, more serious and more important, obligations. They are our obligations to the world proletariat…. We achieved victory not solely through the efforts of the working class of the U.S.S.R., but also thanks to the support of the working class of the world. Without this support we would have been torn to pieces long ago….

Why does the international proletariat support us? How did we merit this support? By the fact that we were the first to hurl ourselves into the battle against capitalism, we were the first to establish working-class state power, we were the first to begin building socialism. By the fact that we are engaged on a cause which, if successful, will transform the whole world and free the entire working class. But what is needed for success? The elimination of our backwardness, the development of a high Bolshevik tempo of construction. We must march forward in such a way that the working class of the whole world, looking at us, may say:

There you have my advanced detachment, my shock brigade, my working-class state power, my fatherland; they are engaged on their cause, our cause, and they are working well; let us support them against the capitalists and promote the cause of the world revolution. Must we not justify the hopes of the world’s working class, must we not fulfill our obligations to them? Yes, we must if we do not want to utterly disgrace ourselves.

Such are our obligations, internal and international.

As you see, they dictate to us a Bolshevik tempo of development.

I will not say that we have accomplished nothing in regard to management of production during these years. In fact, we have accomplished a good deal…. But we could have accomplished still more if we had tried during this period really to master production, the technique of production, the financial and economic side of it. In ten years at most we must make good the distance that separates us from the advanced capitalist countries. We have all the “objective” possibilities for this. The only thing lacking is the ability to make proper use of these possibilities.

And that depends on us. Only on us! … If you are a factory manager — interfere in all the affairs of the factory, look into everything, let nothing escape you, learn and learn again. Bolsheviks must master technique. It is time Bolsheviks themselves became experts….

It is said that it is hard to master technique. That is not true! There are no fortresses that Bolsheviks cannot capture. We have solved a number of most difficult problems. We have overthrown capitalism. We have assumed power.

image

Source: Joseph Stalin, “No Slowdown in Tempo!” Pravda , February 5, 1931, excerpted from “Reading No. 14” in Soviet Economic Development: Operation Outstrip, 1921–1965 , by Anatole G. Mazour.

EVALUATE THE EVIDENCE

Explaining History Podcast

Modern history podcasts for students and enthusiasts

How to write an essay about Stalin’s Five Year Plans

How to write an essay on stalin’s five year plans: a comprehensive guide.

Stalin’s Five Year Plans were a series of centralized economic plans implemented in the Soviet Union from 1928 to 1932. These plans aimed to transform the Soviet Union from an agricultural society into an industrialized nation through rapid industrialization and collectivization of agriculture. The plans were characterized by ambitious production targets, strict state control, and the use of forced labor.

Writing an essay on Stalin’s Five Year Plans can be a challenging task, but with the right approach, it can be a rewarding experience. To begin with, it is important to understand the historical context in which the plans were implemented and the impact they had on the Soviet Union and its people. This requires a thorough analysis of primary and secondary sources, including government documents, speeches, and scholarly articles.

Moreover, a successful essay on Stalin’s Five Year Plans should also address the controversies and debates surrounding the plans. While some historians argue that the plans were necessary for the Soviet Union’s survival and modernization, others criticize the plans for their human cost and inefficiencies. By examining multiple perspectives and sources, a well-crafted essay can provide a nuanced understanding of this complex historical topic.

Section 2: Historical Background

Joseph Stalin was the leader of the Soviet Union from 1924 until his death in 1953. He was known for his strong leadership and his desire to modernize the Soviet Union. Stalin believed that the Soviet Union needed to catch up with the industrialized Western countries in order to protect itself from foreign threats.

In order to achieve this goal, Stalin introduced a series of Five Year Plans. These plans were designed to rapidly industrialize the Soviet Union and transform it from an agricultural society into an industrial powerhouse. The first Five Year Plan was launched in 1928 and focused on heavy industry, such as steel production and coal mining.

The Soviet Union had a long way to go to catch up with the industrialized nations of the West. The country had been devastated by World War I, the Russian Revolution, and the subsequent civil war. The economy was in shambles, and the country was facing widespread famine and poverty. Stalin’s Five Year Plans were seen as a way to modernize the country and improve the lives of its citizens.

However, the Five Year Plans were not without their drawbacks. The rapid industrialization came at a great cost to the people of the Soviet Union. Workers were forced to work long hours in dangerous conditions for low pay. Many were sent to labor camps or executed for failing to meet production quotas. The agricultural sector suffered as resources were diverted to heavy industry, leading to widespread famine and starvation.

Despite these drawbacks, the Five Year Plans were largely successful in achieving their goal of modernizing the Soviet Union. By the end of the Second World War, the Soviet Union had become a major industrial power, with a strong military and a growing economy. The legacy of Stalin’s Five Year Plans can still be seen in modern-day Russia, where heavy industry continues to play a major role in the country’s economy.

Overview of Stalin’s Five Year Plans

Stalin’s Five Year Plans were a series of centralized economic plans in the Soviet Union from 1928 to 1932. The main objective of these plans was to rapidly industrialize the country and modernize the economy. The first Five Year Plan focused on heavy industry, such as steel, coal, and machinery production, while subsequent plans emphasized the development of consumer goods and agriculture.

The Five Year Plans were implemented through a series of strict quotas and targets that were set by the government. These targets were often unrealistic and led to a number of negative consequences, including widespread famine, labor shortages, and poor working conditions. However, the plans also led to significant advancements in Soviet industry, particularly in the production of heavy machinery and steel.

The Five Year Plans were accompanied by a number of political changes, including the elimination of private enterprise and the collectivization of agriculture. These policies were often enforced through violent means, such as the forced relocation of peasants and the execution of political dissidents.

Despite the significant human cost of the Five Year Plans, they are often credited with transforming the Soviet Union from an agricultural society into an industrial powerhouse. The plans laid the groundwork for the country’s rapid industrialization during World War II and its subsequent emergence as a superpower during the Cold War.

Key Features of Stalin’s Five Year Plans

The Five Year Plans were a series of centralized economic plans in the Soviet Union, created under the leadership of Joseph Stalin. The first plan was launched in 1928 and the last one ended in 1952. These plans were designed to transform the Soviet Union from an agricultural country into an industrial powerhouse.

The key features of Stalin’s Five Year Plans are:

  • Centralized Planning:  The Soviet government controlled all economic decisions, and the plans were created by a central planning agency. The government set targets for production, and factories were required to meet these targets.
  • Industrialization:  The main goal of the Five Year Plans was to rapidly industrialize the Soviet Union. This was achieved through the construction of new factories, power plants, and transportation infrastructure.
  • Collectivization:  The government forced farmers to give up their private land and join collective farms. This was done to increase agricultural productivity and provide a source of food for the growing urban population.
  • Heavy Industry:  The Five Year Plans focused on the development of heavy industry, such as steel production and machine building. This was seen as essential for the modernization of the Soviet economy.
  • Rapid Growth:  The Soviet Union experienced rapid economic growth during the Five Year Plans, with industrial production increasing by over 250% between 1928 and 1937.

Despite the successes of the Five Year Plans, there were also significant costs. The forced collectivization of agriculture led to widespread famine and the deaths of millions of people. The focus on heavy industry also meant that consumer goods were in short supply, and living standards for ordinary people were often low.

Writing the Essay: Tips and Strategies

When writing an essay about Stalin’s Five Year Plans, it is important to keep in mind the purpose of the essay. The purpose is to analyze and evaluate the effectiveness of the Five Year Plans in achieving their goals, and to provide evidence to support your arguments.

One tip for writing a successful essay is to start with a clear thesis statement. The thesis statement should clearly state your argument and provide a roadmap for the rest of the essay. It should be specific and concise, and should be supported by evidence from primary and secondary sources.

Another strategy for writing a successful essay is to organize your ideas into a logical structure. This can be done by creating an outline or a mind map, which will help you to identify the main points of your argument and how they relate to each other. You can then use this structure to guide the writing process, ensuring that each paragraph and section of the essay contributes to the overall argument.

When writing the essay, it is important to use evidence to support your arguments. This can include statistics, quotes from primary sources, and analysis of secondary sources. It is also important to acknowledge and address counterarguments, as this will demonstrate that you have considered multiple perspectives and have a nuanced understanding of the topic.

Finally, it is important to proofread and edit your essay carefully. This will ensure that the essay is free from errors and is presented in a clear and concise manner. You can also ask a friend or family member to read over your essay and provide feedback, as this can help you to identify areas for improvement and refine your argument.

Sample Outline for an Essay on Stalin’s Five Year Plans

When writing an essay on Stalin’s Five Year Plans, it’s important to have a clear and well-organized outline. This will help you stay focused and ensure that your essay is coherent and easy to follow. Here is a sample outline to get you started:

I. Introduction

  • Brief overview of Stalin’s Five Year Plans
  • Thesis statement

II. Background Information

  • Historical context and political climate in Soviet Union during the time of the Five Year Plans
  • Overview of the economic conditions in the Soviet Union before the implementation of the Five Year Plans

III. Implementation of the Five Year Plans

  • Overview of the first, second, and third Five Year Plans
  • Details on the specific goals and targets of each plan
  • Discussion on the methods used to achieve these goals, including collectivization and industrialization

IV. Impact of the Five Year Plans

  • Economic outcomes of the Five Year Plans, including improvements in industrial production and agricultural output
  • Social impacts of the Five Year Plans, including changes in living standards and working conditions
  • Political implications of the Five Year Plans, including the consolidation of Stalin’s power and the impact on Soviet foreign policy

V. Criticisms of the Five Year Plans

  • Overview of the criticisms leveled against the Five Year Plans, including their impact on the environment and human rights abuses
  • Discussion on the validity of these criticisms and their impact on the legacy of the Five Year Plans

VI. Conclusion

  • Restatement of thesis
  • Summary of key points
  • Final thoughts on the significance of the Five Year Plans in Soviet history

By following this outline, you can ensure that your essay on Stalin’s Five Year Plans is well-structured and informative. Remember to use credible sources and avoid making exaggerated or false claims. Good luck!

Stalin’s Five Year Plans were a significant milestone in the history of the Soviet Union. They were aimed at transforming the country from an agrarian society into an industrialized one. The plans were successful in achieving the desired results, but at a great cost. The human toll was immense, with millions of people dying due to famine and forced labor. The plans were also criticized for their lack of focus on consumer goods and their overemphasis on heavy industry.

Despite the criticisms, the Five Year Plans had a lasting impact on the Soviet Union. They laid the foundation for the country’s industrialization and helped it become a superpower. The plans also set the stage for the country’s involvement in World War II and its eventual victory over Nazi Germany.

Writing an essay on Stalin’s Five Year Plans requires a deep understanding of the historical context and the impact of the plans on the Soviet Union. It is important to present a balanced view of the plans, highlighting both their achievements and their shortcomings. By doing so, the essay can provide a nuanced understanding of one of the most significant events in Soviet history.

Share this:

Leave a comment cancel reply.

' src=

  • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
  • Subscribe Subscribed
  • Copy shortlink
  • Report this content
  • View post in Reader
  • Manage subscriptions
  • Collapse this bar

joseph stalin 5 year plan essay

Spartacus Educational

Stalin's five year plan, primary sources, (1) joseph stalin, speech (1931).

No comrades... the pace must not be slackened! On the contrary, we must quicken it as much as is within our powers and possibilities. To slacken the pace would mean to lag behind; and those who lag behind are beaten.... The history of old Russia... was that she was ceaselessly beaten for her backwardness. She was beaten by the Mongol Khans, she was beaten by Turkish Beys, she was beaten by Swedish feudal lords, she was beaten by Polish-Lithuanian Pans, she was beaten by Anglo-French capitalists, she was beaten by Japanese barons, she was beaten by all - for her backwardness... We are fifty or a hundred years behind the advanced countries. we must make good this lag in years. Either we do it or they crush us.

(2) British Embassy report (21st June 1932)

A record of over-staffing, overplanning and complete incompetence at the centre; of human misery, starvation, death and disease among the peasantry... the only creatures who have any life at all in the districts visited are boars, pigs and other swine. Men, women, and children, horses and other workers are left to die in order that the Five Year Plan shall at least succeed on paper.

(3) Eugene Lyons , Assignment in Utopia (1937)

The period of the Five Year Plan has been christened Russia's "Iron Age" by the best-informed and least sensational of my American colleagues in Moscow, William Henry Chamberlin. I can think of no more apt description. Iron symbolizes industrial construction and mechanization. Iron symbolizes no less the ruthlessness of the process, the bayonets, prison bars, rigid discipline and unstinting force, the unyielding and unfeeling determination of those who directed the period. Russia was transformed into a crucible in which men and metals were melted down and reshaped in a cruel heat, with small regard for the human slag. It was a period that unrolled tumultuously, in a tempest of brutality. The Five Year Plan was publicized inside and outside Russia as no other economic project in modern history. Which makes it the more extraordinary that its birth was unknown and unnoticed. The Plan sneaked up on the world so silently that its advent was not discovered for some months. On the momentous October first of 1928, the initial day of the Five Year Plan, we read the papers, fretted over the lack of news and played bridge or poker as though nothing exceptional was occurring. It was the beginning of a new fiscal year, precisely like the October firsts preceding it. The "control figures" or plan for the ensuing twelve months were rather more ambitious, with new emphasis on socialization of farming through state-owned "grain factories" and voluntary collectives of small holdings. But they were not sufficiently different from other years to arrest the attention of competent observers. The fact is that the Kremlin itself was far from certain that a new era had been launched. It had not yet charted a course. Or rather, it had charted alternative courses and hesitated in which direction to move. Not until Stalin and his closest associates see fit to reveal what happened in the crucial months of that autumn will we know how close the Soviet regime came to choosing a course which would have altered the whole history of Russia and therefore of the present world. There was nothing in the figures for the fiscal year of 1929 that committed the ruling Party to a Five Year Plan of the scope eventually announced. But a feeling of tense expectancy now stretched the country's nerves taut. A sharp turn of the wheel to one side or the other was inevitable, and the population squared for the shock. Economic difficulties were piling up dangerously and the Kremlin could not steer a middle course much longer. Food lines were growing longer and more restive. The producers of food had tested their strength and tasted a measure of victory; they rebelled more boldly against feeding the urban population and the armies for rubles which could buy nothing. Millions of grumbling mouths had to be either filled with food or shut by force. A partial crop failure in southern Russia aggravated the situation. Grain collections were not going well and, as always happened under these circumstances, the collectors began to resort to strong-arm tactics. Arson and assassination flared up once more in the villages, and Red troops were said to be "pacifying" the most unruly districts with lead. Schools, clubs, government buildings, and other institutions typifying the Soviet power were burned down in dozens of places. The published details of the peasant revenge were sufficiently harrowing, and what the press reported, we all assumed, was no more than a fraction of the picture. Death penalties, with and without trials, were the government's automatic answer. But they did not suffice. Something decisive had to be done that would either placate the peasants or end their insubordination.

(4) James William Crowl , Angels in Stalin's Paradise (1982)

With the defeat of Trotsky and the Left Wing in 1927, Stalin apparently began to look for a way to outmaneuver the final power bloc in the Party: the Right Wing led by Bukharin, Rykov and Tomsky. It was not by accident that the economy provided him with the issues he needed to destroy his erstwhile allies. Midway through 1927 the Politburo had initiated an ambitious economic program that included a number of expansive construction projects such as the Turkish-Siberia railroad and the Dnieper dam. Such an undertaking involved a risk since it was to be underwritten largely by the sale of grain, and the grain collection program had become increasingly unreliable during the mid-1920's. The yearly crises stemmed in part from insufficient supplies of consumer goods, but they were even more the result of the low price the government offered for grain. As a result of that price, peasants turned over to the state only the grain they were required to deliver through the procurement quotas, and they sold the rest through Nepmen on the private market where the price was substantially higher. Yet, in order to raise the additional revenue needed for the industrial program in 1927, the state dropped its price for grain still lower and cracked down on the private market in an effort to force the peasants to sell their grain to the state at the lower price. The peasants responded, however, by feeding their grain to their cattle, turning it into alcohol, or hoarding it in expectation of higher prices. By late 1927, grain collections fell off more sharply than in earlier years, and the regime faced a crisis. Signs of disagreement over the response to the crisis appeared as early as October 1927. Stalin and his henchmen sounded the need for anti-kulak measures, while Bukharin and his allies worried aloud about the lagging collections but insisted on the need for caution in finding a solution. Unity was maintained at the Fifteenth Party Congress in December, however, as even the Politburo rightists agreed that action was needed to convince the peasants to relinquish their supplies. Thus the Congress that vanquished Trotsky fairly bristled with leftist declarations. A heavier, graduated procurement tax was issued that hit directly at the kulaks and promised to bring the state additional grain. In addition, a land act rescinded the right to hire labor and lease land that had been granted to peasants in 1925 and 1926, and kulaks were deprived of their voting rights in order to curtail their power in the village soviets. The Congress encouraged collectivization as well, although it stressed that it should be a gradual and voluntary process. Because of such measures, the Fifteenth Congress is often cited as marking the end of the N.E.P, era. In the weeks following the Congress, Bukharin, Rykov and Tomsky apparently again supported Stalin in the attempt to compel the peasants to turn over their grain. Stalin was given control of the effort, and he singled out West Siberia for his personal attention since the harvest there had been excellent and the peasants were believed to be holding back substantial grain supplies. Though the Politburo still issued reassuring reports claiming that the Party had not broken with past agricultural policy, the Soviet press wrote about the grain "front" as if a military campaign had begun. Violence was widespread as officials tried to ferret out the grain, and Alec Nove claims that for some time thereafter such arbitrary and violent grain seizures were referred to as the "Urals-Siberian" method, after Stalin's tactics of early 1928. Though grain collections lagged and even the new procurement quotas fell short in January and February, by March the grain seizures were successfully at last in bringing the state the needed grain. Until February and March of 1928, when the confrontation with the peasants reached a highpoint, it appears that Bukharin reluctantly agreed that temporary measures against grain-hoarding were necessary. The violence of the campaign was repulsive to the Politburo Right, however, and jolted it into an awareness of the deep division that had been developing in the Party since the fall of 1927. As a result, the two Politburo factions clashed repeatedly in the late winter, and Stalin found it necessary to publicly repudiate the "Urals-Siberian" methods at times over the next few months. Nevertheless Stalin had apparently committed himself to a radical economic stance by the late winter of 1927-1928, if only as a means of striking at his foes, and the power struggle had begun again in earnest.

(5) Eugene Lyons , Assignment in Utopia (1937)

Was the first Five Year Plan a "success"? For whom and for what? Certainly not for the socialist dream, which had been emptied of human meaning in the process, reduced to a mechanical formula of the state as a super-trust and the population as its helpless serfs. Certainly not for the individual worker, whose trade union had been absorbed by the state-employer, who was terrorized by medieval decrees, who had lost even the illusion of a share in regulating his own life. Certainly not for the revolutionary movement of the world, which was splintered, harassed by the growing strength of fascism, weaker and less hopeful than at the launching of the Plan. Certainly not for the human spirit, mired and outraged by sadistic cruelties on a scale new in modern history, shamed by meekness and sycophancy and systematized hypocrisy. If industrialization were an end in itself, unrelated to larger human ends, the U.S.S.R. had an astounding amount of physical property to show for its sacrifices. Chimneys had begun to dominate horizons once notable for their church domes. Scores of mammoth new enterprises were erected. A quarter of a million prisoners -a larger number of slaves than the Pharaohs mobilized to build their pyramids, than Peter the Great mobilized to build his new capital-hacked a canal between the White and the Baltic Seas; a hundred thousand survivors of this "success" were digging another canal just outside Moscow as the second Plan got under way. The country possessed 3 blast furnaces and 63 open hearth furnaces that had not existed in 1928, a network of power stations with a capacity four times greater than pre-war Russia had, twice as many oil pipe lines as in 1928. Hundreds of machines and tools formerly imported or unknown in Russia were being manufactured at home and large sections of mining were mechanized for the first time. The foundations were laid for a new industrial empire in the Urals and eastern Siberia, the impregnable heart of the country. Two-thirds of the peasantry and four-fifths of the plowed land were "socialized"-that is, owned and managed by the state-employer as it owned and managed factories and workers. The defensive ability of the country, in a military sense, had been vastly increased, with new mechanical bases for its war industries. Measured merely for bulk, the Plan achieved much, though it fell far short of the original goals. On the qualitative side, the picture is much less impressive. Here, we find reflected the low caliber of the human material through which the Plan was necessarily translated from paper to life. Overhead costs were greater all along the line than expected.

Student Activities

(1) isaac deutscher , stalin: a political biography (1949) pages 320-321, (2) john simkin , stalin (1987) page 50, (3) james william crowl , angels in stalin's paradise (1982) pages 88-89, (4) roy a. medvedev , let history judge: the origins and consequences of stalinism (1971) page 103, (5) robert service , stalin: a biography (2004) page 264, (6) john simkin , stalin (1987) page 52, (7) bertram d. wolfe , three who made a revolution (1948) page 197, (8) isaac deutscher , stalin: a political biography (1949) page 337, (9) edvard radzinsky , stalin (1996) pages 234-235, (10) robert service , stalin: a biography (2004) page 264, (11) eugene lyons , assignment in utopia (1937) pages 383-389, (12) walter duranty , new york times (18th january, 1931), (13) isaac deutscher , the listener (8th july 1948), (14) walter duranty , speech reported in the new york times (3rd may, 1932), (15) british embassy report (21st june 1932).

  • Society and Politics
  • Art and Culture
  • Biographies
  • Publications

Home

History Grade 11 - Topic 1 Essay Questions

Explain to what extent Stalin succeeded in transforming Russia into a superpower by 1939.

Stalin came to power on the back of Lenin’s death in 1925, after which he instituted a range of far-reaching policy changes that would alter the course of Russian society and politics for the rest of the 20th century. The communist Soviet Union we now remember was the product of Stalin, although it can be argued that Lenin was responsible for laying the foundations of its highly authoritarian political culture. The new Russia under Stalin was supposed to radically break from the economic and social backwardness that characterised the Tsarist regime, and which Lenin had little time to achieve. In many ways, Stalin did create a completely different Russia, one almost unrecognisable from before the October revolution which overthrew the provisional government. However, whether that translated into it being a superpower is quite another thing. This paper will argue that although momentous and radical, the reforms Stalin instituted did not transform Russia into a superpower by 1939, although it did lay the framework for such a status to be attained during the post-WWII era.

Stalin rose to power as the leader of the Soviet Union by crushing his opposition in the Central Committee led by Leon Trotsky. Although we shall not detail this complicated political battle, it is important to note that the vying for power between the powerful figures was also a contestation over the ideological and policy framework which the Soviet Union should take. By the late 1920s, Stalin had emerged victorious, and went on to institute his own brand of communism in the Soviet Union. This centred on the notion of ‘Socialism in one Country’, which was ideally to build up the “industrial base and military might of the Soviet Union before exporting revolution abroad.” [1] This was in contrast to earlier pronouncements made by Lenin and Trotsky, which indicated the need to establish a worldwide ‘uninterrupted revolution’ of workers. [2] The logic here was that socialism could never survive independently outside of a socialist world order; Stalin, on the other hand, saw a national socialism – which, ironically, would be compared to Nazism – as the only way for socialism to survive. [3]

The practical effects of Stalin’s socialism in one country was the rescindment of the New Economic Policy (NEP) – which had allowed for small-scale capitalist enterprise to operate – the collectivisation of agriculture, and rapid forced industrialisation. [4] Socialism in one country forced the Soviet Union to look inwards, to create a socialist nation whose lessons and ideas could then be exported overseas. This means that, for all practical purposes, Russia was not interested in attaining any overtly ‘superpower’ status in global politics. It meant, in terms of foreign policy, of “putting the interests of the Soviet Union ahead of the interests of the international communist movement.” [5] Ideally, when Russia became powerful enough, it would then ferment for workers’ revolutions the world over.

The costs and benefits of these sweeping policy changes – which essentially closed off the Soviet Union from the outside world – are difficult to determine. On the one hand, they certainly led to large-scale industrialisation which outstripped the pace of Russia’s Western counterparts. Through the policy instrument of Five-Year Plans, which set production targets for industries and farms, Stalin was able to bring Russia up to date with modern heavy-industry production techniques and increase output exponentially. For example, cast iron production increased 439% in ten years, and coal extraction 361%. [6] Russia also went on an extensive electrification programme, called GOELRO, which increased electricity production from 1.9 billion kWh in 1913 to 48 billion kWh in 1940. [7]

However, despite the resounding success with which certain - especially heavy - industries benefitted from forced industrialisation, many other industries and rural farmers often suffered. Because of the focus on heavy industrialisation, lighter industries that catered for consumer goods were often poorly made and faced shortages. The agricultural collectivisation programme which was conducted with increased inflexibility and violence across the Russian hinterland cost the lives of millions of peasants, who died of hunger resulting from famine caused by the upheaval of forced collectivisation. Figures range from 5.6 million to 13.4 million. [8] Millions of other prosperous peasants – known as Kulaks – were sent to gulag camps in Siberia for work; Molotov suggested that between 1.3 and 1.5 kulak households (accounting for between 6 and 7 million persons) were expropriated. [9] Thus, whilst Stalin broke the back of these peasants – by 1941, 97% of agriculture was conducted in collectives, and finally there was enough food to feed the cities – the human cost remains an ever-contested aspect of this period.

What is clear about this period, is that these policies centralised the economy and political power in Russia in Stalin’s hands. The increased industrial output, and the ability for (eventual) increased agricultural production to feed the cities, allowed Russia a certain amount of confidence in its ability to conduct itself as an industrial nation. As Stalin was once quoted as saying, “We are fifty to one hundred years behind the advanced countries. We must make good this distance in ten years. Either we do it, or they crush us.” [10] Thus, one of the primary reasons for industrialisation was for the ability for Russia to protect itself. This fits in well with the overall ideological implication of Stalin’s ‘socialism in one country’, which advocated for an insular reading of socialism that would allow for ‘proper’ socialist conditions to be reached within the massive country before a worldwide socialist revolution took place.

And in many ways, the industrial capacity generated during Stalin’s leadership up to 1939 was crucial for Russia to defend itself against Germany in 1941. Not only did allow for the production of millions of armaments and supplies crucial to the success of any armed conflict, but it also laid the groundwork for a post-war reconstruction. Because the Soviet Union boasted such impressive industrial capacity, it could rebuild after WWII much easier – and more importantly, without the help of aid from the West, especially the USA. The Marshall Plan, in which the USA loaned $15 billion to European countries to help rebuild industry and cities after their decimation during the second world war, was largely a strategic move to counter the spread of communism in Europe. [11] The spread of Russian influence into eastern Europe, on the other hand, was premised on its industrial power, which resulted in its alternative to the Marshall Plan - namely the Molotov Plan - which extended aid to socialist regimes in central and eastern Europe. [12]

The success of Russian industrialisation and agricultural collectivisation during the pre-war years allowed for the repel of German forces and the extension of Russian influence into the eastern European region. It was then that Russia became a superpower. In fact, it is only during the post-WWII war era when the notion of an international ‘superpower’ becomes widespread, when the cold war divides the world into two ideologically opposed sides – America on the one side and the Soviet Union on the other. [13] One could thus argue that the relative military strength of Russia after WWII, a result of its impressive industrial capacity – and its focus on heavy industry and agricultural production – meant that it could become a superpower. Thus, although no one would suggest that Russia was a superpower before WWII in 1939, its ability to retain its industrial strength after the war meant that it would become one. In conclusion, although Stalin did not transform Russia into a superpower by 1939, he laid the necessary groundwork for that to occur in the post-war era.

This content was originally produced for the SAHO classroom by Sebastian Moronell, Ayabulela Ntwakumba, Simone van der Colff & Thandile Xesi.

[1] "Communism - Stalinism". 2021. Encyclopedia Britannica. https://www.britannica.com/topic/communism/Stalinism#ref539199

[2] Erik Van Ree. "Socialism in One Country: A Reassessment." Studies in East European Thought 50, no. 2 (1998): 77.

[3] Kate Frey. 2020. "An Introduction to Trotsky’s Theory of Permanent Revolution". Left Voice. https://www.leftvoice.org/an-introduction-to-trotskys-theory-of-permane… .

[4] "Communism - Stalinism". 2021. Encyclopedia Britannica.

[6] John P. Hardt and Carl Modig. The Industrialization of Soviet Russia in the First Half Century. Research Analysis Corp. McLean, 1968, pg. 6.

[8] Massimo Livi-Bacci. "On the Human Costs of Collectivization in the Soviet Union." Population and Development Review (1993): 751

[9] Ibid, pg. 744.

[10] Flewers, Paul. 2021. "The Economic Policy of The Soviet By Isaac Deutscher 1948". Marxists.Org. https://www.marxists.org/archive/deutscher/1948/economic-policy.htm .

[11] "Marshall Plan". 2021. History. https://www.history.com/topics/world-war-ii/marshall-plan-1 .

[12] Morroe Berger. "How the Molotov Plan Works." The Antioch Review 8, no. 1 (1948): 18.

[13] Joseph M. Siracusa. "Reflections on the Cold War." Australasian Journal of American Studies (2009): 3.

  • Berger, Morroe. "How the Molotov Plan Works." The Antioch Review 8, no. 1 (1948): 17-25.
  • "Communism - Stalinism". 2021. Encyclopedia Britannica. https://www.britannica.com/topic/communism/Stalinism#ref539199 .
  • Flewers, Paul. 2021. "The Economic Policy of the Soviet by Isaac Deutscher 1948". Marxists.Org. https://www.marxists.org/archive/deutscher/1948/economic-policy.htm .
  • Frey, Kate. 2020. "An Introduction to Trotsky’S Theory of Permanent Revolution". Left Voice. https://www.leftvoice.org/an-introduction-to-trotskys-theory-of-permanent-revolution .
  • Livi-Bacci, Massimo. "On the Human Costs of Collectivization in the Soviet Union." Population and Development Review (1993): 743-766.
  • "Marshall Plan". 2021. History. https://www.history.com/topics/world-war-ii/marshall-plan-1.
  • Siracusa, Joseph M. "Reflections on the Cold War." Australasian Journal of American Studies (2009): 1-16.
  • Van Ree, Erik. "Socialism in One Country: A Reassessment." Studies in East European Thought 50, no. 2 (1998): 77-117.
  • Hardt, John P. and Carl Modig. The Industrialization of Soviet Russia in the First Half Century. Research Analysis Corp. McLean, 1968.

Return to topic: Communism in Russia from 1900 to 1940

Return to SAHO Home

Return to History Classroom

Collections in the Archives

Know something about this topic.

Towards a people's history

Why Did Stalin Introduce the Five-Year Plans? ( Cambridge (CIE) IGCSE History )

Revision note.

Zoe Wade

How Important were the Five-Year Plans - Summary

The Five-Year Plans were pivotal in of the USSR under Stalin's rule.

Stalin aimed to rapidly industrialise the nation and achieve specific economic goals within five-year intervals. These plans played a significant role in .

Stalin focused on the development of heavy industry, . This resulted in impressive advancements in sectors such as steel production and transportation. However, the plans also resulted in , including . The government set that could never be met.

Overall, while the Five-Year Plans helped to modernise the Soviet Union, their implementation came with significant costs.

Reasons for the Five-Year Plans

The Five-Year Plans aimed to rapidly industrialise the USSR

Stalin introduced the concept in 1928

There were many motivations behind the Five-Year Plans

A concept map showing the motivations behind the Five-Year Plans

Details of Stalin's Five-Year Plans

Stalin created Gosplan to organise the Five-Year Plan

Gosplan stood for 'State Committee for Planning'

It set targets for:

Each region

Each factory

Each manager

Each worker

Targets were ambitious and usually unachievable

Stalin utilised foreign help and investment from countries like Britain and the USA to help

In Stalin's regime, there were three Five-Year Plans

The First Five-Year Plan

Dates

Targets

Outcomes

1928-1932

To develop heavy industry such as coal, iron, steel and electricity

The building of steelworks such as Magnitogorsk. Coal and iron output doubled

Increase production by 300%

Targets were unrealistic so they could not be met. There was a shortage of skilled workers

A photograph of Magnitogorsk Steel Works in 1930

The Second Five-Year Plan

Dates

Targets

Outcomes

1933 - 1937

To further develop heavy industry

Heavy industry production more than doubled

To focus on lighter industries such as chemicals, railways and communication

The Moscow Railway was completed. However, targets were still too unrealistic and output was of poor quality

The Stakhanovite Movement

The movement began during the second Five-Year Plan in 1935

Its name came from Aleksei Stakhanov

Stakhanov reportedly mined 102 tons of coal in less than 6 hours (14 times his quota) on 31 August 1935

The communist government embraced Stakhanov's achievement

Stakhanov travelled the country as a national celebrity

The government gave Stakhanov a home, extra pay and more holiday

The government organised contests all over the country to find the best worker in each industry

The publicity attracted people to follow Stakhanov's example

On 1 February 1936, Nikita Izotov reportedly mined 640 tons of coal in a single shift

Stakhanovites were located in multiple industries in towns and the countryside

Stakhanov and his followers likely did not achieve these levels of output

It only increased expectations and pressure on workers and managers

Worked Example

Describe the Stakhanovite movement

Stakhanov was a worker who mined over 100 tons of coal in one shift (1) . Soviet propaganda encouraged all Soviet workers to be Stakhanovites (1) . The movement spread from the coal industry to other industries across the Soviet Union (1) . The communists organised contests in many industries to find the best workers (1) .

This question in Paper One requires you to state information you know about the Stakhanovite movement. The Cambridge IGCSE gives you a point for each relevant piece of information that you write. Therefore, do not spend any additional time trying to describe or explain each reason.

The Third Five-Year Plan

Dates

Targets

Outcomes

1938 - 1941

To mechanise and improve agriculture

The Second World War meant the plan had to be abandoned

To produce some consumer goods

There was a lack of good managers and specialists due to Stalin's

You've read 0 of your 10 free revision notes

Get unlimited access.

to absolutely everything:

  • Downloadable PDFs
  • Unlimited Revision Notes
  • Topic Questions
  • Past Papers
  • Model Answers
  • Videos (Maths and Science)

Join the 100,000 + Students that ❤️ Save My Exams

the (exam) results speak for themselves:

Did this page help you?

Author: Zoe Wade

Zoe has worked in education for 10 years as a teaching assistant and a teacher. This has given her an in-depth perspective on how to support all learners to achieve to the best of their ability. She has been the Lead of Key Stage 4 History, showing her expertise in the Edexcel GCSE syllabus and how best to revise. Ever since she was a child, Zoe has been passionate about history. She believes now, more than ever, the study of history is vital to explaining the ever-changing world around us. Zoe’s focus is to create accessible content that breaks down key historical concepts and themes to achieve GCSE success.

  • Accounting Assignment Help
  • Do My Assignment For Me
  • Nursing Assignment Help
  • Dissertation Help
  • Thesis Help
  • Best Quality
  • Affordable Price
  • Multiple Contacts

Home » za » Stalin five year plan essay

Table of Contents

What was the main purpose of Stalin’s 5 year plan

Joseph Stalin’s five years plan is an important way of planning economic growth over a limited period of time. The five-year plans are created with the objective of making a proper plan so that economic growth can be achieved as expected. It was fully utilised in the Soviet Union by Joseph Stalin, and later it has been adopted by many socialist states. The first five year plan in the Soviet Union started in 1928 and continued till 1932 under the leadership of Joseph Stalin. The main purpose of this first five year plan was on developing heavy industry and collectivising agriculture and at the same time it was aimed at achieving a drastic fall in consumer goods. The main purpose of Joseph Stalin under the five year plan was to convert the Soviet Union into a world power. This is to achieve by way of a massive agricultural and industrial advancement within a short period of time of five years.

Collectivisation of agriculture remained the focus area in first five year plan

Agriculture was collectivised during this period of five years with the objective of achieving bigger farms under state control. Collectivisation of agriculture means the land would no longer belong to individual peasants and it is acquired by the state. However it does not prove to be effective because it has resulted into a grain crisis and there was lack of effective participation in this collectivisation among many of the peasants. The strategies used by Stalin to ensure active participation were highly abusive and those who disobeyed were shot or sent to labour camps. Collectivisation was forced among the peasants with the objective of industrialisation of agriculture, but there was resistance identified among many of the peasants to collectivise. They were highly interested in working on their own land rather than supporting the attempt to collectivise.

Industrialisation is used as a factor to promote collectivisation

Industrialisation was an essential requirement for the collectivisation to succeed. There were requirements for tractors and agricultural machines by bigger farms, and emphasizes were made on heavy industry and rapid industrial progress. The overall infrastructure was developed at a rapid pace with new factories and towns were set up in record time. New roads and railways were built up with the objective of supporting industrialisation and ultimately collectivisation. The target set up by the government was highly ambitious and industrialization was aimed to accomplish through forced labour, terror, competition and incentives, low wages, technical training and literary programs.

Success/failure of the Stalin’s first five year plan

The overall Emphasis of the first five year plan was therefore on achieving industrialisation and collectivization through forceful measures, and Stalin has declared the success of the first five year plan by all these strategies. Such claims of success of the first five year plan were made on the basis of exceeding the production goals for heavy industry. However, in reality, the plan was considered a failure despite many actions because it failed to meet all the quotas and had a negative implication on human life. All the initiatives to achieve industrialisation were made at the cost of human life and it is the major factor that indicates the failure of the first five year plan. Joseph Stalin carried out many such five year plans after recognising the first one as a successful one.

Subsequent five year plans for Stalin to promote economic growth

The second five year plan started in the year 1933 and continued till 1937 and the focus of this five year plan was on continuing the objective of the first plan i.e. to collectivisation and industrialisation. In addition to this, the second five year plan also emphasised on stanlinist policies and they have created terrible famines that caused the death of millions of people. The third five year plan was carried out from 1938 to 1942 and it focused on the production of armaments. The fourth five year plan started from 1946 and lasted till 1953 and the main emphasis during this period was on heavy industry and military build-up. As a result of this development, the western powers got angry with the Soviet Union.

Important questions on Stalin’s five years plan we can help         

Our professional writing experts are good at providing answers to any of the questions relating to spellings five year plan. Some of the important questions related to Stalin five years plan include:

  • ‘Stalin was ruthless in his mission to implement communism in Russia through the Five-Year Plans, from 1928 to 1939.’Critically discuss this statement. Use relevant historical evidence to support your line of argument.
  • The first Five-Year Plan, introduced in 1928, concentrated on the development of iron and steel, machine tools, electric power and transport. Joseph Stalin set the workers high targets. He demanded a 110% increase in coal production, 200% increase in iron production and 335% increase in electric power. Write an essay in which you discuss the impact of Stalin’s Five-Year Plans on the Soviet Union.
  • Discuss the impact of Stalin’s Five-Year Plan on the people of the Soviet Union. KEY ASPECTS Introduction Stalin’s economic policy of industrialisation – make a statement linked to the question. Purges and show trials of the 1930s and the effects of Stalin’s policies on the Soviets

We at Student Life Saviour offers best essay writing service in South Africa at affordable prices and can cover topics like Stalin’s five year plans in a perfect way by including introduction, body and conclusion on the five years plan.

Facebook

Content Removal Request

If you believe that the content above belongs to you, and you don’t want it to be published anymore, then request for its removal by filling the details below. It will only be removed if you can provide sufficient evidence of its ownership.

#ezw_tco-2 .ez-toc-widget-container ul.ez-toc-list li.active{ background-color: #ffffff; } Table of Contents Toggle Table of Content Toggle

Our value added service.

  •   Proactive Approach
  •   No False Promise
  •   50% Prepay
  •   Multiple Contact Options

Recent Posts

  • Points to consider while selecting a topic for dissertation help
  • Do essay writing needs professional writers?
  • Basic things to know before seeking help in assignment
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • New Zealand
  • Saudi Arabia
  • South Africa

   

Disclaimer: The reference paper provided by Student Life Saviour should be used as a model paper, and are not intended to be submitted to the universities. They should be used as a reference paper for further research.

24/7 writing help on your phone

To install StudyMoose App tap and then “Add to Home Screen”

Joseph Stalin and First Five-Year Plan

Save to my list

Remove from my list

Prof. Finch

Joseph Stalin and First Five-Year Plan. (2016, Mar 20). Retrieved from https://studymoose.com/joseph-stalin-and-first-five-year-plan-essay

"Joseph Stalin and First Five-Year Plan." StudyMoose , 20 Mar 2016, https://studymoose.com/joseph-stalin-and-first-five-year-plan-essay

StudyMoose. (2016). Joseph Stalin and First Five-Year Plan . [Online]. Available at: https://studymoose.com/joseph-stalin-and-first-five-year-plan-essay [Accessed: 22 Aug. 2024]

"Joseph Stalin and First Five-Year Plan." StudyMoose, Mar 20, 2016. Accessed August 22, 2024. https://studymoose.com/joseph-stalin-and-first-five-year-plan-essay

"Joseph Stalin and First Five-Year Plan," StudyMoose , 20-Mar-2016. [Online]. Available: https://studymoose.com/joseph-stalin-and-first-five-year-plan-essay. [Accessed: 22-Aug-2024]

StudyMoose. (2016). Joseph Stalin and First Five-Year Plan . [Online]. Available at: https://studymoose.com/joseph-stalin-and-first-five-year-plan-essay [Accessed: 22-Aug-2024]

  • Stalin's First Five Year Plan: A Comprehensive Analysis Pages: 3 (650 words)
  • A Portrayal of Joseph Stalin: Life Path and Political Career Pages: 9 (2577 words)
  • The Legacy of Joseph Stalin: A Complex and Controversial Chapter Pages: 2 (470 words)
  • Joseph Stalin's Great Terror Pages: 8 (2385 words)
  • Controversial Hero Joseph Stalin Pages: 3 (829 words)
  • Joseph Stalin: a “Good” but “Evil” Dictator Pages: 4 (1066 words)
  • Joseph Stalin's Goal in Creating a Command Economy Pages: 3 (745 words)
  • Biography Of Joseph Stalin – National Hero Or Cold-Blooded Murderer? Pages: 4 (1078 words)
  • Five Year Career Development Plan Pages: 4 (1125 words)
  • Five-Year Plan: Home, Camping, Potty, Debt-Free, Degree Pages: 3 (684 words)

Joseph Stalin and First Five-Year Plan essay

👋 Hi! I’m your smart assistant Amy!

Don’t know where to start? Type your requirements and I’ll connect you to an academic expert within 3 minutes.

IMAGES

  1. Stalin 5 Year Plan Essay Example

    joseph stalin 5 year plan essay

  2. STALIN'S FIVE YEAR PLANS by Taylor Campbell

    joseph stalin 5 year plan essay

  3. PPT

    joseph stalin 5 year plan essay

  4. Stalin and the Five Year Plans (500 Words)

    joseph stalin 5 year plan essay

  5. Stalin's Five Year Plan Essay with Introduction & Conclusion

    joseph stalin 5 year plan essay

  6. Stalin's Five Year Plans- A level History

    joseph stalin 5 year plan essay

COMMENTS

  1. Joesph Stalin 5 year plan gr11 History essay

    Grade 11 History Essays. STALIN'S FIVE-YEAR PLANS Explain how Stalin had risen to become one of the most powerful men in the world, making his nation a superpower to challenge the United States. [50] SYNOPSIS Candidates should explain Stalin's leadership and how he made his nation a superpower to challenge the United States. KEY ASPECTS

  2. Hist.gr11 Stalin's(5)year.Plans essay

    A major part of the Second Five-Year Plan was to create new infrastructure and communication systems, such as railways and roads and then develop the chemical industry. The Third Five-Year Plan put an emphasis on weapons and military production which required input from heavy industry as Stalin feared future Russian involvement in World War II.

  3. PDF The Five Years Plans of Joseph Stalin

    2 A major part of the Second Five-Year Plan was to create new infrastructure and communication systems, such as railways and roads and then develop the chemical industry. The Third Five-Year Plan put an emphasis on weapons and military production which required input from heavy industry as Stalin feared future Russian involvement in World War II.

  4. Stalin Five Year Plan Essay Grade 11 History Memorandum (Questions and

    An answer guide for Stalin Five Year Plan Essay History Grade 11 with memorandum on pdf: The Five Year Plan was a set of economic goals that were developed in the Soviet Union under the leadership of Joseph Stalin. The plan was launched in 1928, and it aimed to transform the Soviet Union from an agricultural economy into an industrial ...

  5. Five-year plans of the Soviet Union

    The initial five-year plans aimed to achieve rapid industrialization in the Soviet Union and thus placed a major focus on heavy industry. The first five-year plan, accepted in 1928 for the period from 1929 to 1933, finished one year early. The last five-year plan, for the period from 1991 to 1995, was not completed, since the Soviet Union was ...

  6. Stalins 5 year plan essays

    Stalin's 5-year plan 'Stalin was ruthless in his mission to implement communism in Russia through the Five-Year Plans, from 1928 to 1939.'Critically discuss this statement. Use relevant historical evidence to support your line of argument. Joseph Stalin led the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics as an absolute dictator from 1929 to 1953.

  7. What Were Stalin's Five Year Plans?

    Between 1928 and 1932, Stalin's Five Year Plan was targeted at collectivizing agriculture and developing heavy industry. This was the first of four so-called plans, which took place in 1928-32, 1933-37, 1938-42 and 1946-53. After a period of relative economic liberalism Stalin decided that a wholesale restructuring of the economy was needed ...

  8. Five-Year Plans

    In the Soviet Union the first Five-Year Plan (1928-32), implemented by Joseph Stalin, concentrated on developing heavy industry and collectivizing agriculture, at the cost of a drastic fall in consumer goods. The second Five-Year Plan (1933-37) continued the objectives of the first. Collectivization, coupled with other Stalinist policies ...

  9. Primary Source 27.2: Stalin Justifies the Five-Year Plan

    Stalin Justifies the Five-Year Plan. On February 4, 1931, Joseph Stalin delivered the following address, titled "No Slowdown in Tempo!" to the First Conference of Soviet Industrial Managers. Published the following day in Pravda, the newspaper of the Communist Party, and widely publicized at home and abroad, Stalin's speech reaffirmed the ...

  10. How to write an essay about Stalin's Five Year Plans

    The Five Year Plans were a series of centralized economic plans in the Soviet Union, created under the leadership of Joseph Stalin. The first plan was launched in 1928 and the last one ended in 1952. These plans were designed to transform the Soviet Union from an agricultural country into an industrial powerhouse.

  11. Stalin's Five-Year Plans: Soviet Society and Economy

    state. The Five-Year Plans provided the economic and industrial infrastructure necessary for the Soviet Union to become a formidable military power, and this in turn allowed Stalin to pursue an aggressive foreign policy and expand the influence of the Soviet Union in Eastern Europe and Asia. Remember! This is just a sample Get your custom essay

  12. Stalin's Five Year Plan

    The first Five Year Plan that was introduced in 1928, concentrated on the development of iron and steel, machine-tools, electric power and transport. Stalin set the workers high targets. He demanded a 111% increase in coal production, 200% increase in iron production and 335% increase in electric power.

  13. History Grade 11

    History Grade 11 - Topic 1 Essay Questions. Explain to what extent Stalin succeeded in transforming Russia into a superpower by 1939. Stalin came to power on the back of Lenin's death in 1925, after which he instituted a range of far-reaching policy changes that would alter the course of Russian society and politics for the rest of the 20th ...

  14. Why Did Stalin Introduce the Five-Year Plans?

    The Five-Year Plans were pivotal in shaping the economy and society of the USSR under Stalin's rule. Stalin aimed to rapidly industrialise the nation and achieve specific economic goals within five-year intervals. These plans played a significant role in transforming the USSR from an agricultural society into a major industrial power.

  15. PDF Schendel 1 The first Five Year Plan was introduced in 1928by Stalin

    Robert Conquest was one historian in the first school of thought, who went greatly into. h on the "Great Terror", s he called it in his book The Great Terror: Stalin's Purge of theThirties, blished in 1968. The "Great Terror" as Conquest defines it happened between. 934 and 1941. In this "terror" many.

  16. Joseph Stalin Five Year Plan Essay

    Joseph Stalin Five Year Plan Essay. The 5 year plan was produced to output industrial goods and agriculture; a list of economic goals created by Joseph Stalin in 1928 and was based on his policy of socialism. Stalin was alive for only 3 full 5 year plans. The first plan was made in 1928-1932 (considered to officially end later in 1932).

  17. Stalin's Five Year Plan Essay with Introduction & Conclusion

    The first Five-Year Plan, introduced in 1928, concentrated on the development of iron and steel, machine tools, electric power and transport. Joseph Stalin set the workers high targets. He demanded a 110% increase in coal production, 200% increase in iron production and 335% increase in electric power. Write an essay in which you discuss the ...

  18. Stalin's Five-Year Plan

    The First Five-Year Plan. Joseph Stalin, the leader of the Soviet Union from 1924 until his death in 1953, ... Joseph Stalin Essay Topics; Stalin Lesson Plan; Tsar Bomba History, Test ...

  19. PDF Stalin's 5Year Plan

    Stalin used an active secret police to arrest disloyal Russians who went against Communist ideology. 5 Year Plan: Stalin forced industrial workers to achieve high production quotas to modernize the U.S.S.R. The Great Purge: Stalin killed millions of Russians in an effort to hunt down disloyal citizens. Censorship:

  20. 1st October 1928: The USSR introduces the first five-year plan under

    The plan set a series of economic goals to be achieved between 1929 and 1934, with the intention of rapidly industrialising the USSR in case of war with the ...

  21. What was Stalin's five-year plan?

    Share Cite. The Five Year Plan (I assume that you are asking about the first of these plans) was Stalin's plan for the Soviet economy for the years 1928 to 1932. The Soviet Union was a centrally ...

  22. Stalin Five Year Plan Essay

    The Soviet Union from 1928-1985 was a command economy meaning production, investment prices, and incomes were centrally controlled by the government. Joseph Stalin (Soviet Union leader from 1920's-1953) wanted to become a modern world power. He decided in order to be one of the leading influences, he would come up with a Five-year plan.

  23. Joseph Stalin and First Five-Year Plan Free Essay Example

    8. NEP: New Economic Policy (1921-1929) introduced by Lenin. 9. Pravda: the semiofficial newspaper of the Communist Party. Introduction. In October 1928, Joseph Stalin (1) executed the First Five-Year Plan (piatiletka) in order to strengthen the economy of the Soviet Union and accelerate its rate of industrialization.