critical thinking in construction management

All in Agreement

Thinking critical in the construction industry.

“ An education isn’t how much you have committed to memory, or even how much you know. It’s being able to differentiate between what you do know and what you don’t.”  — Anatole France

“Too often we give children answers to remember rather than problems to solve.”  — Roger Lewin

“The eye sees only what the mind is prepared to comprehend.”  —Henri Bergson

“Invest a few moments in thinking. It will pay good interest.”  —Anonymous 

In my opinion, critical thinking is an art and is simply defined as “the ability to analyze and evaluate an issue to form a judgment.” Hopefully correctly. Critical thinking should not be confused with people who are critical.

How critical thinking applies to construction is quite simple when considering Bergson’s quote.

If project managers, project supervisors or safety managers don’t have or are not taught critical thinking skills, they may not have the ability to see, analyze or evaluate the problem when it occurs. (For example, a metal stud contractor that started work four months late due to a delay in concrete completion.) We would all agree that a four-month delay is easy to see. However, we may not all agree how a four-month delay might impact us now or in the future unless we analyze and evaluate the issue correctly.

Analyzing the Problem

To analyze and evaluate the problem, we would need more information. For example, a person with good critical thinking skills would ask the following questions to form a judgment:

• Will we have the same amount of time to complete our work?
• Will we have less time to complete our work?
• Will the schedule be extended four months?
• Will overtime be required?
• Will work be done in a different sequence?
• Will multiple trades be in our way?

Once we know the answers to these questions, we can then make a judgment, which may or may not include additional costs. The problem in this case is that the manager on this job didn’t ask the questions because he didn’t comprehend what he was seeing and hearing.

A far more subtle example costing millions each year is because companies don’t comprehend what they’re seeing and hearing. They see that they’re not making enough money on change orders, that the supervision budget is upside down, and they hear there’s not enough supervision time in the budget.

However, they don’t take time to analyze the issue to form a judgment. In the case of change orders, one would have to ask this question to analyze the issue, “What all does a foreman do to integrate and complete a change order?” To answer the question, one would develop the following answers to the question: “What all does a foreman do to integrate and complete a change?”

1. Planning and Approval Phase

• Get written authorization to proceed.
• Time to review and understand change.
• Time to procure necessary or lacking information.
• Time to procure material, tools and equipment.
• Time to coordinate with others.
• Time to schedule the work.

2. Construction Phase

• Time to receive material, tools and equipment.
• Time to assist in layout.
• Time to procure labor multiple times.
• Time to oversee labor.
• Time to resolve conflicts.
• Time to schedule clean up.
• Time to attend inspections and make correction.

3. Accounting Phase

• Time to manage time cards-cost codes.
• Time to manage job cost.
• Time to manage EWA Tickets-Daily.

4. Closeout Phase

• Time to demobilize.
• Time to get signatures-approvals if on a work order.
• Time to return documentation to manager.
• Time to meet with the client in the event of a dispute.

The next obvious step for a critical thinker is to ask others if they think the assumptions made are true or false. Once the assumptions are determined true, it’s time to make a judgment.

Your judgment in this case is, “My foremen are spending much more time on change orders than I originally thought. I’m going to start charging the client the time it takes my foreman to do the things that apply to each change.” In other words, “I may charge the client for everything on the checklist, or for just those I think apply.”

Critical thinking is commonly a three-step process, which includes:

• Identify the issue/problem.
• Analyze by asking questions.
• Make a judgment-determination.

The most difficult of the three-step process is Step 1, because, “The eye sees only what the mind is prepared to comprehend.”

In other words, if a manager doesn’t have critical thinking skills, he or she won’t see the problem for what it is.

Teaching Critical Thinking

Can critical thinking skills be taught? Yes, but it’s difficult when a high percentage of people don’t see things as they really are. In other words, many people have learned to see things the way they want to see them.

Although I’m writing this article before the Super Bowl, a good critical thinking sports analogy is Richard Sherman, the Seattle Seahawks’ defensive cornerback. Like him or hate him, he reads plays better than most, and his stats support it. We can probably all agree that if he’s not the best corner in the NFL he’s one of the top three. Why? Because he sees the problems, understands them, finds solutions, and finds them in seconds.

Educators now understand how important it is to teach students how to think critically from an early age. According to the Centers for Disease and Control, the number one killer of adolescents is motor vehicle crashes. According to the center, the factors include:

• Teens are more likely than older drivers to underestimate dangerous situations or not be able to recognize hazardous situations.
• Teens are more likely than older drivers to speed and allow shorter headways (the distance from the front of one vehicle to the front of the next). The presence of male teenage passengers increases the likelihood of this risky driving behavior.
• Among male drivers between 15 and 20 years of age who were involved in fatal crashes in 2012, 37 percent were speeding at the time of the crash and 25 percent had been drinking.
• Compared with other age groups, teens have the lowest rate of seat belt use. In 2013, only 55 percent of high school students reported they always wear seat belts when riding with someone else.
• At all levels of blood alcohol concentration (BAC), the risk of involvement in a motor vehicle crash is greater for teens than for older drivers.
• In 2012, 23 percent of drivers aged 15 to 20 involved in fatal motor vehicle crashes were drinking.
• In a national survey conducted in 2013, 22 percent of teens reported that, within the previous month, they had ridden with a driver who had been drinking alcohol. Among students who drove, 10 percent reported having driven after drinking alcohol within the same one-month period.
• In 2012, 71 percent of drivers aged 15 to 20 that were killed in motor vehicle crash after drinking and driving were not wearing a seat belt.
• In 2012, 49 percent of teen deaths from motor vehicle crashes occurred between 3 p.m. and midnight and 53 percent occurred over the weekend.

From the research I’ve done, it appears that teaching kids critical thinking skills at the youngest possible age may save their lives and will likely improve their personal and professional success rates because critical thinking improves judgment.

A Critical Thinking Company

Keeping in mind that the steps in a critical thinking process commonly include:

• Make a judgment/determination.

Again, the most difficult step in the process is identifying the issue/problem. If the mind doesn’t comprehend what it’s seeing and hearing, (what’s happening/not happening or what will happen on a job) as in football, the play will be over before you respond.

An excellent and easy to implement way of improving an operations teams critical thinking skills is to develop a set of questions requiring yes or no answers. The following “yes” or “no” questions will help the team understand the critical thinking process and improve their overall critical thinking skills.

• Is your project following the originally planned schedule?
• Is your project following the originally planned sequence?
• Is your project following the originally planned manpower?
• Is your project following the original planned supervision budget?

When any of the above four questions are answered with a “no,” the leader of the group should ask why until the root cause of the problem is determined. Once the root cause is determined a judgment can then be made.

  With that said, I want to leave you with a final quote. In my own words, “The time and money you invest in teaching critical thinking skills will result in a tenfold return.”  

Share This Story

Report Abusive Comment

Restricted Content

You must have JavaScript enabled to enjoy a limited number of articles over the next 30 days.

Recommended Articles

W&C Top 50 Contractors

W&C State of the Industry

What is an “EQ” Stud?

Related articles.

New Department of Homeland Security Guidance Clarifies Construction's Role in Supporting Essential Critical Infrastructure

Risk Management in the Construction Industry (Part 1)

Embracing Technology to Improve Labor Crunch in the Construction Industry

Connect with the industry’s leading resource for unparalleled insights and education., join thousands of industry professionals today. shouldn’t you know what they know.

Copyright ©2024. All Rights Reserved BNP Media.

Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing

• Unito home /
• The Project Manager’s Guide to Critical Thinking Skills

Remember playing the game Clue as a kid? You’d collect evidence, analyze the possibilities, and come to your own conclusions based on what you knew (and what you didn’t). As a project manager, the skills you developed playing games like Clue are extremely useful. The acting gatekeeper for your team, you’re used to evaluating information and making decisions to benefit your department and the business as a whole. Whether you’re a seasoned project manager or just learning the ropes, knowing how to fine-tune your critical thinking skills will come in handy every single day.

Continue reading to learn: 

• A definition of critical thinking
• The six critical skills project managers need
• Why critical thinking skills are crucial for project managers
• How to work your critical thinking muscles
• Effective critical thinking techniques

Let’s get critical. 

What is critical thinking?

Ask five different people what critical thinking means and you’ll probably get five different answers. But, generally speaking, critical thinking refers to intellectual tactics used to observe and analyze information to draw better conclusions. A key factor in critical thinking is looking beyond the surface of an idea, a concept, or a piece of information. It involves asking questions — to yourself or others — to go deeper and draw better conclusions.

Critical thinking can be used by anyone, in any role, to make their job easier. You can find new insights, optimize an inefficient process, and get projects done faster. Developing your critical thinking means building habits that follow you throughout your career.

Here’s a breakdown of crucial critical thinking skills for project managers — or any other role.

6 critical thinking skills for project managers

Skill #1: observation.

Critical thinking skills starts with being more aware of what’s going on. Working on an important project? Being observant might mean keeping a close eye on comments from collaborators, or just paying better attention during meetings with your data team. Becoming a more observant person means you can identify problems others miss or pick up on context clues that help you solve problems down the road.

Skill #2: Analysis

Spotting problems, clues, and that one important comment in a Slack thread is just the beginning. If observation is how you bring in more information, analysis is how you determine what you’re going to do with it. Having an analytical approach to your problems means knowing what information you have available, knowing how relevant each piece is to the problem at hand, and being able to ask better questions. 

Skill #3: Identifying bias

This critical thinking skill ties in closely with analysis but is important enough to be its own skill. Bias is inherent in everything we do, from collecting data to creating content and solving problems. For instance, because this blog post is being written by a marketer, it might use different examples than a writer from a more technical team. You can spot a bias by asking yourself questions, like “are there elements of this person’s experience or perspective that might be affecting what they’re saying?” Bias can affect every role in an organization.

Skill #4: Inference

This is a fancy term for drawing better conclusions. This crucial critical thinking skill helps you make better use of the information you collect, the questions you ask, and the potential problems you spot. Think of everything you might have done so far as putting ingredients in a stew. You can have the best ingredients in the world, but if you leave the pot on too long, you’ll end up with something closer to charcoal than stew.

One of the quickest ways to improve your inference skills is, ironically, by slowing down. Instead of blurting out the first conclusion that comes to mind, start with a few educated guesses, and compare them to each other. Which one makes the most sense? Which is weakest?

Skill #5: Problem-solving

If inference is how you come to better conclusions, problem-solving is how you put them into action. This critical thinking skill encompasses the tactics and strategies you use to take something that looks good on paper and make it great in practice. Problem-solving includes  planning  how you’ll solve a problem, but also reacting to hurdles along the way and staying flexible. A great way to improve your problem-solving skills is asking yourself “is this still the best way to solve the problem?” at every stage of your plan. Sometimes, people can get set in their ways, meaning they stick to an ineffective solution long after they should have pivoted to something else.

Skill #6: Curiosity

This is less a skill than it is a characteristic every critical thinker should work to develop. Every other critical thinking skill is helped by broadening having access to more information and more knowledge. For instance, you can be the most observant person in the world, but you’d still struggle to pick out all the problems in a presentation from the data team if you weren’t at least a little familiar with data analysis. Beyond expertise in specific fields, critical thinking — and thinking in general — is easier when you have a breadth of knowledge and experiences to draw from. You can find links that others would miss and learn to think in different ways. Read more books, listen to more podcasts, and approach the world at large with more curiosity.

Why do project managers need critical thinking skills? 

When people hear the phrase ‘critical thinking’, they often picture a negative person. Being a critical thinker doesn’t mean you have a bad attitude or that you aren’t a team player. It’s quite the opposite. 

Critical thinking means questioning processes, projects, and even core business practices that are widely accepted as given. Not to tear them down, but to improve them for the benefit of the entire team. 

The Project Management Institute (PMI) outlines how important this skill is: 

“Corporate leaders have put critical thinking at the top of the list of essential competencies needed by their workers to understand these challenges, explore opportunities, and make good decisions in this new competitive environment.” 

When used in the context of project management, effective critical thinking can: 

• Encourage deeper, more  productive discussions
• Facilitate open communication between team members 
• Resolve issues between team members and stakeholders more quickly
• Develop better solutions to problems 
• Reduce stress throughout a project 
• Prevent repetitive issues
• Achieve better results faster 

Now that you know why critical thinking skills are priority for project managers, it’s time to find out how you can improve yours.

How project managers can develop better critical thinking skills 

There’s one core principle that will guide your critical thinking: question everything. Project managers can’t just approve all requests that come in from stakeholders across the organization — unless they want a stressed-out, overworked team.

A good project manager knows how to prioritize projects according to the business’ overall needs and goals. With every request that comes in, you need to be prepared to evaluate the project’s impact on the business, the necessity of the project, and the why. Building this process — this instinct — into your daily work is how you build and strengthen your critical thinking skills.

For every potential project, consider: 

• Why is this important right now? While most stakeholders will say their project is urgent, you need to find out exactly how true this is. Perhaps the project could be scheduled for a later date that works better for your team’s schedule. 
• Why does my team need to be involved? For example, if you manage the creative team and a request for a sales presentation comes in, figure out exactly what your team will need to do.
• Why is my team’s time better spent on this project than other projects? Does this project contribute more to the business than other work your team could be doing? 

Those are three important questions to ask yourself, but what about the questions you ask others?

When a new project lands in your inbox, you need to know what to ask of the sender and how to delicately frame those questions. There are a few question formats that work especially well for this stage of the project. These include:

• ‘tell me more’ questions (eg. Tell me more about what will be required from each member of my team)
• ‘help me understand’ questions (eg. Help me understand why this project is urgent)
• ‘can you give me an example’ questions (eg. Can you give me an example of the types of results you’re looking for here?). 

These questions allow you to get a better understanding of the project and make sure it’s a good fit for your team. They’re also usually well-received by whoever initiated the project.

Prioritization means making tough calls, and project managers need to be ready and equipped to do so. You can’t be afraid to say no when the project doesn’t make sense from a timing or business standpoint. However, you will also need to be ready to explain the reasoning behind your “no”. The following techniques will help you feel confident in your decisions and authority as a project manager. 

Critical thinking techniques for project managers 

Critical thinking skills are one thing, but when evaluating the priority of a new project, there are critical thinking techniques you can put into practice to boost results and team morale. 

• Avoid making or accepting assumptions 
• Identify potential issues (and their consequences) from the start
• Use the Five Whys to find the root of problems 

Let’s dive into these a little bit more. 

1. Avoid assumptions 

You know what they say about assuming things. When you make assumptions as a project manager, you’re missing out on and ignoring key information that could make or break your project. You can have the best critical thinking skills in the office, but making the wrong assumption can undo all your hard work.

A big part of critical thinking is digging into reasoning and probing for evidence rather than drawing your own immediate conclusions. When you’re pitched a new project — and during the course of the entire project — question any preconceived notions (yours or theirs). Ensure you’re given concrete evidence for the viability of the project, and look for any holes in the process or strategy that could impact your team. 

When challenging assumptions, consider the following questions: 

• Am I assuming all members of this project have all the information they need to complete their tasks?
• What assumptions am I making about each team members’ skill sets? 
• Am I making assumptions about each team member’s time and availability? 
• What are some possible issues that may arise with this project? How can I work backwards and challenge any assumptions in order to avoid these issues? 
• What assumptions have I made about the stakeholder or project creator? What do they need to know? 

Never take anything for granted. When your job is to facilitate and manage expectations, it’s important that you’re questioning and challenging your own assumptions — and those of team members and stakeholders — at all stages of the process. 

2. Consider potential issues 

When you’re questioning assumptions, you’re also working towards another big part of your job: risk management. By proactively questioning what could go wrong, you can prepare for any issues that might arise during the course of the project. Not only that, but you can consider the implications and consequences of when things go awry. 

Consider a cause and effect approach with hypothetical — but realistic — issues. Give yourself an hour to write down any possible issues that could arise with the project, along with a list of consequences associated with each one. For example: 

• Problem : The video editor won’t have enough time to deliver the final file. 
• Consequence : The rest of the project will be held up. Costs will increase and we could miss the deadline.  

In a perfect world, project managers wouldn’t face any problems and all projects would be smooth sailing. Since that’s unfortunately not the case, here are some helpful tools you can use to avoid the escalation of issues — as well as repeating roadblocks with future projects.

3. Use the Five Whys

In addition to the “why” questions outlined above, a proven project management technique called “The Five Whys” can help you explore the true cause or causes of any problem. 

Here’s how ProjectManagement.com explains it: 

“5 Whys is an iterative elicitation method used to explore cause-and-effect relationships underlying a particular problem. The primary goal of the technique is to determine the root cause of a defect or problem by repeating the question ‘Why?’. Each answer forms the basis of the next question.” 

To complete The Five Whys, you simply repeat the question “why?” five times until you come to the root of the problem. Each answer is understood to be a “contributing cause” that impacts the final result. 

For example: 

• Because multiple teams weren’t able to complete their tasks on time (contributing cause). 
• Because their time wasn’t prioritized properly (contributing cause). 
• Because multiple last-minute projects were assigned (contributing cause). 
• Because other stakeholders didn’t understand the prioritization and project assignment process (contributing cause). 
• Because they haven’t been properly trained or given the necessary information (root cause). 

Once you get to the root of the problem, you can take action to ensure these issues are minimized or avoided in the future. 

For project managers, sometimes taking a moment to just stop and consider all of the possibilities, consequences, and information can make all the difference between a well-thought-out decision and a future regret. Developing and exercising your critical thinking skills is a surefire way to drive positive business results.

How do project managers save time?

They use Unito to sync crucial data across tools like Trello, Jira, Asana, and more.

Find out how

How to Integrate Process Improvement into Your Project

An easy guide to process improvement.

How to Use Basecamp Like a Pro

From the “campfire” chat, itemized to-do lists, and a space to organize shared files, Basecamp offers an elegant, simple solution for project management.

Related articles

Unlock the Power of Sync (Ebook)

Data integration isn’t a luxury, but most existing platforms haven’t stepped up to the plate in a meaningful way. In this ebook, you’ll learn how a 2-way sync can change the game for your organization.

The 8 Best Smartsheet Alternatives

Smartsheet is a robust tool that combines the flexibility of a spreadsheet with project management features. Still, it isn’t always the best option. Here are some alternatives.

The 24 Best Trello Power-Ups

Want to get more out of your Trello board? With the right Power-Up, you can turn Trello into a custom solution for your use case. Here are some of the best Trello Power-Ups out there.

Critical Thinking Skills and activities for Project Managers

Weaving critical thinking into your projects

Brought to You by Dave Litten

CRITICAL THINKING IS A CORE SKILL OF SUCCESSFUL PROJECT MANAGERS

Think back to how project management is applied. Activities, methods, processes, procedures and techniques only go so far... Think about planning, monitoring and control.

Think about estimating and identifying risk respnses

Think about project strategies and approaches

Think about project controls

Think about delivery approaches

ALL of the above, and more, depend 100% upon Critical Thinking.

Think You Can Do WITH Critical Thinking?

Critical Thinking Skills and activities for Project Managers Critical thinking is for everyone yet few are able or willing to do it. Critical thinking is a set of transferable skills that can be learned for one thing yet equally useful for any other. Critical thinking cuts across all academic disciplines and is applicable in all spheres of human activity - particularly project management where it becomes a toolbox for driving both career and project success. So what are the key activities, abilities and attributes of a critical thinker? Analytical skills Like any one skilled in debate, critical thinkers demand properly constructed arguments that presents reasons and more sound conclusions Tolerance Critical thinkers delight in hearing diversion views and enjoy a real debate Confidence This is key since critical thinkers must be confident and able to examine views made by others, often those in authority Curiosity This is the essential ingredient for ideas and insights Truth seeking The critical thinkers are looking for objective truth even if it turns out to undermine their own previously held convictions and long cherished beliefs and even if this goes against their own self interest "There goes another beautiful theory about to be murdered by a gang of facts" You need to learn how to identify other peoples arguments and conclusions and go on to interpret and produce your argument more effectively. This means you will want to read between the lines, see behind services and identify false assumptions. To be successful as a project manager it is vital that you apply critical thinking within the planning, monitoring, and control of your projects

The Soft Stuff Matters

Critical thinking skills is the backbone to Critical Decision-making, which in and of itself, leads to successful change management and project delivery success. But don´t take my word for it…just listen to The Project Management Institute (PMI), and their Project Management Body Of Knowledge (PMBOK) 6th Edition now includes The Talent Triangle:

Check out the “technical, strategic and business management bits above…these cannot be learned by rote alone.

See, Critical Thinking Skills is about a range of skills and understandings – the kind of open-mindedness that allows you to make creative leaps and gain insights.

Get this...

Demand over the next 10 years for project managers is growing faster than demand for workers in other occupations. Organizations, however, face risks from this talent gap.

This talent gap analysis shows that project managers are important contributors to productivity. Talent shortages in the profession can potentially create risks of nearly $208 billion in GDP over the next 10-year period up to 2028

The latest PMI-commissioned talent gap analysis has found outstanding opportunities in jobs and career growth for project managers.

From the present day up to 2028, the project management skills and jobs are expected to grow by 33 percent, or nearly 22 million new jobs.

By 2027, employers will need nearly 88 million individuals in project management-oriented roles

If you need to become a Project Management Professional (PMP), then click below

What has this to do with Critical Thinking Skills and activities for Project Managers?

To answer this, we need to look again at the life-skills of critical thinking…

Critical thinking Questions - The Assertibility Question (AQ) This weeds out wobbly views having shaky evidence from sensible theories that are worth serious consideration. To use AQ you ask what evidence allows you to assert that the claim is true.

This will include questions such as:

• Does the idea fit well with common sense or is it crazy?
• Who proposed the idea, and is the person biased towards it being true?
• Have statistics been used and presented in an honest way, and are they backed up with references to other work that supports the approach?
• Does the idea explain too much — or too little — to be useful?
• Have they been open about their methods and data?
• How many artificially decided settings are there that constrain and affect the theory?

Every day we are bombarded by problems and situations needing to be evaluated and solved.

The challenge is to view these from different perspectives and all too often we make decisions only based on previous similar situations or experiences.

This can lead to cloudy decision-making since we are often affected by emotional thinking, poorly prioritized facts and external influences that may not be relevant.

Then compare and contrast this with critical thinking which builds a rational and open minded process built upon information and empirical evidence.

Critical Thinking Skills Definition:

“ an intellectually disciplined process of actively and skillfully conceptualizing, applying, analyzing, synthesizing, and/or evaluating information that has been gathered from, or generated by, observation, experience, reflection, reasoning, or communication ”

Critical thinking provides the skills to judge and evaluate situations that is based on understanding the related data. It is analyzed to build a clear understanding of the problem, a proper solution identified, and then to take actions based on that solution.

The power of the critical thinking process is that it prevents our minds from jumping directly to conclusions, and instead, leads the mind through a set of logical steps to widen the range of perspectives, to accept the findings, sidestep personal biases, and consider reasonable possibilities.

Critical Thinking - The 6 Basic Steps

To determine what are the critical thinking questions, here are the six basic steps:

Step 1. Knowledge Here, we need a clear vision, starting with identifying the argument or the problem that needs to be resolved. Open questioning is used to acquire a deep understanding about the problem or situation. This involves the use of open ended questioning to discuss and explore the main reasons or root causes. A clear understanding must be obtained of what the problem is and why do we need to solve it. Step 2. Comprehension You need to fully understand the situation along with the facts that align and support it. The way in which you collect such facts will depend upon the research methods used, and this in turn will depend upon the problem, the type of data and information available, and any constraints. Step 3. Application This is the next practical step following comprehension, and builds to fully understand the different facts and resources needed to solve the problem. Mind maps are helpful here to analyze the situation while building a strong relationship between it and the core problem while resolving the best way to move forward. Step 4. Analyze This step builds on the information and linkages identified from the main problem, and analysis to close to identify the strong and weak points plus the challenges faced one identifying a solution to the problem. The main causes are prioritized to determine how they can be applied, and one of the most often used tools here to analyze the problem and those circumstances that surround it, is the cause and effect diagram, which isolates the problem from its root causes and identifies such causes so that they can be categorized on their type an impact on the problem. Step 5. Synthesis Once the problem has been fully analyzed and the related data has been considered, a decision needs to be taken how the problem can be solved along with the initial set of actions required. If there are several identified solutions, then each should be evaluated and prioritized to identify the best solution approach. It is here that SWOT analysis can be helpful in identifying the solutions strength, weakness, opportunity, and threats.

SWOT Analysis

If they are to interpret and use the SWOT analysis, the project can form the strategy based on the following factors:

• ​​ ​​ Strength vs. opportunity . The strategies or approaches build on the available existing strengths and how they may be used to leverage existing or new opportunities
• ​​ ​​ Weaknesses vs. opportunities. This strategies suggest ways of overcoming existing weaknesses while building new potential opportunities
• ​​ ​​ Strengths vs. threats. These strategies identify approaches to build on the organization, product, or project strengths while reducing threats and risk to the main objectives.
• ​​ ​​ Weaknesses vs. threats. These are strategies designed to prevent such weaknesses from the influenced by external threats.

Step 6. Take Action The final step is to build a problem valuation that can be put into action, as the final result of critical thinking should be transferred into actionable steps. Within a project, a plan of action should be implemented to ensure that the solution is adopted and implemented as planned. Summary The critical thinking method is used to replace the emotions and biases when dealing with a situation or a problem. The advantage of using critical thinking is its contribution to widening perspectives about situations and providing a broader range of action choices to ensure that the decided resolution is implemented and integrated between all the involved individuals and organizations.

Critical Thing Tools

The Cause and Effect Diagram

The cause and effect diagram is helpful when exploring problems and their solution:

How to solve problems using the cause and effect diagram The cause and effect diagram is also known as the Ishikawa diagram or fishbone diagram. For its successful use, a clear problem definition is first needed so that the proper solution can be targeted.

Additionally, the root causes behind the problem must also be carefully analysed. The Ishikawa diagram has two main sections, causes on the left hand side, and effect on the right-hand side.

Possible problem causes are thought through by creating branches from the line that links cause and effect. This type of diagram has a focus on solving problems rather than exploring ideas which is normally the case when applying critical thinking skills. The headings used to brainstorm the various problem causes, can vary from industry to industry, and as an example here are typical cause headings for three industries:

• The service industry. S urrounding, S uppliers, S ystems, S kills, and S afety
• The manufacturing industry.   M achine, M ethod, M aterial, M anpower, and M easurement
• The marketing industry. P roduct, P rice, P lace, P romotion, P eople, P rocess, and P hysical evidence

There are four steps to create the Fishbone diagram:

• 1 Identify the problems. The defects, or problem, results from one or several causes, for these reasons the problem must be clearly identified so that potential related causes can be investigated
• 2 A straight horizontal line should be drawn as a link between cause and effect, so that general causes such as the three cause models mentioned above can be drawn as branches from this main line
• 3 ​ Once the main general categories have been added, all possible causes for the problem can now be investigated and organized under the general categories
• 4 The final step is to investigate and discuss each possible cause and organize them in priority and influence order

Critical Thinking and Mind Mapping Mind mapping is a tool to help understand ideas and collaboration. Those who use Mind mapping for critical thinking can improve their productivity by 25%. It is also used to support the project management process and can easily be integrated when performing project management planning. I include here an excellent example (not my own) showing how the use of diagrams and colors help convey easily identified and remembered relationships. As stated at the center of this diagram, this is an example of brainstorming the various elements of time management:

Critical Thinking  - Real World Example

Here at Projex Academy, we have the market leader in online streaming training the world´s project management community. Our Flagship training course is for the PRINCE2 Methodology. First, I generated a Mind map on the structure and application of the PRINCE2 Methodology, then I performed root cause analysis to determine customer-demand potential training spin-offs. This resulted in created TWO new products - BOTH of which are UNIQUE to the project management training industry. They are:

• PRINCE2  SCRUM Masterclass for fast-to-market and high ROI projects
• PRINCE2 Lite for tailoring and blending smaller projects

Both have been selling like hot cakes since their launch a few months back - click on their images below to find out more... THANK YOU Critical Thinking!

Want to become a PRINCE2 Practitioner?

A personal learning experience.

Study anywhere, anytime at your own pace. We will be at your side every step of the way.

100% SATISFACTION-GUARANTEE.

Our mission is to exceed your learning expectations in the most professional and efficient way possible. In the unlikely event that you are not 100% satisfied - we will gladly arrange a full refund with no quibbles. That's how confident we are :)

• Free PM Courses
• Testimonial

We noticed you're visiting from Russia. We've updated our prices to Russian ruble for your shopping convenience. Use Euro instead. Dismiss

Construction & Real Estate Education

Learn, Grow, and Succeed in Construction & Real Estate

Critical Thinking in Construction: Solving Problems Efficiently

Enhance your construction projects by utilizing critical thinking to efficiently tackle complex issues and make well-informed decisions in the industry's fast-paced setting. Structured problem-solving and systematic analysis are essential for successful outcomes. Engage in data analysis for valuable insights and strategic planning. Embrace innovative techniques and collaboration for effective solutions. Identify bottlenecks, encourage out-of-the-box thinking, and constantly refine processes for enhanced efficiency. Overcome challenges through open communication, proactive risk management , and continuous improvement . Prioritize tasks, embrace diverse perspectives, and leverage technology for best project planning. Take the first step towards enhancing your construction projects with critical thinking.

Key Takeaways

• Utilize critical thinking for efficient problem-solving in construction challenges.
• Analyze data to make informed decisions swiftly and effectively.
• Implement innovative problem-solving techniques for unconventional solutions.
• Foster collaboration for effective solutions through diverse perspectives.
• Continuously improve project efficiency by identifying and addressing bottlenecks.

Importance of Critical Thinking in Construction

In construction, critical thinking plays a pivotal role in problem-solving, decision-making, and ensuring project success. When faced with construction challenges, employing effective problem-solving strategies and critical thinking techniques is imperative. By analyzing issues systematically and considering various perspectives, you can tackle complex problems efficiently.

Critical thinking enables you to break down construction challenges into manageable parts, facilitating a structured approach to finding solutions. By evaluating different options and predicting potential outcomes, you can make informed decisions swiftly. This ability to engage in efficient decision-making is essential in the dynamic environment of construction projects, where time is often of the essence.

Moreover, critical thinking empowers you to anticipate obstacles, evaluate risks, and adapt to unexpected circumstances , enhancing your ability to navigate the uncertainties inherent in construction. By incorporating critical thinking techniques into your problem-solving process, you can proactively address issues, mitigate risks , and contribute to the overall success of the project.

Understanding Complex Construction Issues

Understanding intricate construction issues requires a thorough analysis of interrelated factors, demanding a strategic approach to problem-solving and decision-making. When faced with complex construction challenges, your ability to navigate through the intricacies of the project is vital. To tackle these issues effectively, consider the following:

• Leverage Problem Solving Strategies : Utilize a variety of problem-solving techniques to address different aspects of the construction complexity.
• Apply Critical Thinking Applications : Engage in critical thinking to dissect the core of the problem and identify potential solutions with clarity and precision.
• Embrace Project Efficiency : Streamline your processes by integrating efficiency measures that optimize resource utilization and time management.
• Seek Interdisciplinary Insights : Collaborate with experts from various fields to gain diverse perspectives and innovative solutions to complex issues.
• Prioritize Continuous Learning : Stay updated on the latest trends and technologies in the construction industry to adapt and evolve your problem-solving skills effectively.

Analyzing Data for Informed Decisions

To make informed decisions in construction, data analysis plays a crucial role in providing valuable insights for strategic planning and problem-solving. By effectively analyzing data, you can uncover trends , identify potential risks , and recognize opportunities that may impact your construction projects. Data analysis involves collecting, organizing, and interpreting information to extract meaningful patterns and relationships. Utilizing various tools and techniques, such as statistical analysis and data visualization , can help you make sense of complex datasets and derive actionable conclusions.

Incorporating data analysis into your decision-making strategies allows you to optimize resource allocation, streamline processes, and enhance project outcomes. By leveraging historical data and real-time information, you can improve forecasting accuracy and mitigate potential disruptions. Furthermore, data-driven decision making enables you to evaluate the effectiveness of different courses of action and choose the most strategic path forward.

Implementing Innovative Problem-Solving Techniques

By applying innovative problem-solving techniques in construction, you can open up new avenues for addressing challenges and optimizing project outcomes. When faced with complex issues, it's vital to think outside the box and embrace creative brainstorming to find unconventional solutions.

By fostering a culture of innovation and experimentation, you can propel your projects towards success. Strategic solutions play a key role in overcoming hurdles efficiently and effectively, ensuring that your construction endeavors stay on track.

Here are five essential techniques to enhance your problem-solving skills:

• Encourage out-of-the-box thinking to explore unconventional ideas.
• Embrace failure as a learning opportunity to refine your problem-solving approach.
• Collaborate with diverse team members to gain different perspectives and insights.
• Utilize technology and digital tools to streamline problem-solving processes.
• Continuously evaluate and adapt your strategies to meet evolving challenges and opportunities.

Collaboration for Effective Solutions

When tackling complex construction challenges, you must prioritize teamwork to leverage diverse perspectives and skills. Effective communication is essential for ensuring that everyone is on the same page and working towards a common goal.

Embracing innovation within collaborative efforts can lead to creative solutions that push the boundaries of traditional problem-solving approaches.

Teamwork for Problem-Solving

Effective problem-solving in construction projects often relies on collaborative teamwork to generate innovative solutions and guarantee successful outcomes. When it comes to teamwork for problem-solving, consider the following:

• Open Communication: Foster an environment where team members freely share ideas and concerns.
• Utilize Diverse Perspectives: Embrace the unique viewpoints of each team member to approach problems from multiple angles.
• Encourage Active Participation: Motivate team members to engage actively in brainstorming and decision-making processes.
• Leverage Individual Strengths: Assign tasks based on individual strengths to optimize problem-solving efficiency.
• Celebrate Success Together: Recognize and celebrate team achievements to boost morale and strengthen teamwork bonds.

Communication for Clarity

In the domain of construction projects, fostering clear communication among team members is paramount for achieving effective collaborative solutions. Clear communication guarantees that everyone on the team understands the project goals , timelines, and individual responsibilities .

By openly sharing information, ideas, and concerns, team members can address any potential issues early on, leading to smoother project progress. Effective collaboration relies heavily on communication for clarity to avoid misunderstandings and reduce errors. Regular meetings, progress updates, and utilizing communication tools can enhance team understanding and cohesion.

When team members communicate clearly, it promotes a supportive environment where everyone feels heard and valued, fostering a culture of collaboration that ultimately leads to successful project outcomes.

Innovation for Solutions

To foster innovative solutions in construction projects, collaboration among team members is essential for achieving effective outcomes. Creative brainstorming and out of the box thinking are key elements that drive successful problem-solving in the construction industry. When team members come together to share their diverse perspectives and ideas, new and innovative solutions emerge that may not have been apparent initially.

This collaborative approach allows for a more thorough exploration of potential options and a deeper understanding of the problem at hand. By encouraging open communication and active participation from all team members, the construction process can benefit from the collective intelligence and creativity of the group. Remember, innovation thrives in environments where collaboration is valued and nurtured.

• Embrace diverse viewpoints
• Encourage active participation
• Foster a culture of experimentation
• Value creativity and originality
• Celebrate innovative solutions

Risk Management Through Critical Thinking

Implementing critical thinking in construction projects allows for a proactive approach to risk management , enhancing decision-making processes and minimizing potential setbacks. Risk assessment plays a vital role in identifying potential hazards before they escalate into problems. By actively engaging in risk assessment, you can strategically plan for potential risks and mitigate them effectively. This proactive stance enables you to make informed decisions based on a thorough understanding of the project's risks, thereby reducing the likelihood of costly errors.

Furthermore, critical thinking empowers you to focus on problem prevention rather than just reacting to issues as they arise. Through critical analysis, you can anticipate challenges, evaluate their potential impact, and develop proactive solutions to address them before they disrupt the project timeline or budget. This approach not only saves time and resources but also fosters a more efficient construction process by minimizing disruptions and delays.

Enhancing Project Efficiency With Critical Thinking

Enhance project efficiency by leveraging critical thinking skills to streamline processes and optimize outcomes in construction projects. When applying critical thinking to project management, you can greatly improve efficiency through:

• Process Optimization: Analyze each step in your project workflow to identify bottlenecks and inefficiencies, then implement strategies to streamline these processes.
• Creative Problem Solving: Encourage thinking outside the box to come up with innovative solutions to complex issues that may arise during construction projects.
• Streamlining Operations: Evaluate the various tasks and activities involved in your project to eliminate redundancies and ensure a more efficient use of resources.
• Strategic Decision Making: Utilize critical thinking to assess different options, weigh their pros and cons, and make well-informed decisions that align with your project goals.
• Continuous Improvement: Foster a culture of ongoing evaluation and refinement, always seeking ways to enhance project efficiency through critical thinking practices.

Overcoming Challenges in Construction Projects

Overcoming challenges in construction projects demands a strategic approach to problem-solving and adaptability to unforeseen circumstances. When faced with obstacles, efficient resource allocation and effective time management are essential for successful project completion. Here is a table highlighting key strategies for overcoming challenges in construction projects:

Critical Thinking in Project Planning

When contemplating critical thinking in project planning, it's imperative to approach the process with a proactive mindset that anticipates potential challenges and opportunities for optimization. Strategic planning plays a pivotal role in project optimization, ensuring that every step is aligned with the overall goals.

Resource allocation is another critical aspect that demands meticulous attention to detail to guarantee efficiency and cost-effectiveness. Effective timeline management is essential to keep the project on track and meet deadlines without compromising quality.

Here are some key points to ponder:

• Prioritize tasks based on their impact and dependencies.
• Constantly evaluate and adjust the project plan as new information arises.
• Collaborate with stakeholders to gain diverse perspectives and insights.
• Use technology and data analysis tools to enhance decision-making processes.
• Regularly communicate progress and setbacks to maintain transparency and accountability.

Continuous Improvement Through Critical Analysis

To achieve continuous improvement in construction projects, you must focus on analyzing for efficiency, engaging in iterative problem-solving , and reflecting on the results obtained.

By scrutinizing processes and identifying areas for enhancement, you can streamline operations and boost overall project performance.

Through a cycle of critical analysis and adjustment, you pave the way for ongoing progress and success in the construction industry.

Analyzing for Efficiency

Efficiency in construction projects can be greatly enhanced through continuous critical analysis. To achieve best results, it's essential to focus on efficiency optimization and thorough problem analysis. Here are some key points to keep in mind:

• Identify Bottlenecks: Pinpoint areas causing delays or inefficiencies.
• Streamline Processes: Simplify complex procedures to save time and resources.
• Utilize Technology: Implement innovative tools for improved productivity.
• Regular Monitoring: Track progress consistently to address issues promptly.
• Feedback Integration: Encourage input from team members for diverse perspectives.

Iterative Problem-Solving

Enhancing construction project outcomes involves a continuous cycle of iterative problem-solving to drive critical analysis and foster ongoing improvement. By continuously refining problem-solving techniques, construction projects can achieve higher efficiency and effectiveness. This iterative approach allows for evaluation of strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, threats, leading to better decision-making and optimized processes.

Reflecting on Results

In critical construction projects, reflecting on results through continuous improvement is paramount for driving success and innovation. Evaluating processes and improving outcomes are essential steps to guarantee efficiency and quality in your work. Here are some key considerations to help you enhance your reflective practices:

• Embrace a growth mindset to view challenges as opportunities for improvement.
• Analyze both successes and failures to uncover valuable insights for future projects.
• Seek feedback from team members and stakeholders to gain diverse perspectives.
• Implement changes based on your evaluations to enhance overall project performance.
• Continuously refine your approach to problem-solving to achieve best results.

You have now seen the pivotal role of critical thinking in construction, from understanding complex issues to implementing innovative problem-solving techniques .

By analyzing data, collaborating effectively, and continuously improving, you can enhance project efficiency and overcome challenges.

Embrace the power of critical thinking to solve problems efficiently and drive successful construction projects forward.

Remember, in the construction industry , the ability to think critically is the key to opening up endless possibilities.

Similar Posts

Effective Communication Skills for Construction Managers"

Gain essential insights on how effective communication skills impact construction project success and team dynamics.

The Art of Negotiation: Techniques for Construction Professionals

Gain the upper hand in construction negotiations by mastering key techniques – unlock the secrets to successful outcomes!

Adapting to Change: Resilience in the Construction Industry

Get ahead in the construction industry by mastering resilience amid change – discover key strategies for success in this dynamic field.

Building and Maintaining Client Relationships in Construction

Transform your client relationships in construction with expert tips and strategies – discover the key to long-lasting success!

Ethical Leadership: Making the Right Decisions Under Pressure

Prioritize resilience and integrity in ethical leadership dilemmas, unraveling the secrets to making sound decisions under pressure.

Navigating Team Dynamics on Large Construction Projects

Discover effective strategies for enhancing team cohesion and performance on large construction projects to ensure project success.

• SUGGESTED TOPICS
• The Magazine
• Newsletters
• Managing Yourself
• Managing Teams
• Work-life Balance
• The Big Idea
• Data & Visuals
• Case Selections
• HBR Learning
• Topic Feeds
• Account Settings
• Email Preferences

A Short Guide to Building Your Team’s Critical Thinking Skills

• Matt Plummer

Critical thinking isn’t an innate skill. It can be learned.

Most employers lack an effective way to objectively assess critical thinking skills and most managers don’t know how to provide specific instruction to team members in need of becoming better thinkers. Instead, most managers employ a sink-or-swim approach, ultimately creating work-arounds to keep those who can’t figure out how to “swim” from making important decisions. But it doesn’t have to be this way. To demystify what critical thinking is and how it is developed, the author’s team turned to three research-backed models: The Halpern Critical Thinking Assessment, Pearson’s RED Critical Thinking Model, and Bloom’s Taxonomy. Using these models, they developed the Critical Thinking Roadmap, a framework that breaks critical thinking down into four measurable phases: the ability to execute, synthesize, recommend, and generate.

With critical thinking ranking among the most in-demand skills for job candidates , you would think that educational institutions would prepare candidates well to be exceptional thinkers, and employers would be adept at developing such skills in existing employees. Unfortunately, both are largely untrue.

• Matt Plummer (@mtplummer) is the founder of Zarvana, which offers online programs and coaching services to help working professionals become more productive by developing time-saving habits. Before starting Zarvana, Matt spent six years at Bain & Company spin-out, The Bridgespan Group, a strategy and management consulting firm for nonprofits, foundations, and philanthropists.  

Partner Center

FTBA 2023 Construction Conference

12 must-know construction management tips

As a construction project manager, you’ve undoubtedly experienced a number of successes and failures throughout your career. The construction industry is constantly evolving and it can be difficult to balance everything that is needed to do your job well. 

The difference between a construction manager and a successful and efficient construction manager is a specific set of skills and follow-through with how a project is managed. This article will cover key skills required for successful construction management and tips on how to successfully manage construction projects.

What skills are needed for construction management?

Construction managers should possess the following skills in order to perform their jobs to the best of their ability:

• Research and planning
• Risk assessment
• Critical thinking
• Problem-solving
• Detail-orientation
• Time management 
• Business management 
• Cost management
• Organization
• Communication skills 
• Quality management
• Technical skills

These skills are a baseline for effective project management. Below we will explain exactly how these skills can be used to improve your roles as a project manager and better manage construction projects.

Tips on how to successfully manage construction projects 

• Plan ahead 
• Be adaptable
• Budget accordingly
• Manage your time wisely
• Manage your team wisely
• Exercise patience
• Maintain good relationships
• Practice good communication
• Track everything
• Embrace automated reporting
• Use a single source of truth 
• Stay up-to-date on industry knowledge  

1. Plan ahead

One of the most powerful tips to successfully managing a construction project is to plan ahead. Construction project managers should have the foresight to anticipate what is needed and how to resolve issues that are likely to arise.

Effective project management calls for a high level of detail orientation. This skill is especially important to thoroughly review project plans and specifications and get a full understanding of the required scope of work. This in-depth review enables construction project managers to determine the types of resources required to execute the project. Resources like materials, equipment, tools, and manpower. 

Be sure to work closely with your subcontractors and suppliers in the planning stage to ensure realistic timelines and project milestones being established. 

In this early stage of a construction project, the project manager also needs to think critically to understand project risk and manage it using problem-solving techniques before finalizing the details . Blueprints and drawings are never perfect and conflicting issues will often arise between drafts and their execution. Common examples of where contradictions occur include mechanical, structural, landscape, or building code. Project managers should anticipate these issues with budgets and timelines in mind and have alternative solutions that work for everyone.

2. Be adaptable

Revisions are almost always needed as a construction project progresses. Developing new plans to get the project to completion is just part of the job. Construction managers should be adaptable and flexible enough to make these changes as they arise. Remain rigid enough to keep your project on schedule and within budget, but flexible enough to adjust project plans to keep it moving forward and avoid major delays .

3. Budget accordingly

On any given construction project, permits, materials, equipment, and wages are exchanged between multiple vendors. From the bidding process to the project closeout and billing , project managers are responsible for tracking and monitoring every cost that relates to the budget.

Look at historical project and company data to help with forecasting and budgeting. Frequently reviewing costs and tracking all transactions will help you identify budget changes that are needed as the project progresses. Consider using software that helps you balance your construction project budgets and forecast for the future. Look for a program that allows all vendors to input expenses and changes so financial disputes can be eliminated. 

Read more: How to get paid faster and eliminate payment disputes

4. Manage your time wisely

Between planning, designing, coordinating, managing, and reviewing, project managers have a lot on their plate. Construction projects are constantly evolving and new problems bubble up to the surface all the time. 

Effective time management, prioritization, and delegation skills are essential to being successful in your role and leading a project to successful completion. Use your team as a resource to coordinate and organize tasks in the most efficient and logical way possible.

5. Manage your team wisely 

In addition to managing your time wisely, you should also be managing your team’s time wisely. Use spreadsheets and lists to organize your project teams. Communicate with them often to ensure everyone is on the same page and that timelines are realistic. If there are scheduling changes, notify everyone right away. Send emails as a paper trail and follow up with phone calls if urgent.

Part of being a good leader means checking in with your team often. Is everyone feeling supported and are they free from roadblocks to complete their work on schedule? Try developing a friendly rapport with everyone on your team—including those on the ground level at the construction site. This helps people feel heard and valued and makes for faster problem solving should issues arise.  

Finally, develop a clear understanding of the duties and responsibilities of everyone working under you . This will make you a well-rounded project manager and can streamline communication and conflict resolution.

6. Exercise patience 

Construction projects don’t always go according to plan. Many issues can surface throughout the construction process that cause delays and disputes. Change orders, budget and scheduling changes, weather conditions, material or supply delays, issues with subcontractors , re-negotiations, etc. You will need to keep your cool in order to deal with each situation in the most effective and professional manner possible.

7. Maintain good relationships

Since project management requires a great deal of engagement and communication across multiple vendors and stakeholders, it is critical to maintain good relationships with everyone involved in the project. This includes your team, project owners, subcontractors, suppliers, safety inspectors, and more.

Include stakeholders as much as possible to maintain good relationships. Give them access to shareable documents, invite them to contribute and collaborate, and extend social invitations where appropriate. 

Maintaining good relationships also helps your company win bids on future construction projects. When managing client expectations, do so in an empathic and professional manner to ensure everyone’s needs are met realistically and fairly.

8. Practice good communication

As a project manager, you are constantly communicating with your project team—developers, engineers, architects, subcontractors, clients, suppliers, the municipality, rental companies, administrative staff, and safety inspectors. Effective communication with all stakeholders is key to a successful project and ensuring nothing gets missed or overlooked.

Good communication means communicating in a timely manner. If issues arise, they should be communicated to those involved as soon as possible and offer solutions to help things move forward. Consider using software platforms that enhance communication capabilities between vendors and stakeholders.  

Always maintain an environment that facilitates open, two-way communication. Let people know they can come to you with questions or concerns at any point throughout the project. Really listen to what they have to say and consider their input. People involved in the project should feel comfortable approaching you with questions at any time. Communication is a two-way process, so also be open to feedback

9. Track everything

Construction project management is a constant stream of information. Between planning, budgeting, communicating, managing, and adjusting, construction managers are at the eye of the project’s storm. On top of that, everything in the construction industry is contractual, and contracts are tied to financial obligations. If project information is not properly tracked and documented, your company is left exposed and at risk for many issues such as disputes and delays.

Tracking also allows you to clearly see project progress and identify scope creep. You can then make schedule or budget changes as needed. Just be sure to always leave that notorious paper trail and keep records organized. All communications, decisions, plans, transactions, etc. should be documented and stored in a secure—ideally digital— location. 

10. Embrace automated reporting

Construction project management requires constant distribution of spreadsheets, project progress updates, and expenses to date. If you can lean on automation to collect and populate this data instead of manually doing it yourself, you will save a significant amount of time over the course of the project and avoid the inevitable human error that comes with manual reporting. Look for programs that are designed specifically for the construction industry. This will ensure correct and accurate reporting is collected and shared with the right people.

11. Use a single source of truth

When it comes to project progress and payments, it is especially important to refer to one source of truth to avoid errors and disputes. When all vendors and stakeholders have full visibility into this information, the construction process carries on seamlessly and helps projects reach completion by their estimated deadlines. To this end, use software that is specific to your industry and allows multiple vendors the visibility, access, and control required to keep everyone up-to-date and on the same page.

12. Stay up-to-date on industry knowledge

The construction industry is constantly evolving. You will need to evolve with it to manage projects in the most efficient and effective manner. Staying up-to-date means keeping yourself informed on industry news including new materials, equipment, safety requirements, best practices, trends, and tech. 

Make a habit of checking industry news websites regularly, having open discussions with colleagues and other project managers in the industry, and keeping an ear to the ground for relevant updates. Never stop learning and teach others what you have learned so that they can grow with you. This will make you an elite construction manager and ensure that your team is supported and well-led. 

Construction software to improve project management

When looking for new construction technology, find for a management software that helps with the tips listed above. If you work with construction fleets, consider Tread . 

Tread is a construction fleet management software that:

• Improves communication between field and office
• Schedules and dispatches trucks
• Enables e-ticketing and digital sign-offs
• Tracks fleet location and driver status
• Automatically collects job data 
• Generates detailed job reports

Our cloud-based platform allows you to maintain long-standing business relationships with project stakeholders because it can be accessed by everyone involved. This offers full transparency and visibility, plus a reliable, accurate, and centralized source of truth. Tread’s capabilities help you reduce billing disputes from an average of 17% to 0%.

Request a customized demo to learn more about how Tread can make construction project management easier for you.

Top 7 Responsibilities of a Construction Fleet Manager

Companies both in and and outside the construction industry often use mobile workforces and vehicle...

What Is Construction Fleet Management?

Managing a construction company comes with many challenges. Some of the most common issues include...

Performance management in the construction industry

Construction projects are considered a success when they are completed on time and on budget, and...

• Ticketing & Timesheets
• Material Producers
• Civil Contractors
• Asphalt Millers & Pavers
• Case Studies
• Tread System Status
• Tread Terms of Use
• Work With Us

500 King Street W, 3rd Floor, Toronto, ON, M5V 1L9

Download Our Driver App

® 2023 Tread

An ASCE membership login is required to participate in discussion forums and ASCE Mentor Match. You must login to participate. 

Learning about Thrive?  View Video Tutorials here . 

Rhode Island Section

• Community Home
• Discussion 7
• Members 3.2K

Critical Thinking in Construction

By chad morrison posted 10-20-2020 01:58 pm.

Related Content

Fiu pedestrian bridge collapse - ri asce may lunchtime live stream, ri asce april dinner meeting, ri asce march dinner meeting, update on hard rock hotel collapse.

RI ASCE December Lunchtime Live Stream - RI Airport Corporation Master Plan

Privacy & terms.

Need advice? Call Now , Schedule a Meeting or Contact Us

Speak to an advisor

Our Advisors are on hand to guide you through all your options and help answer any of your queries

Call now to speak with a course advisor and take the next step in your Project Management career!

Book a free consultation with one of our Project Management experts and explore the most appropriate path for career progression.

The Role of Critical Thinking in Project Management

Project managers are drivers by nature. They are not typically satisfied to hear an issue and simply wait for resolution to come their way. Most successful PMs want to dig in and understand the problem they are facing, how it impacts their project and most importantly, how to resolve it. More often than not, however, the PM isn't the subject matter expert on the team. We rely on the knowledge and skills of others to produce project deliverables and develop solutions. The PM's role is predominantly to manage; track the issues, report the impact and facilitate resolution. It is in this facilitation where project managers can bring value and realise the benefits of critical thinking.

Critical thinking, in the simplest form, is the process of using logic and reasoning to remove bias and opinion, and fully understand a topic. Project teams can benefit greatly by operating from this fact-based viewpoint, especially considering the varied skills and responsibilities of the team members. Clarity around the facts and finely articulated specifics are less likely to create confusion, miscommunication, rework, and unnecessary stress.

Exploring the project lifecycle leads to endless opportunities for improvement by way of critical thinking as well. During project initiation, does it make sense to remove partiality from our Objective Statement? As Plan and Design progresses, should PMs challenge the status quo to ensure that more creative solutions have been considered? During the Execution Phase is clearly a great place to ensure the team is working from a foundation of fact, and the Monitoring and Controlling phase is worthless if what is being monitored is based on an individual or team bias versus relevant metrics and measurements. Clarity in all of these areas is critical and can mean the difference between success and failure.

There are several critical thinking tools in use by project managers every day, although we may not necessarily recognise them as such. These are the more basic tools, which attempt to provide a template to walk users through the critical thinking process. One example is the “5 Whys” , where the facilitator simply continues to ask why until the team has reached the root cause.

• Because my battery was dead (Contributing Cause)
• Because my dome light was left on all night (Contributing Cause)
• Because my car door was left open (Contributing Cause)
• Because the kids were playing in the car (Contributing Cause)
• Because I did not lock the doors to the car (Root Cause)

Each contributing cause is further drilled down until a final cause for an issue is discovered. Five is the typical number of questions one asks, but it can be seven or three or whatever number is needed to get through the contributing causes and focus on the root cause.

Another simple example is a Cause and Effect diagram , also known as a Fishbone or Ishikawa diagram, named so for Kaoru Ishikawa, its creator. This diagram places the general contributing factors along branching lines or “bones” on the diagram, typically items like Materials, Process, People, Equipment, Environment (although there could be others) all angled towards the output or “head” of the fishbone, which typically is the effect or problem one is trying to solve. This technique forces the team to think about all of these items individually and ask, “How could this category cause or potentially create this problem?” The tool is very helpful in organising thoughts and encouraging dialogue.

The Failure Modes and Effects Analysis (FMEA) is another example of a common critical thinking tool. Here a user lists all the potential failures a process could have, and then scores them on Severity, Occurrence and Detection. Those scores are combined into a Risk Priority Number (RPN) and each failure is ranked highest to lowest. The goal is to identify what problems may occur in a process and develop controls to mitigate the most impactful ones.

Each of these more common tools are very useful when working to get a team to think about the issues and challenges of a project. However, none of these tools will inherently get to the right answer without the appropriate thought process. As with anything, poorly thought-out inputs will lead to poor conclusions. The broader challenge then becomes, “How do we do a better job of thinking critically?”

The foundation of any critical thinking exercise rests on basic reasoning, which falls into two categories: Inductive Reasoning and Deductive Reasoning. Inductive reasoning is inherently uncertain. It’s based on and deals with probabilities, either formally, as in a statistical analysis, or informally, as in a certain person’s own experience. An example of the latter may be a six-foot-tall movie theatre patron with a child’s 12-and-under ticket. Most children 12 and under are not that tall, so it may be safe to assume that the patron is older than 12. In most cases, that would be true, but it is certainly not always the case.

Deductive reason, also referred to as “Top Down” logic, is a logical sequence of statements that are believed to be true, and if they are true, then the final statement or conclusion must be true. An example may be:

• All mammals breathe air
• Dolphins are mammals 
• Dolphins breathe air 

Top-down logic has become popular in crime stories like Sherlock Holmes, and is a great technique when the statements made are indisputably accurate. However, any use of deductive reasoning should be evaluated for validity and soundness.

Arguments can have two accurate statements, but may lead to an inaccurate conclusion.

• All birds have feathers
• Feathers allow birds to fly
• All birds can fly

Both statements leading to our conclusion may seem correct through traditional observation and logic, but clearly not all birds can fly. This is an example of an unsound argument and any time deductive reasoning is used, it should be verified and scrutinised for accuracy.

If inductive and deductive reasoning provide a roadmap on how to explore any information provided through discovery, then Socratic questioning is the means for getting to that information. Socratic questioning is one of the more widely accepted methodologies in exploring problems through logic. It is named for the Greek philosopher Socrates and his Socratic Paradox, which was “The only thing that I truly know is that I know nothing”. According to Socrates, all wisdom begins with wondering, so in order to attain such wisdom, one must admit ignorance. His approach when discussing subjects with experts in their field was to ask questions to explore the topic. He found that nothing was so much of a fact that he could not bring up counterpoints, or argue from alternate perspectives. He believed that true wisdom came from recognising that he knew nothing, so he could be open to everything.

Socratic questioning as a methodology allows users to explore complex ideas and concepts openly and directly. It exposes assumptions and opinions, and allows us to distinguish what we know from what we do not know.

There are six types of Socratic questions:

• Conceptual Clarification
• Probing Assumptions
• Probing Reason, Evidence and Rationale
• Questioning Viewpoints and Perspectives
• Probing Implications and Consequences
• Questioning the Question

Conceptual Clarification questions are the basic “Tell me more” type of questions. The user asks the team to provide more information on exactly what is being said. “Help me understand” or “what does that mean” are examples of Conceptual Clarification. The facilitator tries to delve deeper into the topic to ensure all participants are clear on exactly what is being stated and that any other potential interpretations are clarified and/or corrected. These questions will lead the team down some of the other avenues below.

A second type is Probing Assumptions . Here, the team is looking to discover the assumptions and presuppositions founding the argument, and uncover what is supported by fact. "Please explain why or how…" or "What else could we assume if…" are effective ways to draw assumptions out of a statement and lead the team down a fact-based road. Often, it is the team’s own assumptions, assumed to be fact, that guard the truth and stifle creative solutioning.

In Probing Reason, Evidence and Rationale , the PM is asking for support to an argument or perspective. Here, rather than assuming that any statements are simply true, the PM asks how they know it to be true. "How is this statement supported?" and "How do we know this?" "Is there data and can you show me?" A statement can be poorly supported by semi-related facts or simply urban legend, which, if not uncovered, will undoubtedly lead your project down a poor direction.

By Questioning Viewpoints and Perspectives , the facilitator is looking to understand the position and discover other equally valid viewpoints. One may ask "How could you look at this another way…" or "What is the difference between… and…" as ways to expose the viewpoint or alternate views. Next steps beyond that may be to explore those viewpoints for validity and application to the project. Ask what perspectives make the most sense for what the team is trying to solve.

All actions have consequences, obvious or subtle. By Probing Implications and Consequences , we may be able to uncover or identify what has actually happened or what should occur. Asking "Then what would happen…" or "If so, wouldn’t we have seen…" are excellent ways to stretch the team’s thinking around the repercussions of an act or an event and may provide evidence which could lead to additional factors.

Questioning the question is a great way to put the focus back on the facilitator and help the team feel more comfortable with how the discussion is progressing. "What am I missing?" or "Am I making sense?" allows everyone the opportunity to push back and feel less interrogated and more engaged. Additionally, the team may offer up information that the PM may not even know, supporting that the line of questioning is in fact valid, or offering up even more alternatives. This reflexive approach will help ensure that the conversation is hitting all the right points and helping get to the core issues.

Socratic Questioning is an impactful way to get to the core truth of an issue or question. It can create clarity around team member input, and help make using the more common critical thinking or root cause tools more effective and less time-consuming. These benefits make implementing critical thinking as a standard practice in your project management methodology extremely valuable.

However, as with any tool, Socratic Questioning needs to be used appropriately. It can be easy as a facilitator to focus too narrowly on the issue or statements that you are challenging and miss the human effect of the interaction. Many people, when challenged on their perspectives, take this as a personal attack (which is clearly not the intention). The most valuable exchanges of thought are done with your team members’ reactions and emotions in mind. It’s easy for a person to feel attacked in this type of discussion, so proceed with caution when challenging someone’s viewpoints.

Another challenge with critical thinking is that it does not come naturally to everyone. Most PMs will need to be taught how to think critically and effectively facilitate this type of conversation. The best way to do so, like anything else, is through practice. Practice with the team in project meetings. If in every meeting, the team members know that they will be asked these types of questions, they will begin to prepare. They will ask themselves these same types of questions before the facilitator does, which in turn develops thoughtfulness in perspectives and non-bias opinions.

Other ways to learn critical thinking skills is to practice through play with the team – logical thinking puzzles or Twenty Questions are great team builders and help sharpen the skills it takes to think laterally. Examples of these logical thinking puzzles can be found on the internet or in books. Also, learn to practise in everyday life, asking how people do the simple things that are done in their regular routines, in what order and why. Why is it done that way and what could make more sense? Opportunities to think and learn can be found in surprising places.

Of course, critical thinking in and of itself will not resolve your project issues. As a PM, the next step is to apply the appropriate project discipline to collect data, identify the most impactful action items, assign owners, set a timeline and manage progress and status. Critical thinking will only get you to that point faster and more effectively.

Developing and practising critical thinking is an effective way to help you understand the full scope of an issue, drive out solutions faster and more effectively and make the most of the tools available to tackle the big issues. This practice of asking and answering will help Project Managers add value as a leader and a facilitator, and may even be able to help the project stay on track. These are valuable skills that will help not only in managing projects, but any facet of a career.

• Certified Project Management Diploma

Get the latest news and insights in project management

• Campus Ambassador
• Apply to Lecture
• Partner with IPM
• Explore All our Courses
• Explore All our Certifications
• Corporate Training
• Project Management Software
• Join our Membership
• Publish Your Writing
• Attend our Events

Related Resources

Most Recognised Courses

Download Brochure

By clicking 'Download Brochure', you agree to our terms and privacy policy.

Thanks for downloading

Download resource.

By clicking 'Download Resource', you agree to our terms and privacy policy.

Waiting List

By clicking 'Join Waiting List', you agree to our terms and privacy policy.

We use cookies to ensure you get the best experience of our website. By clicking “Accept All”, you consent to our use of cookies.

A Systems Thinking Approach to Construction Project Management

• Conference paper
• First Online: 10 August 2019
• Cite this conference paper

• Joe Frederick Cobbinah 3 ,
• Clinton Ohis Aigbavboa 3 ,
• Wellington Didibhuku Thwala 3 &
• Kwamina Ewur Banson 4  

Included in the following conference series:

• Construction Industry Development Board Postgraduate Research Conference

2252 Accesses

Construction projects plays an important role in nation’s development. The complexity and dynamic environment of the construction industry characterized it frequent cost, time overruns, low quality, etc. for construction project management. This study therefore uses a systems thinking approach to identify the key variables that are affecting this trend. Casual loop and Systems Archetypes were used to develop systems models to determine the components and interactions between the policy and the social, environmental and economic dimensions of the industry. As demonstrated in the aforementioned CLD and archetypes, construction projects will remain to be the engine that develops and empowers the emerging and existing commercial business, housing sectors and nation building across Africa. This systems thinking approach will also provide more clarity in dealing with the complex management challenges and gradually replace the traditional theoretical approach of dealing with construction project management.

This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.

Access this chapter

Subscribe and save.

• Get 10 units per month
• Download Article/Chapter or eBook
• 1 Unit = 1 Article or 1 Chapter
• Cancel anytime
• Available as PDF
• Read on any device
• Instant download
• Own it forever
• Available as EPUB and PDF
• Compact, lightweight edition
• Dispatched in 3 to 5 business days
• Free shipping worldwide - see info

Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout

Purchases are for personal use only

Institutional subscriptions

Similar content being viewed by others

Addressing the Challenges in the Construction Industry Using a Systems Thinking Approach; A Case Study in Ghana

A framework for systemic sustainable construction industry development (SSCID)

A Study on ‘Design Thinking’ for Constructability

Hartlieb, S., Silvius, G.: Dealing with uncertainty in projects: what project management can learn from business development. Proj. Manag. Dev.–Pract. Perspect. 141 (2016)

Google Scholar  

Mir, F.A., Pinnington, A.H.: Exploring the value of project management: linking project management performance and project success. Int. J. Proj. Manage. 32 (2), 202–217 (2014)

Article   Google Scholar  

de Blois, M., Lizarralde, G., De Coninck, P.: Iterative project processes within temporary multi-organizations in construction: the self-, eco-, re-organizing projects. Proj. Manage. J. 47 (1), 27–44 (2016)

Weil, H.B., Dalton, W.J.: Risk management in complex projects. Syst. Dyn. (1992)

Debrah, Y.A., Ofori, G.: The State, skill formation and productivity enhancement in the construction industry: the case of Singapore. Int. J. Hum. Resour. Manage. 12 (2), 184–202 (2001)

Yip, B., et al.: Job burnout within the Hong Kong construction industry: a cultural perspective. In: Proceedings of the CIB W92/T23/W107 International Symposium on Procurement Systems (2005)

Nicholas, J.M., Steyn, H.: Project Management for Engineering, Business and Technology. Routledge, Abingdon (2017)

Book   Google Scholar  

Aziz, Z., et al.: Intelligent wireless web services for construction—a review of the enabling technologies. Autom. Constr. 15 (2), 113–123 (2006)

Banson, K.E., Nguyen, N.C., Bosch, O.J.: Systemic management to address the challenges facing the performance of agriculture in Africa: case study in Ghana. Syst. Res. Behav. Sci. 33 (4), 544–574 (2016)

Akadiri, P.O., Chinyio, E.A., Olomolaiye, P.O.: Design of a sustainable building: a conceptual framework for implementing sustainability in the building sector. Buildings 2 (2), 126–152 (2012)

Bosch, O., Nguyen, N.: A new approach for cross sectoral and organizational collaboration and communication to deal with increasing complexity and promote effective change. In: IUAES/AAS/ASAANZ Conference (2011)

Kerzner, H.: Project Management: A Systems Approach to Planning, Scheduling, and Controlling. Wiley, Hoboken (2017)

Banson, K.E., et al.: A systems thinking approach to address the complexity of agribusiness for sustainable development in Africa: a case study in Ghana. Syst. Res. Behav. Sci. 32 (6), 672–688 (2015)

Kim, S.: Can systems thinking actually solve sustainability challenges? Part 1, the diagnosis (2012). http://www.fusbp.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/Can-Systems-Thinking-Actually-Solve-Sustainability-Challenges.pdf . Accessed 24 Apr 2018

Doppelt, B.: Business leaders need systemic thinking for sustainability (2012). https://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/blog/business-leaders-systems-thinking-sustainability . Accessed 24 Apr 2018

Nguyen, N.C., Bosch, O.J.: A systems thinking approach to identify leverage points for sustainability: a case study in the Cat Ba Biosphere Reserve, Vietnam. Syst. Res. Behav. Sci. 30 (2), 104–115 (2012)

Sherwood, D.: Seeing the Forest for the Trees: A Manager’s Guide to Applying Systems Thinking. Nicholas Brealey Publishing, Boston (2002)

Braun, W.: The system archetypes. System 2002 , 27 (2002)

Banson, K.E., Nguyen, N.C., Bosch, O.J.: Using system archetypes to identify drivers and barriers for sustainable agriculture in Africa: a case study in Ghana. Syst. Res. Behav. Sci. 33 (1), 79–99 (2016)

Toole, T.M.: A project management causal loop diagram. In: ARCOM Twenty First Annual Conference (2005)

Senge, P.M.: The Fifth Discipline: The Art and Practice of the Learning Organization. Crown Business, New York (2006)

Bosch, O.J., et al.: Managing complex issues through evolutionary learning laboratories. Syst. Res. Behav. Sci. 30 (2), 116–135 (2013)

Sherwood, D.: Seeing the Forest for the Trees: A Manager’s Guide to Applying Systems Thinking. Nicholas Brealey Publishing, Boston (2011)

Banson, K.E., Nguyen, N.C., Bosch, O.J.: A systems thinking approach to the structure, conduct and performance of the agricultural sector in Ghana. Syst. Res. Behav. Sci. (2016)

AGI Construction Sector: What is gov’t Strategic Agenda for the construction sector? (2017). https://www.myjoyonline.com/opinion/2017/december-13th/what-is-govt-strategic-agenda-for-the-construction-sector.php . Accessed 21 Mar 2019

Download references

Acknowledgements

The authors would like to express a great gratitude to all the respondents and construction stakeholders of Ghana and Tarkoradi Technical University students of the faculty of Built for their time, willingness and contributions to this study.

Author information

Authors and affiliations.

Department of Engineering Management, University of Johannesburg, Johannesburg, South Africa

Joe Frederick Cobbinah, Clinton Ohis Aigbavboa & Wellington Didibhuku Thwala

Department of Technology Transfer Centre (TTC), Biotechnology and Nuclear Agriculture Research Institute (BNARI), Ghana Atomic Energy Commission (GAEC), Legon-Accra, Ghana

Kwamina Ewur Banson

You can also search for this author in PubMed   Google Scholar

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Joe Frederick Cobbinah .

Editor information

Editors and affiliations.

Construction management and Quantity Surveying, University of Johannesburg, Johannesburg, Gauteng, South Africa

Clinton Aigbavboa

Wellington Thwala

Rights and permissions

Reprints and permissions

Copyright information

© 2020 Springer Nature Switzerland AG

About this paper

Cite this paper.

Cobbinah, J.F., Aigbavboa, C.O., Thwala, W.D., Banson, K.E. (2020). A Systems Thinking Approach to Construction Project Management. In: Aigbavboa, C., Thwala, W. (eds) The Construction Industry in the Fourth Industrial Revolution. CIDB 2019. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-26528-1_1

Download citation

DOI : https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-26528-1_1

Published : 10 August 2019

Publisher Name : Springer, Cham

Print ISBN : 978-3-030-26527-4

Online ISBN : 978-3-030-26528-1

eBook Packages : Engineering Engineering (R0)

Share this paper

Anyone you share the following link with will be able to read this content:

Sorry, a shareable link is not currently available for this article.

Provided by the Springer Nature SharedIt content-sharing initiative

• Publish with us

Policies and ethics

• Find a journal
• Track your research

What are the Different Types of Planning in Project Management?

Can there be multiple project managers, what happens when a project goes over budget prevent it, what is a steering committee, a.k.a. steerco plus, 10 tips, what is the difference between sprint and scrum, sarah model of change: the change curve for projects, insights spotter.

What is the Role of Critical Thinking in Project Management?

Every individual has their biases, and project managers are no exception. However, thinking critically and recognising your biases are essential to have a successful project. So, what is the role of critical thinking in project management?

From the top answer, it is clear that we all have biases, but it is tough to recognise them for any individual. It requires a separate sit down with yourself and objective self-analysis. However, what could help in this process is the list of biases that each of us may have. 

Hopefully, by the end of the post, I and you will be more self-aware and will be able to make more rational decisions in your teams and organisations. Plus, we should recognise the same biases in other stakeholders and enhance our stakeholder management skills.

What is Critical Thinking?

Critical thinking is finding and understanding facts to make a decision. The goal is to be as rational as possible, critically evaluate situations and information to stay rational and find the best options. 

Still, the best school you will have is life with actual complex grey situations, where a straightforward decision is not clear. You will need to learn through: 

Why Do Project Managers Need Critical Thinking Skills?

Sometimes people associate critical thinking with being critical of something or someone. However, that is not the case, as we merely clarify the situation through open discussion or rational thought processes.

We will learn how to improve our critical thinking by asking the right questions in the first place and addressing our biases. But before that, let’s understand objectives for the project manager and critical thinking.

What Is Project Manager’s Objective with Applying Critical Thinking?

Second, we need to make sure that our messages are unambiguous. People have biases and beliefs; the last thing we need is misinterpretation and hurdles from various stakeholders. Critical thinking can help with refining communication. 

What Are Top Qualities of Critical Thinkers?

1. enhance analytical skills to become better critical thinker.

As we try to be more logical, analytical skills are essential. As a project manager or business analyst, the good news is that you have those in abundance. You only need to utilise them. Well analysed situation or constructed argument to follow a specific direction could save a project from wasted resources. 

2. Being Tolerant to Become Better Critical Thinker

3. critical thinkers need to be confident, 4. curiosity helps to be a critical thinker.

If you would like to learn about different perspectives or understand broader pictures and situations, you need to be interested. If you are not, you are unlikely to seek those answers and will just follow the status quo. A bit of curiosity might give you a more rounded solution.

5. Critical Thinkers Need to be Truth-seekers 

6. constructing a good argument to become a critical thinker.

What Are Challenges with Critical Thinking in Projects?

Time constraints for critical thinking in projects.

Critical thinking is hard work and requires time. Projects tend to be a fast-paced environment with multiple deadlines, meetings and deliverables. Sometimes you do not have time for all those second opinions, inputs from stakeholders or complex thought processes. Although you should sometimes prioritise logic and reason, you end up going with your experience, a.k.a. “gut feeling”.

Senior Stakeholders Is A Challenge For Critical Thinking

Unrealistic expectations hurst critical thinking, misunderstanding international teams or processes.

Misunderstanding is common in projects that are run internationally. Different cultures might interpret input or output unexpectedly. Also, you can have stakeholders who may not appreciate all the processes involved in various project activities. 

Challenging Norms is Difficult

Lack of knowledge .

A project can have a particular domain which is new to you. It would help if you read up about it, but sometimes it is not enough. Trying to wing it will not be the right approach as you cannot have a rational, considered point of view without understanding. It is reasonable to get outside help, like consultants or other project managers in those cases.

Not Asking a Question or the Right Question

What Are Top 10 Biases of Project Managers?

If you would like to get an exhaustive list, check out the book on amazon,  The Art of Thinking Clearly . It is a very long list, but the author gives very lovely examples interesting to listen to.

1. Planning Fallacy Impacts Your Critical Thinking

The easiest solution would be to compare your project with a similar project in the past when preparing plans and cost vs benefits analysis. I have also written two articles that help to deal with budget and timeline issues. Have a look; they both help if you end up in a bad spot in your project.

2. Confirmation Bias   Impact Your Critical Thinking

In both cases, we might overlook great options in the market that could bring more value to the business with lower costs. The best way to approach the problem is to define a very clear process that should test if a particular solution is good or bad. Then get stakeholders to approve the approach and eventually ask people to trust the results. Therefore, you have a data-driven answer.

3. Déformation Professionnelle Impact Your Critical Thinking

Also, stakeholders might only like to use one particular tool in the business. For example, they are very good with VBA code, and they want to transform data using only VBA. In contrast, Python or R might be much faster and easier to use for the same processes.

4. Anchors   Impact Your Critical Thinking

In the project, I would say it has both negative and positive effects. If you had a similar project before, you might use that information as a starting point to evaluate your current project. 

5. Availability bias Impacts Your Critical Thinking

If you are a project manager, you might have particular experience with various tools already available in the business. These might do the job well, but more suitable options are available elsewhere. You can do your research or get other people to share their take. Creating an environment where different perspectives are respected and considered can help to counter this bias.

6. Information bias Impacts Your Critical Thinking

I think the rule of thumb 80/20 works well here. Try concentrating on the 20% of information that gives you the most insights. Explain to your stakeholders the cost and benefit of getting the rest. They should appreciate that you are giving already 80% of valuable information for their decisions, and the rest might just take too much time.

7. Decision fatigue Impacts Your Critical Thinking

8. Effort Justification Impacts Your Critical Thinking

Effort justification is increasing the value of your results depending on the amount of effort you put in. The rule of thumb of 80/20 fits here as well. Most of the activities in projects (80%) will bring only 20% of the value and vice versa.

In initiatives, try to work backwards from the value you create whenever it is possible. Then only do the tasks with the given quality that still achieves the desired objective or results. Anything that does not have to be done to reach the required value, leave for later.

9. Default Effect Impact on Your Critical Thinking

If you would like to read more about dealing with such stakeholders, check out my post:  SARAH MODEL OF CHANGE: THE CHANGE CURVE FOR PROJECTS

10. Action Bias   Impacts Your Critical Thinking

Action bias is a tendency to act instead of doing nothing and observing the situation for more extended periods. People forget that choosing not to act is also an action but not as visible. 

11. Bonus: Procrastination Impact Your Critical Thinking

Procrastination could be applied to any activity. But I wanted to include it here. The project manager sometimes needs to have difficult discussions. For example, they might need to discuss additional resources with stakeholders, explain unsatisfactory progress or adjust expectations. 

Project Management Critical Thinking Hacks

We can use multiple hacks to address our inability to deal with biases efficiently. Some we have already discussed, and I will just mention them here again; some will be new. Applying these can help us to be more rational in our project delivery.

1. Critical Thinking Rules of Thumb

Use the Five Whys:  I am sure you have heard this rule, but do you apply it. If something goes wrong, do not jump to solving issues. Try to understand why did it happen by using “Five Whys”. That way, at least you will be solving the right problem.

How to be Efficient with Critical Thinking?

Unfortunately, it is tough to be rational all the time. The good news is you do not need to be. You can go with your gut feeling for those decisions that have a lower impact. Plus, if you are very knowledgeable in a particular type of project, you can also skip the complex process to ensure you are rational.

What Is the Critical Thinking Approach In Project Management?

Ok, you have booked your Workshop, and now you think about how to approach the session to get the critical thinking going? What will help is a systematic approach to understanding the problem.

1. Understanding the Core Problem

2. gathering and evaluating data.

Now that you have built some sort of hypothesis of the problem or situation, you need to prove it with data or accounts from participants. Therefore, clarifying questions to test various assumptions will build clarity and structure if you have the right individuals in the meeting. If you do not have the right individuals to answer questions, you might need to take this offline.

3. Generating and Weighing Alternatives

Check if you or the team have fallacies in the reasoning discussed openly in the group. Have you based your data on tangible investigations and facts rather than opinions?

4. Choosing The Best One

How to Uncover Stakeholder’s Biases in the Project?

Stakeholders impact your project and understanding their views, positions, and biases is also highly important to successfully deliver the project. To uncover stakeholder biases in the project, you need to ask the right questions. In general, though, looking from another person’s perspective is an excellent way to approach it. What helps to understand the beliefs are the right questions.

Current View of the World

What are prioritisation questions for critical thinking.

In the project, you have limited resources; therefore, you need to prioritise every day. Your stakeholder will want you to do everything yesterday and will put pressure to give everything now. Asking the right questions to understand the situation and uncover stakeholder fallacies could save you some tough conversations later down the line.

Why is this Significant Today? 

Why does the team or i need to be involved .

Sometimes, you may get random requests that are a bit outside your team’s scope. Do not jump blindly addressing them and discuss with stakeholders their thought processes to involve the team. Maybe they just need more information to understand where to direct the query.

Why is this the Most Critical Project for the Team?  

Critical thinking in project management conclusion.

Critical thinking is a form of balancing act as the correct answer is not always clear; you always end up somewhere midway in the thought process. It is hard to go against your biases, but it could save your project. Therefore, it is worth trying to achieve. You won’t become an expert in logic in one day, but I hope my post will get you a bit closer to keeping a rational mind where needed.

These days, business problems require data crunching and telling stories to make the right decisions. Simply put, business stakeholders  need insights into their projects and deliveries.

Latest Blog Posts

Need project manager’s help.

Check out the Fiverr marketplace if you do not have time to run your own projects or just need extra help. They do have multiple project professionals, including project managers. Maybe you will find just the right fit to take some burden from you. I have used Fiverr in the past. The prices are also not too bad. If you seek PM via the corporate route, it will be easily 5x the price.

The Lean Post / Articles / Lean Thinking in Construction: From “What” & “How” to “Why”?

Line Management

Lean Thinking in Construction: From “What” & “How” to “Why”?

April 30, 2015

"Construction is fraught with conditions of poor quality, cost overruns, and late projects," says Nick Masci of Lean Construction Institute. And in trying to improve, many people fall into the trap of an over-reliance on “tools of waste elimination” rather than a broader, principle-based approach. Read what Masci and his team are doing to shift the field's thinking.

Image courtesy of LCI New England

Construction is a dysfunctional industry fraught with conditions of poor quality, cost overruns, and late projects. We’re similar to manufacturing, too. Our work is about moving from concept to early design to engineering to production. And we even use the same lingo – value engineering, change orders, and commercialization. We’re poised and ready for radical transformation, much like the manufacturing industry was when many in the industry adopted Lean.

What to do?

Start at the beginning! Understand who our customers are and what they value. And use this as our True North . That’s exactly what the Lean Construction Institute’s New England Community of Practice recently did by inviting John Shook to one of our monthly events. John helped an audience of 65 see that “everyone in an organization has a problem to solve on behalf of creating value for the ultimate customer.” (This concept is largely lost in our industry because we are likely to be disconnected from the ultimate customer, focused on our own “means and methods.” We focus on what and how, not on why – which stifles creativity, creates animosity and hides waste.)

Some nuggets from John on how the construction industry might use Lean principles to focus on our customers and start a true transformation:

• Our industry should strive to engage in “daily practical problem solving ” where we “elevate and solve problems one by one”
• Kanban is an example of making order of non-value work with value-add work
• “As long as we are hiding problems, we will have a sick organization”

John’s comments resonated with a group of “owner” panelists that followed his remarks. The panelists we invited are owners of some of the region’s largest and most distinguished public and private organizations – and for us, they represented the customers of the construction industry. These customers told us that the process of design and construction is opaque, and blame is easy to shift. They noted that we have sharply honed our adversarial skills due to our piecemeal approach and many years of fragmentation. But – they do see lean as an overarching and potentially effective countermeasure.

Some nuggets from our customer panelists:

• “Don’t be afraid; let’s grow together” (a message from a large public enterprise to the project team that it’s better to experiment and fail than to continue our existing wasteful ways)
• “Delays to tenant occupancy change our yield. I’m willing to pull the construction stakeholders into the tenant lease so they understand value” (from a national leader in developing hi-tech lab space)
• “The slowest part of what we do is decision making. Integrated teams expose the cost of bad and slow decisions” (project director at an Ivy League school

Interactions such as these, where we share learning and barriers to creating Customer value, have generated a call to action within our LCI Community of Practice.

We are now centering our year-long learning, one month at a time, around 5 principles of Lean:

• value in the eye of the customer
• working in value streams
• maximizing flow and pull
• empowering the people in the team
• pursuing perfection

Our evening with John Shook and our other panelists was a success largely because we gained a sense of humility about where we are in our lean journey. The sense of optimism and potential in the room far outweighed any dismay about the newness of our journey.

We’re excited to see where this work takes us and would love to hear your thoughts and questions about the opportunity for lean thinking in the construction industry. Tell us below!

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

Lessons on Managing Time from the hit show, The Bear

Article by Josh Howell

Respect for People: Making the Job Easier for Workers

Case Study by David Drickhamer

Lead from the Front, Lead from Behind

Article by John Shook

Related books

The Toyota Way of Dantotsu Radical Quality Improvement (Paperback)

by Sadao Nomura

The Gold Mine Trilogy 4 Book Set

by Freddy Ballé and Michael Ballé

Related events

October 02, 2024 | In-Person (Oakland University in Rochester, MI) OR Coach-Led Online

Managing to Learn

October 15, 2024 | Coach-Led Online Course

Management Systems

Explore topics.

Stay up to date with the latest events, subscribe today.

Privacy overview.

• Construction

The Critical Path Method (CPM) in Construction Management

• Kashish Raj
• 17th June, 2024

Share this article :

Critical Path Method (CPM) is a key tool in construction management for planning, scheduling, and overseeing projects with complex timelines and task dependencies. Developed in the 1950s by DuPont and Remington Rand, CPM helps identify the longest sequence of tasks (the critical path) that determines the minimum project duration, allowing project managers to focus on activities that directly impact completion. This blog will explore CPM principles, its application in construction, real-world examples, and insights from relevant data to provide a thorough understanding of this essential project management technique.

The Critical Path Method (CPM)

It is a foundational project management technique used to pinpoint the longest sequence of dependent tasks and calculate the shortest time in which a project can be completed. It is essential for identifying critical tasks that, if delayed, would extend the project’s overall timeline. The Critical Path Method relies on detailed network diagrams that map out tasks, their durations, and dependencies, providing project managers with a visual framework to analyze workflows comprehensively. By focusing on critical tasks susceptible to delays, the Critical Path Method enables managers to streamline project timelines effectively, ensuring efficient resource allocation and timely project delivery in complex project environments like construction, management.

Key Components of the Critical Path Method

Tasks (Activities): Tasks are the specific actions required to complete a project. They should be clearly defined and manageable to ensure smooth progression. For example, in construction, tasks might include site preparation, laying foundations, and installing windows. Proper task management helps allocate resources, estimate costs, and maintain project scope.

• Duration : Duration is the estimated time to complete each task. Accurate estimation considers the task’s complexity, resource availability, and potential risks. For instance, software development tasks may be estimated based on past experiences. Correctly estimating durations ensures a realistic project timeline and budget.
• Dependencies : Dependencies define the order in which tasks must be performed, such as one task needing to finish before another starts (finish-to-start). Recognizing dependencies helps avoid bottlenecks. For example, window installation depends on the completion of building framing in construction projects.
• Critical Path : The critical path is the longest sequence of dependent tasks that determines the minimum project duration. Delays in critical path tasks directly impact the project’s completion date. Identifying this path helps prioritize tasks and allocate resources effectively to stay on schedule.
• Float (Slack) : Float, or slack, is the time a task can be delayed without affecting the project’s overall timeline. Understanding float allows flexibility in scheduling and helps manage unexpected delays. For example, a task with 3 days of float can be postponed without impacting the project deadline.

How Critical Path Method Works

Step-by-step implementation.

• Identify Tasks : List all activities required to complete the project. Tasks should be specific and clearly defined. For example, in construction, tasks might include site preparation, excavation, and electrical work. Proper task identification helps in developing a comprehensive project plan.
• Estimate Durations : Determine how long each task will take to complete. Consider factors like task complexity, resources needed, and potential risks. Techniques such as expert judgment and historical data analysis can help in providing accurate estimates, ensuring a realistic project timeline.
• Establish Dependencies : Define the relationships between tasks to determine their sequence. Dependencies like finish-to-start or start-to-start dictate the order tasks must follow. Recognizing these helps prevent bottlenecks and ensures a smooth workflow throughout the project.
• Construct Network Diagram : Create a visual representation of the project schedule, showing tasks, durations, and dependencies. Tools like Microsoft Project or Primavera can help create this diagram, which is useful for identifying the critical path and visualizing task flow.
• Calculate Early Start (ES) and Early Finish (EF) Times : Determine the earliest possible start and finish times for each task based on their dependencies. Calculating ES and EF provides insight into the earliest timeline for project completion and helps in scheduling tasks efficiently.
• Calculate Late Start (LS) and Late Finish (LF) Times : Calculate the latest start and finish times a task can have without delaying the project. These times help identify tasks with float, allowing for flexibility in scheduling and helping manage potential delays.
• Identify Critical Path : The critical path is the longest sequence of tasks that determines the minimum project duration. Tasks on this path have zero float, meaning any delay will directly affect the project’s completion date. Identifying the critical path is key for prioritizing and resource allocation.
• Monitor and Update : Continuously monitor task progress and update the CPM diagram to reflect actual progress. Regular updates help identify delays or changes needed to keep the project on schedule, ensuring successful project delivery.

Application of Critical Path Method (CPM) in Construction Management

1. Project Planning and Scheduling

Critical Path Method plays a crucial role in construction project planning and scheduling by providing a structured approach to organizing tasks and timelines. Here’s how it enhances these processes:

• Detailed Project Schedules : Critical Path Method enables construction managers to create detailed schedules that outline the sequence of tasks, their durations, and dependencies. This level of detail allows for better planning and coordination among various stakeholders, including subcontractors and suppliers.
• Sequence of Tasks : By identifying the critical path— the longest sequence of dependent tasks—Critcal Path Method helps in determining the order in which tasks must be executed to minimize project duration. For instance, tasks like foundation work typically depend on earlier tasks, such as site preparation, being completed first.
• Resource Allocation : With a clear understanding of task dependencies and durations, construction managers can effectively allocate resources such as manpower, materials, and equipment. This allocation is critical for ensuring that resources are available when needed, thereby avoiding delays and optimizing project efficiency.
• Coordination of Subcontractors : Critical Path method facilitates coordination among subcontractors by providing them with a predictable timeline and sequence of work. Subcontractors can plan their activities accordingly, reducing conflicts and potential delays.

2. Resource Allocation and Management

Efficient resource allocation is essential for keeping construction projects on schedule and within budget. Critical Path Method aids in resource management through:

• Prioritization based on Critical Path : By identifying the critical path, construction managers can prioritize resources for tasks that directly impact project timelines. Tasks on the critical path have zero float, meaning any delay in these tasks will delay the overall project completion.
• Optimization of Resources : With a detailed project schedule in place, managers can optimize the allocation of resources such as labor, materials, and equipment. This optimization minimizes idle time and ensures that resources are utilized efficiently throughout the project lifecycle.
• Resource Contingency Planning : Critical Path Method also helps in developing contingency plans for resource allocation. For example, if a critical task requires additional manpower or specialized equipment, managers can plan ahead to ensure these resources are available without disrupting the project timeline.

3. Risk Management

Risk management is crucial in construction projects, where uncertainties and unexpected events can impact timelines and costs. Critical Path Method aids in risk management by:

• Identification of Critical Tasks : Critical tasks identified through Critical Path Method are those that, if delayed, would extend the project duration. By focusing on these tasks, managers can prioritize risk assessment and mitigation efforts.
• Contingency Planning : With insights from CPM, construction managers can develop contingency plans to address potential risks associated with critical tasks. These plans may involve alternative approaches, resource reallocation, or preemptive actions to mitigate risks before they escalate.
• Scenario Analysis : CPM allows for scenario analysis, where managers can simulate the impact of different risks on the project schedule. This proactive approach helps in devising effective risk response strategies and maintaining project resilience.

4. Progress Tracking and Control

Critcal Path Method provides a structured framework for monitoring project progress and maintaining control over project timelines. Key aspects include:

• Real-Time Monitoring : Construction managers use CPM to track actual progress against the planned schedule in real-time. This monitoring helps in identifying deviations, delays, or potential bottlenecks early on.
• Comparison with Baseline Schedule : By comparing actual progress with the baseline CPM schedule, managers can assess project performance and identify areas where corrective actions are needed. This comparison enables proactive decision-making to keep the project on track.
• Issue Resolution : CPM facilitates timely issue resolution by highlighting tasks that are behind schedule or at risk of delay. Managers can allocate resources, adjust priorities, or implement corrective measures to address issues promptly and prevent further disruptions.
• Communication and Reporting : CPM enhances communication among project stakeholders by providing a clear and visual representation of project timelines. Regular progress reports based on CPM analysis ensure that all stakeholders are informed about project status and any adjustments to the schedule.

Benefits of Using Critical Path Method in Construction Management

Enhanced project planning.

Critical Path Method provides construction managers with a structured approach to project planning, ensuring that tasks are sequenced optimally for efficient execution. Benefits include:

• Detailed Roadmap : CPM creates a detailed roadmap of tasks and timelines, facilitating better planning and coordination among stakeholders.
• Optimized Sequencing : By identifying the critical path, managers can sequence tasks to minimize project duration and optimize resource utilization.
• Improved Coordination : CPM enhances coordination of subcontractors and suppliers by providing a clear timeline and sequence of work.

Improved Resource Management

Efficient resource management is crucial for controlling costs and ensuring timely project delivery. Critical Path Method supports resource management by:

• Prioritizing Critical Tasks : Managers prioritize resources for critical path tasks to minimize delays and maintain project momentum.
• Optimizing Resource Allocation : With a clear schedule, managers can allocate resources such as labor and materials efficiently throughout the project lifecycle.
• Contingency Planning : CPM enables proactive contingency planning for resource allocation, ensuring that resources are available when needed to address unforeseen challenges.

Effective Risk Management

Risk management is integral to mitigating project uncertainties and minimizing disruptions. Critical Path Method aids in risk management by:

• Identifying Critical Risks : Managers identify risks associated with critical path tasks and develop mitigation strategies to prevent delays.
• Scenario Planning : CPM allows for scenario analysis to assess the impact of risks on project schedules, enabling proactive risk response planning.
• Enhanced Decision-Making : By integrating risk analysis into project planning, managers make informed decisions to maintain project timelines and mitigate potential setbacks.

Accurate Progress Tracking

Monitoring project progress is essential for identifying issues early and implementing timely corrective actions. Critcal Path Method facilitates progress tracking by:

• Real-Time Monitoring : Managers track actual progress against the CPM schedule in real-time, enabling early detection of deviations or delays.
• Baseline Comparison : Comparing actual progress with the baseline schedule helps in evaluating project performance and adjusting plans as necessary.
• Issue Resolution : CPM supports timely issue resolution by highlighting tasks that are behind schedule or at risk, allowing managers to allocate resources and address issues promptly.

Data-Driven Insights and Trends

Integration with building information modeling (bim).

The integration of Critical Path Method with Building Information Modeling (BIM) enhances project visualization and coordination. Benefits include:

• 3D Project Visualization : BIM provides a 3D digital model of the project, complementing the 2D CPM schedule with visual insights into project components and sequencing.
• Collaboration and Communication : BIM-CMP integration improves collaboration among stakeholders by visualizing project timelines and dependencies in a comprehensive format.
• Enhanced Coordination : Stakeholders can better coordinate activities based on both the temporal sequencing from CPM and spatial information from BIM, reducing conflicts and improving project efficiency.

Use of Advanced Technologies

Technological advancements are transforming Critcal Path Method in construction management, enhancing efficiency and decision-making. Examples include:

• Artificial Intelligence (AI) : AI algorithms analyze project data to predict risks, optimize schedules, and recommend resource allocations, enhancing project planning and execution.
• Drones : Drones provide aerial surveys and real-time monitoring of construction sites, offering valuable data for CPM analysis and progress tracking.
• Real-Time Data Analytics : Analytics tools provide insights into project performance metrics, enabling managers to make data-driven decisions and adapt plans dynamically.

Sustainability and Green Building

Critical Path Method is increasingly applied to manage green building projects, integrating sustainability practices into project schedules. Benefits include:

• Green Materials Integration : CPM schedules incorporate tasks for sourcing and implementing sustainable materials, aligning project timelines with environmental goals.
• Efficiency Improvements : By optimizing task sequencing and resource allocation, CPM supports efficient use of sustainable practices and materials, minimizing environmental impact.
• Compliance and Certification : CPM ensures that tasks related to obtaining green building certifications are integrated into project schedules, facilitating compliance with environmental standards.

The Critical Path Method (CPM) is an indispensable tool in construction management, providing a systematic approach to project planning, scheduling, and control. By identifying the critical path and focusing on essential tasks, construction managers can optimize resources, manage risks effectively, and ensure project success. The integration of advanced technologies and data-driven insights further enhances the effectiveness of Critcal Path Method , enabling managers to make informed decisions and adapt to evolving project dynamics.

As the construction industry continues to evolve, the importance of Critcal Path Method in managing complex projects and achieving operational efficiency cannot be overstated. By leveraging CPM and embracing innovative technologies, construction managers can navigate challenges, minimize risks, and deliver projects on time and within budget.

Table of Contents

Ready to supercharge⚡
your projects, more from rdash.

• Gourav Gandhi
• September 26, 2024

• September 25, 2024

• September 24, 2024

RDash Videos

• Success Stories
• October 19, 2023
• October 18, 2023
• October 13, 2023

Get in Touch

Do you have any questions/queries? Or Do you have any messages for us? Simply, fill out the form and our team will get back to you within 24 hours.

+91 8826555176

[email protected].

RDash is a new age construction management platform for Developers, contractors and design studios. It enables complete workflow automation for all professionals involved in construction and interior projects management.

• Privacy Policy
• Terms of Service
• Lead Management
• Project Management
• Vendor Management
• Task Management

Quick Links

• Help Center
• Apple App Store
• Google Play

Ready to get started?

Fill out the form below and we will contact you as soon as possible.